Labels and Tags

Accountability (71) Adequate documentation (7) ADR in procurement (4) Allocation of risks (6) Best interest of government (11) Best practices (19) Best value (15) Bidder prejudice (11) Blanket purchase agreement (1) Bridge contract (2) Bundling (6) Cancellation and rejection (2) Centralized procurement structure (12) Changes during bid process (14) Clarifications vs Discussions (1) Competence (9) Competition vs Efficiency (29) Competitive position (3) Compliance (35) Conflict of interest (32) Contract administration (26) Contract disputes (4) Contract extension or modification (9) Contract formation (1) Contract interpretation (1) Contract terms (3) Contract types (6) Contract vs solicitation dispute (2) Contractor responsibility (20) Conviction (4) Cooperative purchasing (3) Corrective action (1) Cost and pricing (13) Debarment (4) Determinations (8) Determining responsibility (37) Disclosure requirements (7) Discussions during solicitation (10) Disposal of surplus property (3) Effective enforcement requirement (35) Effective procurement management (5) Effective specifications (36) Emergency procurement (14) eProcurement (5) Equitable tolling (2) Evaluation of submissions (22) Fair and equitable treatment (14) Fair and reasonable value (23) Fiscal effect of procurement (14) Frivolous protest (1) Good governance (12) Governmental functions (27) Guam (14) Guam procurement law (12) Improper influence (11) Incumbency (13) Integrity of system (31) Interested party (7) Jurisdiction (1) Justification (1) Life-cycle cost (1) Limits of government contracting (5) Lore vs Law (4) market research (7) Materiality (3) Methods of source selection (33) Mistakes (4) Models of Procurement (1) Needs assessment (11) No harm no foul? (8) Offer & acceptance (1) Other procurement links (14) Outsourcing (34) Past performance (12) Planning policy (34) Politics of procurement (52) PPPs (6) Prequalification (1) Principle of competition (95) Principles of procurement (25) Private vs public contract (17) Procurement authority (5) Procurement controversies series (79) Procurement ethics (19) Procurement fraud (31) Procurement lifecycle (9) Procurement philosophy (17) Procurement procedures (30) Procurement reform (63) Procurement theory (11) Procurement workforce (2) Procurment philosophy (6) Professionalism (17) Protest - formality (2) Protest - timing (12) Protests - general (37) Purposes and policies of procurement (11) Recusal (1) Remedies (17) Requirement for new procurement (4) Resolution of protests (4) Responsiveness (14) Restrictive specifications (5) Review procedures (13) RFQ vs RFP (1) Scope of contract (16) Settlement (2) Social preference provisions (60) Sole source (48) Sovereign immunity (3) Staffing (8) Standard commercial products (3) Standards of review (2) Standing (6) Stays and injunctions (6) Structure of procurement (1) Substantiation (9) Surety (1) Suspension (6) The procurement record (1) The role of price (10) The subject matter of procurement (23) Trade agreements vs procurement (1) Training (33) Transparency (63) Uniformity (6) Unsolicited proposals (3)
Showing posts with label Emergency procurement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Emergency procurement. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 23, 2017

Alternatives to competitive bidding, designed to save time or money, reduced accountability

New Mexico, USA

Audit: State contracts lack competition
New Mexico state procurement rules designed to ensure competition on contracts for goods and services are being circumvented unnecessarily amid exemptions that cover $6.5 billion in spending each year, the State Auditor’s Office said Tuesday. A special audit by the office of State Auditor Tim Keller found some state agencies used emergency exemptions in ways not permitted by law and that sole source contracting remains common.... New Mexico spends between $10 billion $13 billion in state funds and federal aid each year on procuring goods and services.

Health care contracts signed by the Human Services Department accounted for the bulk of exemptions to the state procurement code — more than $5 million in the fiscal year ending in June 2016.

State Auditor Tim Keller said current alternatives to competitive bidding were designed to save the state time or money, but have ended up reducing accountability in government and fairness to outside businesses. The audit also found limited oversight of political campaign contributions from contractors hired by the state.

The report recommends reforms to rein in exemptions to competitive bidding and to streamline contract approvals under a single procurement oversight authority. Agencies typically spend over six months to approve a contract, making it more likely that agencies will look for short-cuts, the audit stated.

In a letter to Keller, Department of Finance and Administration Secretary Duffy Rodriguez called the methodology behind the audit “questionable” and described as conjecture concerns about the general overuse of non-competitive procurement. Keller said, “We’re supposed to protect against pay-to-play and fraud, waste and abuse, and also I think just be accountable for where those dollars are going. What our audit showed is that, by and large, for billions of dollars, we are not doing that in one way or another. We’re either violating our own laws or we’re not tracking the data.”

Auditor’s report reveals state overreliance on no-bid contracts
The study, to be formally released Tuesday, found state agencies, in violation of the government procurement law, used emergency exemptions from purchasing rules when there was no urgency to bypass the competitive bidding process.

The Auditor’s Office reviewed 11 small contracts, too. Less oversight is required for purchases of less than $60,000 in many cases, but the report found a state agency amending small contracts several times to include much larger sums.

The report examined 13 larger sole-source contracts and found 10 did not meet the state’s rules for such purchases. The State Auditor’s Office said agencies are skipping the competitive bidding process out of convenience and based on assumptions about price. The report also examined 14 emergency purchases and found only three fit the definition of an emergency; an agency said it needed to fix what the report described as a contamination issue even though the agency had learned of the issue one year earlier.

State Auditor Tim Keller said the study’s findings show a government too reliant on contracts that are not put out to bid, as well as a purchasing system that is complex, decentralized and rife with loopholes. “The spirit of procurement is to safeguard tax dollar funded contracting from fraud, waste and abuse,” Keller said in a statement. “Strong directive executive leadership and a reworking of the law to make bidding more effective and efficient would have a game-changing impact on creating local jobs, cutting red tape, and providing essential services to New Mexicans at the best value.”

The biggest share of state spending outside the usual purchasing process goes to goods and services that are bought by one state agency from another or from a local government. Those purchases are usually exempt from competitive bidding. And certain health care spending, a major expense for the state, also falls under what is known as “sole source procurement,” which is when an agency gives the contract to one company without competitive bids.

State agencies can buy goods and services from private companies without a competitive, open bidding process only when one company sells a particular product or an emergency requires officials to move quicker than the time it takes for competitive bids. However, agencies must make an effort to find other vendors and detail the reasons for an emergency. The state’s rules warn that agencies are not supposed to bypass the usual purchasing process because staff believes one particular option is best or the least expensive.

The report raised concerns that the General Services Department and the Department of Finance and Administration “do not always provide adequate scrutiny.” As a result, the report said, agencies can get away with no-bid contracts that do not meet the state’s rules.

The State Auditor’s Office suggested consolidating oversight of the purchasing process, which the Legislative Finance Committee has long recommended. The report also called for additional training of all state personnel involved in procurement and suggested legislators comprehensively review the exemptions and exceptions in the state’s purchasing law.

Sen. Sander Rue, R-Albuquerque, has sponsored legislation reforming the procurement process but said lawmakers may need to revisit the language of the current rules. Rue said the state should open up the process even further by, for example, making public how officials choose winning contracts.

“The more transparent and open procurement is,” he said, “the less you are to have mistakes, errors and perhaps mischief.”
Note: New Mexico is one of a couple of dozen states, including the Territory of Guam, that use the principals and are guided by the processes of the ABA Model Procurement Code.

Sunday, June 11, 2017

Procurement controversy du jour - PI seeks to expand emergency procurement before and after emergency

New purchase rules eyed during crises
Speaker Pantaleon Alvarez has filed a bill proposing to loosen restrictions on negotiated procurement in cases of “extreme urgency and necessity,” and allow the government to skip public bidding in purchasing cheaper goods. House Bill No. 5521 seeks to amend several provisions of Republic Act No. 9184 or the Government Procurement Reform Act, which was enacted in 2003.

The (current) law considers negotiated procurement and direct contracting as alternative procurement methods to public bidding. The former (negotiated procurement) refers to the method used in extraordinary circumstances such as during the failure of bidding and in times of emergency.

Under Alvarez’ bill, negotiated procurement will be allowed “before, during, or after a calamity.” Currently, this mode is applicable “during a state of calamity,” which requires an actual declaration by the affected government unit.

Alvarez said that current regulations “unduly delay and hamstring the delivery of services” in times of calamity.

The proposed measure also provides for an additional criteria to resort to direct contracting, which currently sees the agency ask for a price quotation from the exclusive supplier of goods of critical or proprietary nature.

Read more: http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/904623/new-purchase-rules-eyed-during-crises#ixzz4jkiZKcEF
Sounds like a step onto a slippery slope to a procurement system without accountability, competition, transparency or integrity, as I've illustrated before: When corners are cut, even for great reasons (e.g., war), the way is opened for fraud. Also, refer to the tags/labels associated with this post, just below.

Monday, June 5, 2017

No emergency, just a desire to act quickly, like business

The procurement issues here raise issues of noncompetitive acquisitions, the requirement to obtain a fair and reasonable price before acquiring anything, even by sole source, and the contrast between government acquisition and private business. Government contracting requires market research to have independent knowledge of source alternatives in the market, prices and costs, as part of the acquisition process before a selection process is even chosen.

The governance policies of government acquisition are intended to assure transparency and the pursuit of effective competition within the free enterprise system. It is meant to avoid the secretive and arbitrary selection of colleagues and strong-arm "horse trading" linked to matters far afield from the instant acquisition that is the norm in private business ("you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours").

Government procurement is concerned with public confidence, fair and equitable treatment of market participants, maximization of public funds, and safeguards to establish and maintain a contracting system of integrity with accountability to the public. It's not meant to trade products or services for votes or favors or other "godfather offers".

In these respects, government procurement is intentionally designed to be the antithesis of private business, especially private business whose only concern is the welfare of the business owner. Not that there is anything wrong with that in the context of people betting their own money in their own smoke-filled rooms or out on the golf course or the box seat of some entertainment venue. 

But, private business has no concern about other people's money, whereas government must be concerned with other people's money or face a fractious public, as well as a mutinous supply of vendors. 
 
Again, I advise readers of articles I present to read the articles themselves, at the link provided. I omit, rearrange, slice, dice, paraphrase, editorialize and generally use the general fact situation of articles to provide teachable moments concerning procurement practice and principle. My version may or may not reflect the article's author's intent, and likely do not to my re-working of the following story, so read the original; click the link at the title.


No competition, no cost estimate as Kansas City firm picked for coveted VA contract McClatchy Washington Bureau
The federal government typically awards contracts to private companies after a competitive bidding process in order to keep costs low and avoid conflicts of interest. “When you have competitive bidding it prevents government officials from throwing contracts to their friends or keeping them from people they don’t like,” said Richard Painter, chairman of the board of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, a nonpartisan watchdog group.

But, the Trump administration picked Kansas City-based Cerner Corp. for a coveted contract to modernize veterans health records, and there will be no competition for the taxpayer-funded project. Cerner partnered with defense technology contractor Leidos, Accenture Federal Services and Intermountain Healthcare in its bid for the $4.3 billion, 10-year defense contract. Other health IT companies didn’t have a chance.

VA Secretary David Shulkin told reporters his decision to waive competition and acquire Cerner’s software directly was motivated by President Donald Trump’s desire to act quickly. “From the outset that when the president selected me to be secretary, he made clear to me that he expected us to act with faster decisions, to act like business, and to really make sure that we are really doing the right thing to change veterans’ health care. And that's exactly what we’re trying to do today,” Shulkin said.

Shulkin said there was a “public interest exception” to allow awarding the Cerner contract without a “full and open competition.” The VA still must draw up a justification for waiving open and public competition, and Tester’s office will be following up with VA for those documents, said his spokesman, Dave Kuntz.

Sen. Jon Tester of Montana, the top Democrat on Senate’s Veterans Affairs Committee, was supportive of Shulkin’s announcement but his spokesman said he has some questions and concerns about timing and costs that the secretary did not answer. Neither Cerner nor the Department of Veterans Affairs could say how much the contract will cost, however.

“The challenge here is that by giving up competition, the VA has given up all control to the company” when it comes to price, said Phillip Carter, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security who teaches government contracts law at Georgetown University Law Center. “At the end of the day ... they’re probably going to pay whatever Cerner asks,” Carter said.

The new VA health records system won’t be identical to the Defense Department’s, but its core will be Cerner’s Millennium software, Shulkin said on Monday. He said Cerner’s work on the Pentagon’s system, now known as MHS Genesis, pushed his decision in Cerner’s favor. Adoption of the same system “will ultimately result in all patient data residing in one common system,” the secretary said.
To me, adopting a system that will ultimately result in "all data residing in one common" (but proprietary) software will assure everyone else will become locked out. There are historical precedents, such as Motorola's lock on emergency radio systems, and Microsoft's lock on desktop software systems. See, Sure, Kid, first one's free.


The US government has been trying hard to break free of such locks.  This procurement seems to also go against the US Government's Federal Source Code Policy: Achieving Efficiency, Transparency, and Innovation through Reusable and Open Source Software:
When Federal agencies are unable to identify an existing Federal or commercial software solution that satisfies their specific needs, they may choose to develop a custom software solution on their own or pay for its development. When agencies procure custom-developed source code, however, they do not necessarily make their new code (source code or code) broadly available for Federal Government-wide reuse.

Even when agencies are in a position to make their source code available on a Government-wide basis, they do not make such code available to other agencies in a consistent manner. In some cases, agencies may even have difficulty establishing that the software was produced in the performance of a Federal Government contract.
These challenges may result in duplicative acquisitions for substantially similar code and an inefficient use of taxpayer dollars.

This policy seeks to address these challenges by ensuring that new custom-developed Federal source code be made broadly available for reuse across the Federal Government. This is consistent with the Digital Government Strategy’s “Shared Platform” approach, which enables Federal employees to work together—both within and across agencies—to reduce costs, streamline development, apply uniform standards, and ensure consistency in creating and delivering information. Enhanced reuse of custom-developed code across the Federal Government can have significant benefits for American taxpayers, including decreasing duplicative costs for the same code and reducing Federal vendor lock-in.
Note also the internationally informed Open Source for Government component of the Open Spouse Initiative.

Other article(s) on this topic: VA to dump Vista for DOD's electronic health record system











Wednesday, May 3, 2017

Foreseeability and time to plan before acting vitiates emergency procurement

Homelessness, like poverty, is always with us. It is a perennial issue of municipal governance and a cold, hard reality. There are social service agencies who are expected to deal with social issues. Such issues are not emergencies in and of themselves, even when they turn from invisible to visible. 

Turning a blind eye to a known problem is simply a failure to attend to a responsibility; suddenly having eyes wide open is incentive to deal with the problem, but it's not an emergency. It's something you chose, or "prioritized", to do nothing about, and now you feel compelled by headlines to do something about it.  

Urgency is not emergency when it comes to playing fast and loose with public money by doing an end around normal prudent procurement procedures. 

Tacoma considers declaring homeless state of emergency
The Tacoma City mayor proposed declaring a state of emergency on homelessness in the city.

“It is something that is happening in every single neighborhood, and the reality of homeless is, it’s not a new issue” said Tacoma Mayor Marilyn Strickland, "but it becomes a new issue when it becomes visible."

“This is going to require us to take an approach we haven’t taken before," said Strickland. “We want to form a cross function team to explore what it takes to declare an emergency. We may have the ability to waive procurement rules.”
Tacoma’s homelessness crisis needs an emergency solution, mayor says
The homelessness issue in Tacoma, the county and the region is well-documented. It’s rare a few days go by lately that homelessness goes without mention in local media.

“Our goal here is to make sure that no one who’s in Tacoma has to sleep on a street, in a park, beneath an overpass or outside, and the message we want to send is help is available,” Strickland said Tuesday.

“Now we have to figure out what that means, because the questions we have to answer for folks if we’re clearing out encampments is where do I go then? We have to have an answer to where do I go and we don’t have that answer right now, and we know it’s a very complicated, complex problem.”

While that means getting homeless people access to medical care, food, housing services and emergency shelter, the mayor said, it also means the city needs to enforce against illegal activities that are taking place, such as blatant and public drug use. Pauli said the city wants to find an approach that will also mitigate the impacts of homelessness on residents and neighbors.

The city will have to explore some potential new ways to address homelessness, she said, and short-term solutions could range from tent cities, to adding more affordable housing, and creating emergency shelters. Declaring an emergency would allow the city to fast track some of its processes in getting those plans into place, Strickland said.
The city obviously has seen this issue growing, and has had plenty of time to plan for a solution. And they are still perplexed as to what the solution will be. They hope to avoid planning by cutting spending corners while they are still trying to understand the problem: "we don’t have that answer right now, and we know it’s a very complicated, complex problem."  

Good luck with that.  Hurry up and do something is a political response, not a responsible management response.

Urgency is not an emergency when it comes to procurement. Procurement starts with identifying a particular need, and planning to acquire and mobilize a solution to address the need. Failure to plan and act in a timely manner is never an excuse to cut corners with government spending. 

Emergency procurement trades off good governance procedures for immediate action in the face of genuine disasters.  Graft, waste and excessive costs are the typical result of emergency procurements even when the emergency is genuine (think Hurricane Katrina), and should be avoided unless uniquely necessary.

Guam law allows emergency procurement, but it is defined and conditions are put on it. Not every so-called "emergency" qualifies for the expedited emergency procurement process. The definition is particularly pertinent to this case study:
Emergency means a condition posing an imminent threat to public health, welfare, or safety which could not have been foreseen through the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures, and which cannot be addressed by other procurement methods of source selection. (5 Guam Code Annotated § 5030(x))

BUT WAIT, THERE'S MORE:  Friday, May 5, from Guam

The Pacific Daily News has a similar tale to tell in an article and its editorial. But, there seem to be more than a few in the government and media who "get it". 

In the face of student protests and other bad publicity, while one member of the Board of Education wants the Governor to issue an emergency declaration to fix a long-standing maintenance problem at a local high school, the PDN editorial board stands calmly and responsibly in favor of doing "the procurement process correctly.... That's where lawmakers and the administration need to focus their efforts." 

At last, there are responsible adults engaging in the problem solving.

Emergency declaration for Sanchez High eyed to get $1M for 2-year plan
The facilities at Simon Sanchez High School are in such poor condition the school will need an extra $1 million during the next couple of years to make necessary repairs and to ensure there are enough classrooms for students, according to education officials.

Maria Gutierrez, vice chairwoman of the Guam Education Board, said asking the governor for an emergency declaration is among the options to avoid double sessions at Simon Sanchez next school year. Double sessions mean students would attend school in two shifts.

Sen. Joe San Agustin, chairman of the legislative committee on education, asked for a two-year interim plan for Sanchez High, including funding requirements. The education board said it will be presenting the plan to San Agustin shortly. Ada said he hopes senators will introduce separate legislation to help repair the school.

On Monday, the public auditor is scheduled to hold a hearing on Core Tech’s procurement appeal of the request for proposals to rebuild the campus.
OUR VIEW: Speed up construction of new Simon Sanchez High
The school has been in a state of disrepair for years. It was shut down temporarily in 2013 because of safety issues. Just two years later, there were health and safety violations that should have closed it again, but Public Health said it would work with the school system to keep it open. The following year, some of the needed improvements still weren’t made.

There’s $100 million set aside to rebuild Sanchez High, and to make repairs at other public schools. But procurement protests and problems have repeatedly stalled the project.

Now senators want a two-year plan from the Guam Department of Education that addresses structural problems at the school. Sen. Joe San Agustin said the Legislature will help identify funding sources for repairs, but needs cost estimates.

“We would want DOE to give us an estimate of how much they would need for temporary repairs so that students and teachers can still use Simon Sanchez safely, while procurement is still ongoing,” he said.

But the money for a new Sanchez High is there. What’s needed is for GovGuam to do the procurement process correctly, so there are no further protests and the project can proceed. That’s where lawmakers and the administration need to focus their efforts.









Thursday, August 20, 2015

A counterproductive way to deal with emergency no-bid acquisitions

New board approves millions in no-bid contracts (Read full story at the link)
The revamped Personal Services Contract Review Board is part of a contracting reform bill the state Legislature passed this year after much debate, with the Senate watering down sweeping House proposals.
It appears the Legislature, in its wrangling over contract reform, may have inadvertently given agencies a potential out on competitive bidding.

Numerous agencies requesting approval of contracts and exemptions from bidding quoted the new law that allows exemption if “utilization of a competitive bid procurement would have been counterproductive to the business of the agency.” Now agencies appear to be using it as their reasoning for not competitively bidding contracts.

The legislation was driven by a Mississippi Department of Corrections bribery and kickback scandal. Former state Corrections Commissioner Chris Epps ran one of the largest and longest-running criminal conspiracies in state history. He took about two million in bribes over eight years in exchange for steering hundreds of millions of dollars in prison contracts to a former lawmaker co-conspirator.

The contracts subject to Epps’ malfeasance had been approved by the state Personal Services Contract Review Board. After the prisons bribery scandal, state leaders — and a task force created by Gov. Phil Bryant to recommend reform — criticized agencies’ use of “emergency contracts,” exempt from bidding, for goods and services that did not appear to be emergencies.

The reform legislation revamped the board to include citizen members appointed by the governor and lieutenant governor. The board, holding its second monthly meeting Tuesday, has only four members because Lt. Gov. Tate Reeves has not filled his appointments. The directors of the State Personnel Board and Department of Finance and Administration also serve on the board.

On Tuesday, the PSCRB questioned numerous “emergency” contracts approved by agencies, including two recently inked by MDOC worth more than $60 million combined. MDOC entered into an $11.6 million emergency contract with Valley Services for feeding inmates and a $48.8 million one with Centurion of Mississippi for medical services for inmates. Both are for a year.

New board member Bill Moran of Tupelo questioned why feeding inmates and providing medical care were deemed emergencies and the contracts not put out for bid. “Why can’t you at least take the time to get RFPs?” Moran said. “This is $60 million, and nobody’s put a pencil to it. Have you not had time to do that?”

Stanley Brooks, MDOC director of prison agriculture enterprises, said the agency did attempt to get quotes but ran into problems with the previous PSCRB and the contracts were running out, so feeding and caring for inmates became an emergency. At the board’s direction, Brooks said MDOC would try to quickly get RFPs from vendors — within a couple of months — and can back out of the emergency contracts with a month’s notice.

Moran also questioned several emergency contracts worth more than $200,000 from the state Oil and Gas Board — extensions to previous emergency contracts — for companies to plug and abandon oil and gas wells. “How is it an emergency when these wells have been sitting there for years?” Moran said.


House Accountability, Efficiency and Transparency Chairman Jerry Turner, who authored the House reform bill, said this is the result of the Senate stripping out much of the House plan before it passed the bill. Turner said the new board has the authority to establish tougher rules and regulations on bidding and emergency contracts and to force state agencies to seek best prices. He said he hopes it will. “But if they can’t, we can go back in the Legislature and put new language in there,” Turner said. “We are not going to sit by and watch all those problems we’ve had still be allowed because of misinterpretation of the language.”
I might note, Guam procurement law (5 GCA § 5030(x)) defines "emergency" as:
"a condition posing an imminent threat to public health, welfare, or safety which could not have been foreseen through the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures, and which cannot be addressed by other procurement methods of source selection."

Tuesday, August 4, 2015

The FEMA bone is connected to the hip-pocket bone

Report: El Paso County agency did not follow protocol when awarding disaster contracts
Federal regulators frequently find issues with contracts awarded during disasters, and sometimes rescind grants if bidding protocol is not followed, said Marilyn Gally, who helps local governments apply for FEMA aid through the CDHSEM. In Colorado, as elsewhere, audits have found that cities tend to rely on pre-established contracts to handle disaster repairs when the projects should be open to competitive bidding, Gally said. Particularly during the chaos of a disaster, agencies don't record their hiring decisions, which can cost them federal reimbursement money, Gally said.

"The procurement part is probably our biggest ongoing challenge to make sure that applicants are following all of those rules," said Kevin Klein, director of the Colorado Division of Homeland Security and Emergency Management (CDHSEM).

Audits are routine when FEMA allocates disaster recovery funding, DeFelice said. In recent years, Colorado has been subject to a several audits, including one released in June that recommended Boulder County return $2.5 million of FEMA funds that it didn't use for recovery from September 2013 floods.

Two years after the Black Forest fire, potential issues with Mountain View's contracts serve as a good lesson to local agencies applying for federal aid after El Paso County's latest federally recognized disaster - spring flooding. Rains in May and June caused more than $24 million in damage across the county, most of which local officials hope will be eligible for federal reimbursement.

During a Monday information session in Colorado Springs, Gally cautioned a packed room of county agencies to get at least two bids for every contract, even in the heat of an emergency. While skipping a bidding process might sometimes be necessary when safety is a concern, "we don't encourage it," Gally said.

"I'd prefer you just didn't resurface contracts," Gally told the audience.

Mountain View Electric Association oversees power to eight of Colorado's southern and eastern counties, including eastern regions of El Paso County. In 2013, the Black Forest fire destroyed 488 homes and damaged 25 miles of overhead power lines that. During the first year after the fire, the association spent about $7.4 million repairing lines and restoring power to hundreds of neighborhoods in Black Forest, according to the report. About $2.9 million went to removing thousands of dead trees around the lines.

All of the projects were approved by FEMA, an approval which promised to bring reimbursement for 75 percent of the projects' costs, if auditors found no issues with the work.

The need for competitive bidding is typically waived when agencies and cities respond to ongoing disasters, the report said. FEMA can grant exceptions to procurement standards, and the agency has no problem if municipalities skip bidding processes for emergency repairs if there is an existing contract for that scope of work, Gally said. But all other projects - those not deemed essential to saving lives and property or do not have existing scope-of-work contracts - should be subject to competitive, well-documented bidding that also considers minority-run or women's businesses, according to federal regulations.

All of these requirements were violated by Mountain View, the report found.

In the first month following the fire, Mountain View did not use competitive bidding to find a contractor to restore power to 250 homes that had survived the blaze. This was an acceptable time to waive competitive bidding, the federal report said. But when Mountain View hired a contractor to restore power to hundreds of destroyed homes in the year after the fire, it relied on a contractor that handled maintenance work for the company before the fire and did not conduct open bidding. Work to remove 19,367 trees near power lines was subject to competitive bidding, but the process did not take into account minority businesses, the report found.

The report claimed that part of the problem in Colorado stems from the state, which is charged with monitoring the procurement processes and making sure federal requirements are being met. While the state did offer education to agencies applying for FEMA money, it did not follow up with Mountain View to make sure that the awarded contracts would pass federal scrutiny, the report said.
Read the whole article at the link above.

See related: When corners are cut, even for great reasons (e.g., war), the way is opened for fraud

Thursday, May 8, 2014

Emergencies: man made vs natural

Deval Patrick Awards Emergency Contract to Save Massachusetts Health Connector
Gov. Deval Patrick's administration will invoke emergency rules — reserved for “an unforeseen crisis” — to sidestep the state’s procurement laws and award a lucrative, no-bid Obama­care contract to Minnesota-based Optum to salvage the disastrous state exchange, the Herald has learned.

Health Connector spokes­man Jason Lefferts said the state is executing the unusual crisis clause “to avoid substantial harm to the functioning of government ... and since the health, welfare or safety of citizens of the Commonwealth is threatened without a functioning (state Obamacare exchange).”

But former state Inspector General Gregory Sullivan said the Patrick administration is abusing the emergency language. “It wasn’t unforeseeable,” said Sullivan, now at the Pioneer Institute. “It was just denied by the administration for months. The administration was well aware of the fact that the Connector project was behind schedule, over-­budget and dysfunctional ... I wouldn’t call this an emergency, and I think it should be competitively procured so everyone has a chance to bid.”
There's obviously more to the story, including what is available in the article at the link, but this snippet is all that is necessary to ask the question, what is an emergency in the context of procurement law?

The first and most obvious point must be made that procurement law is not universal, so your own applicable law must be examined. Thus, without knowing anything about Massachusetts law, you would want to see what "an unforeseen crisis" means, if that is the statutory language as mentioned in the article.

The second point I would make is that that word "emergency" does not mean what many executives believe it means. In my experience on Guam, the emergency procurement method of source selection view with sole source selection as the most abused method of source selection in the book.

Guam's Procurement Act uses the ABA Model Procurement Code as its base, as I've mentioned many times. Guam's emergency procurement provision (method of source selection requirements) is at 5 GCA § 5215. Guam's provision goes into greater detail that the Model Code (§ 3-206), but contains the exact same general requirement:
"Notwithstanding any other provision of this Chapter, the Chief Procurement Officer, ... the head of a purchasing agency, or a designee of either officer may make or authorize others to make emergency procurements when there exists a threat to public health, welfare, or safety under emergency conditions as defined in regulations ...; provided that such emergency procurements shall be made with such competition as is practicable under the circumstances...."
Note carefully that an emergency is not a situation where there "exists a threat to public health, welfare, or safety". Most issues government deals with concern situations where there exists a threat to public health, welfare or safety. The key is the "emergency conditions".

So what is an "emergency"? Here, the ABA Model Code regulation and Guam law (and regulation) differ somewhat.

The ABA Regulation (§ R3-206.01) defines "emergency conditions" as "a situation which creates a threat to public health, welfare, or safety such as may arise by reason of floods, epidemics, riots, equipment failures, or such other reason as may be proclaimed.... The existence of such condition creates an immediate and serious need...." § R3206-02 limits the quantity of supplies, services or construction items to that which is "necessary to meet the emergency", and § R3-206.03 provides a dollar limit on the amount of money that may be spent on an emergency procurement ($25,000 is suggested as an example), and requires approval from the highest procurement official in the jurisdiction.

Guam law differs most substantially from the Model Code in its definition of emergency to rule out man made "emergencies". Comment 3 to the Model Code allows emergency procurement to possibly be justified "because all bids submitted under the competitive sealed bid method are unreasonable, and there is no time to re-solicit...." Thus, the Model Code seems to justify an emergency procurement which was not planned sufficiently in advance of need to account for glitches in the solicitation. One such glitch would be a protest, but the comment itself does not contemplate that kind of routine glitch, only the glitch where all bids are unreasonably priced (a situation often observed in emergency conditions).

This suggests, then, that an emergency must not only affect health, welfare and safety but must be unforeseeable. Guam law specifically mentions this. 5 GCA § 5030 defines "emergency" to mean, in relevant part, "a condition posing an imminent threat to public health, welfare, or safety which could not have been foreseen through the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures". It does not provide the descriptive terminology of the Model Code, "such as may arise by reason of floods, epidemics, riots, equipment failures, or such other reason as may be proclaimed". Under Guam law, for instance, an equipment failure would not justify an emergency procurement if it could have been "foreseen through the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures".

Planning is the first of the four main principles of management (see, as one basic statement example of this notion The Foundation of Management; there are plenty of other more scholarly expositions -- indeed entire texts as studied in business management classes). At the US federal level, extensive guidance is given for procurement execution in the Federal Acquisition Regulations, beginning with FAR Part 7 (Acquisition Plans), with reference to Parts 10 (Market Research) and 11 (Describing Agency Needs). Guam law does not deal with these matters, so the FAR provides useful guidance on best practices in executing the planning principle.

Guam law does provide a planning principle, however, broadly specified in 5 GCA § 5010 (Policy in Favor of Planned Procurement). The policy is expressed in the statement, "All procurements of supplies and services shall, where possible, be made sufficiently in advance of need for delivery or performance to promote maximum competition and good management of resources." This statement is broad enough to encompass procurements conducted by the emergency method of source selection.

It is notable that this provision contemplates the use of competitive "bidding" even in emergency conditions. It says, "Except in emergency situations, lower price bids are generally preferable to shorten delivery or performance bids." In emergency procurement (§ 5215), the minimal requirement is the solicitation of at least three informal price quotations. Thus, Guam law would provide an emergency competitive sealed bid wherein price would be of secondary consideration to delivery time in appropriate circumstances (including the price and time differentials specified in § 5010).

There have been many instances of abused emergency procurements in Guam over the years, including serial/rolling monthly "emergencies" specifically excluded by § 5125 of the law. ("No emergency procurement or combination of emergency procurements may be made for an amount of goods or supplies greater than the amount of such goods and supplies which is necessary to meet an emergency for the thirty (30) day period immediately following the procurement.)

The similarity in these instances with the Massachusetts article above is that such abuse requires the tacit connivance of the Governor. On Guam "In addition to any other requirement, the Governor must approve in writing all authorizations for emergency procurement." But the Guam Legislature has also condoned and facilitated emergency procurement that failed to meet the definition of emergency, through special legislation, as reported by the Guam Public Auditor. The controversy arose from legislation passed to allow fire trucks to be procured outside the bounds of the procurement law. The Auditor's Report described the situation, and her response to what transpired:
In December 2003, the GFD Chief (Chief) requested and received an emergency declaration for the purchase of three fire trucks. In two days, the emergency purchase was awarded to Mid-Pacific Far East for $734,913. Morrico Equipment Corporation (Morrico), another local fire truck distributor, protested the emergency purchase and a lawsuit followed. In March 2004, the Superior Court of Guam issued a preliminary injunction (Civil Case No. CV0152-04) in favor of Morrico and GSA was enjoined from taking any actions to procure the fire trucks. The court further found that “the written determination of emergency by the Guam General Services Agency and the Guam Fire Department dated December 31, 2003, failed to comply with requirements of 5 G.C.A. §5425 for the procurement of Fire Trucks in this case and any actions taken in furtherance of the procurement is void pursuant to §5425(g).” To date, there have been no further proceedings on this case.

In June 2004, the Chief testified on Bill 295, which would appropriate $600,000 and waive procurement requirements for the emergency purchase of fire trucks. In his written testimony, the Chief did not disclose the preliminary injunction. Bill 295 was signed by the Governor and became Public Law 27-99; however, the Governor raised concern on Public Law 27-99 that GFD and GSA lacked guidance to make the necessary procurement because it waived all methods of procurement.

In September 2004, GSA issued requests for quotation for the purchase of fire trucks to three local vendors: Mid-Pacific Far East, International Equipment of Guam, and Morrico. GSA allowed only four days for the three vendors to respond to over 100 pages of specifications. Mid-Pacific Far East was the only vendor to submit a price proposal in the four-day time period allotted.

Four days for vendors to respond to over 100 pages of specifications was unreasonably short.

GFD has not been provided a consistent source of funding to replace fire trucks and ambulances. Because of this lack of consistent funding, GFD has had to resort to emergency requests whenever the number of fire trucks and ambulances are precariously low. The passage of P.L 27-99 permitted GFD to purchase two fire trucks without conforming to standard procurement practices, thus, setting a precedent allowing emergency purchases to be obtained without following emergency procurement regulations.

We recognize the Government of Guam’s current financial difficulty, unless a consistent funding source is provided to GFD for the purchase of necessary emergency vehicles and equipment, GFD will continue to resort to emergency requests for these purchases. We urge the Legislature to discontinue passing legislation that waives procurement regulations of any purchase. Even the Governor raised concern over the lack of procurement procedures in P.L. 27-99. We recommend that GFD develop a 5-year and 10-year capital replacement plan and submit the plans to the Legislature to ensure that GFD receives the needed funding for the purchase, maintenance and upkeep of its emergency vehicles and equipment.
There are many principles of procurement, including the fostering of competition to achieve maximum economic benefit to meet the basic needs of the public, and providing fairness, equal treatment, transparency and accountability -- and insisting on planning and other prudent management techniques. But to some extent many of them, in certain cases, conflict. We can insist on efficiency, for instance, at the expense of transparency and accountability.

The principle of planning is intended to ameliorate inefficiency. If we are going to excuse inefficiency, by for example resorting to emergency procurement of supplies or services whose need was well foreseeable, we need to counter-weigh the diminished application of the planning principle by increasing, for instance, the application of the accountability principle.

In simpler terms, management heads should roll.

Monday, August 5, 2013

Another jurisdiction up in the procurement air over airport administration and blames prior government

Aviation Stakeholders Berate House over Airport Contracts
Stakeholders in Nigeria’s aviation industry have frowned on the position of the House of Representatives on the ongoing airport remodelling contracts being undertaken by the Ministry of Aviation. The legislators alleged that the contracts did not pass due process.

According to the stakeholders, the committee should have intervened at the beginning when the programme was started, instead of attempting to terminate the projects that were already at advanced stage. Captain Usman Balarabe said it was quite shocking for any person from Nigeria who has utilised the airports for the past 30 years and had noticed the rot in infrastructure to voice any protest given the magnitude of the rehabilitation that has so far been undertaken in just over two years.

President of Centre for Aviation Safety and Research (CASR), Sheri Kyari, told THISDAY that when the minister started the airports remodelling programme, the House did not raise issues with due process until now the ministry had reached advanced stage with the projects, stressing that the programme should not be aborted.

“As far as I am concerned, let them not do anything that will stop the on-going development in the aviation industry. They are talking about due process now, and we know that to them due process is what will enter their pockets. They were all there when the woman started the development programme and they want to stop it now that it has reached advanced stage. I don’t agree with them,” Kyari, an aircraft engineer said.

A senior official of the ministry explained that all contracts for the remodelling of the airports and other critical infrastructure/equipment followed all due processes prescribed by the relevant law of the Public Procurement Act 2007. “It has to be noted that Selective Tendering is a lawful procurement procedure as enunciated in the Act,” the official said.

He explained the ministry opted for the selective tendering option because, “The present administration met aviation infrastructure, especially the terminals in a terrible state of dilapidation. Understandably, a state of emergency of sorts with regard to rehabilitating the derelict and decrepit infrastructure required a lot of urgency which the selective tendering provision in the Act suited quite aptly.”

The official explained that security related contracts are not subject to open competitive bidding in order not to compromise the process. “Secondly, the security equipment required and ordered by the
ministry is not an off-the shelf item. The equipment is to be custom-made and manufactured specifically to suit our purposes."

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Take the money and run -- amok



When reading the article linked below to get the full story, keep in mind this contract
"was deemed an emergency, D.C. claimed, because federal wind energy tax credits will expire at the end of the year".

Protest filed against D.C. sole-source deal for energy services
The Department of General Services selected Customer First to prepare a solicitation for a massive wind or solar energy purchase on behalf the District government, and then to review the responses. It was deemed an emergency, D.C. claimed, because federal wind energy tax credits will expire at the end of the year, and there's no other company that can do what D.C. has asked of Customer First in such a short period of time.

The District cited an "informal market survey of both local and national firms" that revealed the proposed contractor "is the only renewable energy integrator in the U.S. focused on bringing economically attractive utility-scale renewable electricity solutions to large end-users."
Procurement restrictions are intended to keep the government from spending other people's money (yours) without the self-control and prudence they'd exhibit if they were spending their own money. Here a local government was spending federal government money. The same principle should apply. (Indeed, it is likely that the federal strings attached to that money come with more "bite" for spending the money without legal authority than the local government.)

It will be interesting to see this controversy develop. The story so far has many teasers: the contractor was first selected to prepare the specs, then review responses, then awarded the contract to itself; award was sole source when it appears there were plenty of available competitors; the "emergency" existed only because the local government failed to act quickly enough in the first case to avail of the funds. Under the ABA Model Procurement Code as adopted on Guam, an emergency, as defined in law, does not include an event "which could not have been foreseen through the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures".  (5 GCA § 5030(x).)


Thursday, July 14, 2011

Procurement controversies -- Philippines National Police

DILG uncovers more anomalies in PNP
Authorities pushed for the procurement of rubber boats late 2009 after storm “Ondoy,” which left many parts of Metro Manila submerged in floodwater. National Police Commission (Napolcom) issued guidelines for the procurement but the PNP-BAC junked the order and justified the negotiated/emergency procurement because of Ondoy.

Interior and Local Government Secretary Jesse Robredo has ordered the filing of charges against active and retired police officials involved in the anomalous procurement in February 2010 of P131 million worth of rubber boats and outboard motor engines. Robredo said the people behind the questionable procurement of rubber boats could also be in-charge of the purchase of two second-hand helicopters.

The DILG chief however said the PNP Maritime Group Technical Inspection Committee on Watercrafts found out numerous defects and deficiencies in the acquisition.

“To make it short, the rubber boat and its outboard motor were not compatible and won’t fit for each other. The Napolcom standard specification calls for a 40 horsepower outboard motors but those delivered were 60 horsepower,” Robredo added.

Robredo also pointed out that that more than P1 million freight cost for the distribution of the rubber boats were not included in the contracts.

“The rubber boats can be used only with the paddle thereby defeating its intended purpose,” Robredo said, adding that officials of the Maritime Group requested Bacalzo to suspend the use of rubber boats as it would be risky.

Robredo noted 41 of the rubber boats were made in France, 24 came from Korea, and a third supplier was Costa Rica, and that some were recreational boats.

“Former PNP chief Jesus Verzosa, the members of the PNP Bids and Awards Committee (PNP-BAC) and others involved in the acquisition of defective and deficient rubber boats and outboard motors could be held liable for this irregular and anomalous transaction,” Robredo said in a press conference held at the DILG main office in Quezon City.

Verzosa, in a text message sent by his lawyer Benjie de los Santos, meanwhile said he welcomes any investigation.

“Procurements and procedures are in place in the PNP bidding processes. Complete staff action is undertaken before it reaches me for approval and have no knowledge or information of any irregularities or violation of the procurement law,” the text message said.

“The PNP chief (Verzosa) is not expected to go through the details as head of bureau. Unless it is shown that he has prior knowledge of wrongdoing of his subordinates,” it added.

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

Procurement controversies -- Beaumont, Texas

TEA: Beaumont ISD contracts did not meet state guidelines
The action came as a result of an audit conducted by the TEA which was investigating a number of contracts that were awarded within the last three years.

The TEA audit raises questions about whether the district violated Texas Education Code when entering into a contract with Walker's Electric Company.

The agency also questions whether Walker's Electric's master electrician had a valid license while performing work BISD.

Auditors also took issue with BISD declaring "emergency procurement status" to approve several contracts without going out for bids following Hurricane Ike.

One of those contracts was awarded to Healthy Resources Enterprises, Inc for more than $19 million. The contract was the second phase of a two-phase repair project to Smith Middle School. While the TEA says the first phase, worth $434,000, was properly awarded under emergency status, they say the second phase of the project, worth $18.8 million, is beyond the amount allowed "under a job order contract process."

BISD used emergency procurement status to explain bypassing TEC procurement requirements before awarding a contract to SeTex Construction Corporation for repairs to Martin Luther King Middle School following Hurricane Ike.

The district entered into a contract totaling $1,520,000 in December 2008 for cleanup, repairs, and damage mitigation, then entered into an additional contract with SeTex for additional repairs in February 2009 for nearly $5.4 million.

The Auditors agree that the first phase of the contract would be allowable under emergency procurement status.

Yet, auditors stated that the time between September 2008, when Hurricane Ike hit southeast Texas, and February 2009 would have been enough time for BISD to seek competitive bids for the second phase under TEC procurement requirements.
There are several issues raised in the story for you to read about, but it was this last transgression that really got my attention. The discrimination shown in separating the immediate emergency from the follow-on work arising from an emergency is something I have written about before, in this post: Since when is failure to manage and budget an emergency? There I wrote:
Since emergency procurements preempt the preferred competitive bidding and other forms of bidding, only the minimum amount of goods and services as will alleviate the "imminent" condition should be acquired by emergency, while the goods and services that cannot or need not be applied to the imminent condition should be acquired by other methods.
I was pleased to see this position reflected in the actions taken by the Texas Education Agency.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Serial emergency?

The Guam Department of Education started this school year with inadequately prepared buses and contracts for janitors and copiers.

It appears that contracts have been let on a monthly basis, with serial or sporadic declarations of emergency, pending the preparation and issuance of formal solicitations. The contracts have, however, all been renewed from prior contracts. It has been a rolling emergency.

GovGuam pays firms over $224K every month to clean schools
THE Guam Department of Education issued on Wednesday a stop work order on four private firms providing cleaning services to public schools but voided it later in the day after Governor Felix Camacho signed a certificate of emergency to rehire their services this month.

“We had to issue the notice because they can’t provide services until they have a purchase order for this month and we can’t issue a purchase order because the governor has not signed the certificate of emergency,” [DOE Superintendent Nerissa] Underwood explained.

She added that to continue their services would be in violation of Guam’s procurement law unless the governor signed the certificate of emergency.

The certificate allows GDOE to continue using the custodial services on a month-to-month arrangement until a contract is signed for their services.

She said that has been the arrangement for sometime now.

[The Governor's Legal Counsel, Ray] Haddock said although the governor had not issued an emergency certificate since April 30 for custodial services and the purchase of electronic copiers, and a letter was sent to GDOE, Lt. Gov. Mike Cruz, in his acting capacity as governor, did issue emergency certificates to GDOE for custodial and copier services after the letter was sent.

In the letter, the governor questioned why GDOE gave no explanation as to why they needed a declaration of emergency and were not going through the standard procurement process.

“Since March I’ve been telling them, if they want to do these emergency procurements, they have to complete the regular procurement,” said Haddock.

The governor wrote: “I do understand that circumstances beyond the control of DOE would necessitate the use of emergency procurement in some circumstances, but there is no explanation in your documentation why standard procurements could not be conducted for both copiers and custodial services.”

The governor further stated that “although I have no choice but to approve these declarations to keep DOE up and running while school is in session, I will not be able to approve additional certificates of emergency unless DOE, at the very least, begins to comply with the standard procurement process and releases non-emergency bids or RFPs for these procurements.”
Guam procurement law restricts emergency procurement to only a thirty day supply of goods and services, presumably adequate to both meet an emergency and commence any necessary usual procurement process.

These "emergencies" however were foreseeable, for the most part, and arose from failure to timely prepare for prior contract expiration.

Guam procurement law defines an emergency as meaning "a condition posing an imminent threat to public health, welfare, or safety which could not have been foreseen through the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures, and which cannot be addressed by other procurement methods of source selection." (5 GCA § 5030(x).)

It is hard to see how a series of rolling declarations is at all an "imminent" condition. It may have been imminent the first time, but the second? The third? The fifth?

It is harder to justify how failure to prepare for a proper solicitation in the face of a known contract expiry would in any sense be "the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures".

I wonder what's in their cereal? Certainly not Wheaties.

Tuesday, August 31, 2010

Since when is failure to manage and budget an emergency?

The latest Guam schools drama involves its school buses, which are supposed to be provided, not by the Department of Education, but the Department of Public Works.

Pacific News Center has reported that 60% of DPW 211 buses are inoperable. Only 87 buses in operation. 36 are awaiting repairs. But, it seems, that has been the status quo for some time.

This has resulted in many student's being stuck in bus stops for up to two hours, a condition that clearly raises concerns over their health and safety.

But wasn't that a foreseeable event with less than half the fleet operable?

An emergency is defined in the Guam Procurement Law(§ 5030(x)) as
"a condition posing an imminent threat to public health, welfare, or safety which could not have been foreseen through the use of reasonable and prudent management procedures, and which cannot be addressed by other procurement methods of source selection."
If this bus situation merely reflects the level of service that has been available since last school year, how can it now, suddenly be "imminent".

And since the situation is obviously detrimental, and has been for some time, it is merely the result of a failure of reasonable and prudent management, which disqualifies the situation from being an emergency if it can be addressed by other procurement methods. And this is where it gets a bit tricky, and requires focused procurement, not wholesale budgetary rewriting.

The commentary from the legislature suggests that the full amount of several hundred thousands dollars is required to bring all the buses up to speed. But is that required to alleviate the immediate concern?

If all the money appeared in a magic pudding, would that solve the problem immediately. Assuming all the various required parts could be ordered today, could the government even get them onto the buses immediately, or would it take a fair bit of time to complete the repairs?

The emergency procurement method is not intended to be a budgetary salve or crutch. It is intended only to do such critical amount as will alleviate the immediate crisis.

The Governor's spokesperson indicated an emergency declaration should not be used to rectify long term problems, and in that he was spot on.
See interview with Shawn Guamtaotao at the 2:45 minute mark in this report:



The Guam emergency procurement law (5 GCA § 5215) says
"No emergency procurement or combination of emergency procurements may be made for an amount of goods or supplies greater than the amount of such goods and supplies which is necessary to meet an emergency for the thirty (30) day period immediately following the procurement."
Since emergency procurements preempt the preferred competitive bidding and other forms of bidding, only the minimum amount of goods and services as will alleviate the "imminent" condition should be acquired by emergency, while the goods and services that cannot or need not be applied to the imminent condition should be acquired by other methods.

I would argue that this provision should be construed and applied to be strictly limited, by the policy of planned procurement (5 GCA § 5010) and the express definition of "emergency" set out above in conditions when, in the exercise of reasonable and prudent management procedures, the condition should never have arisen in the first place. Remember, the Procurement Law is intended to be construed and applied to promote its underlying purposes and policies. (5 GCA § 5001(a).)

The government should not be given the easy out to run roughshod over normal procurement safeguards and principles when it fails its essential management functions, or when the legislature fails its essential budgetary functions.

When the emergency procurement law is carefully applied, the truly imminent threat is ameliorated and those who failed us should be made to stand out and account for the failure. Otherwise, those who failed us are bailed out, to fail us again another day. It is a moral hazard to use emergency procurement to fix foreseeable faults; it should only be used for that very, very, very rainy day.

Recall this item along with the thought that emergency procurement should be tailored and proportionate to the imminent threat, not to conditions that can otherwise be addressed in the fullness of an appropriate time:
Buffalo, NY ordered to repay FEMA for improper emergency procurement



FURTHER ON THIS TOPIC: Pacific News Center is now reporting NO EMERGENCY

Governor Will Not Declare Emergency Over School Bus Crisis; Solution Lies With Legislature
Governor's Spokesman Shawn Gumataotao says an Emergency Declaration is not the solution to the school bus crisis.

When asked by PNC News how the Governor would respond to Senator Tom Ada's request for an Emergency Declaration over the issue which has seen up to 2 hours delays, Gumataotao responded, "We are currently working through the situation as it is. Will an emergency bring about the change they are looking for? It does not," he said.
COMMENT: Bravo, Governor.

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Buffalo, NY ordered to repay FEMA for improper emergency procurement

City must pay back $4 million in storm aid
Federal auditors determined that the city didn't comply with procurement standards when contracting for debris removal and other services. Auditors also concluded that the city overspent when it hired companies to remove storm debris.

A 2006 investigation by The Buffalo News several weeks after the storm revealed that Buffalo and Erie County paid top dollar for cleanup, as much as 50 percent to 85 percent higher than some suburban communities.

In Buffalo, city leaders skipped the public bidding process, reasoning that safety concerns took priority. In Erie County, the investigation concluded that the county paid more for debris removal because of its decision to focus on hiring local contractors.

Gillibrand was equally critical of the determination, saying local citizens should not be forced to shoulder the fiscal burden for Buffalo's "efficient" actions after the disaster. "If it weren't for the city's quick response to the Surprise October storm, the toll on its residents and properties could have been much worse," she said. "Local residents should not be left shouldering all of the costs from this storm."

"We did everything by the numbers," the mayor said. "We were one of the communities that most quickly recovered after the storm ... and we had the debris up most quickly."