An Enterprise, Alabama, resident was sentenced today in the Southern District of Florida to 48 months in prison to be followed by three years of supervised release for accepting unlawful kickbacks and tax evasion, announced Acting Assistant Attorney General Caroline D. Ciraolo of the Justice Department’s Tax Division.
According to court documents and statements made in open court, Victor Villalobos, 47, worked for a federal prime contractor at Fort Rucker, Alabama. In 2009, Villalobos approached Maxim Silinsky, a Florida-based subcontractor for this company, and solicited illegal kickbacks on the federal subcontracts that Silinsky held in connection with the federal prime contractor. Villalobos agreed that in exchange for kickback payments he would refrain from conduct that would unfavorably affect Silinsky’s business relationship with the federal prime contractor and help ensure that he obtained additional business.
As part of his plea, Villalobos admitted that from June 2009 to December 2014, he received approximately 57 separate wire transfers totaling more than $1.9 million in kickback payments from various foreign and domestic bank accounts controlled by Silinsky. At two separate meetings in 2015, Villalobos accepted envelopes from Silinsky containing cash kickbacks totaling $60,000. Between June 2009 and February 2015, Villalobos attempted to conceal his receipt of the kickbacks by forming nominee entities and opening nominee bank accounts. Villalobos also admitted that he evaded paying income taxes on the kickback payments by causing false federal income tax returns to be filed with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
In addition to his prison sentence, U.S. District Judge Daniel T.K. Hurley ordered Villalobos to pay $542,562 in restitution to the IRS. As part of his plea agreement, Villalobos also agreed to be permanently debarred from federal government contracting.
Silinsky pleaded guilty to filing a false tax return in November 2015 and cooperated in the investigation and prosecution of Villalobos. Silinsky was sentenced to one year and one day in prison on Feb. 2. Silinsky also cooperated in the investigation and prosecution of Trevor Smith, a retired U.S. Air Force Master Sergeant who pleaded guilty in October 2015 to unlawfully disclosing confidential procurement information and filing a false tax return. On Jan. 28, Smith was sentenced to 18 months in prison.
Simply some articles of interest and comments posted by the author of the Guam Procurement Process Primer, to add a broader context to the Guam procurement law issues discussed in the Primer. This Blog is intended for educational purposes. Nothing posted, said or implied or linked to in this blog, including any public comment, is intended to be taken as fact nor relied upon or used as legal advice. A quick guide to topics is available from the following Labels and Tags:
Labels and Tags
Accountability
(71)
Adequate documentation
(7)
ADR in procurement
(4)
Allocation of risks
(6)
Best interest of government
(11)
Best practices
(19)
Best value
(15)
Bidder prejudice
(11)
Blanket purchase agreement
(1)
Bridge contract
(2)
Bundling
(6)
Cancellation and rejection
(2)
Centralized procurement structure
(12)
Changes during bid process
(14)
Clarifications vs Discussions
(1)
Competence
(9)
Competition vs Efficiency
(29)
Competitive position
(3)
Compliance
(35)
Conflict of interest
(32)
Contract administration
(26)
Contract disputes
(4)
Contract extension or modification
(9)
Contract formation
(1)
Contract interpretation
(1)
Contract terms
(3)
Contract types
(6)
Contract vs solicitation dispute
(2)
Contractor responsibility
(20)
Conviction
(4)
Cooperative purchasing
(3)
Corrective action
(1)
Cost and pricing
(13)
Debarment
(4)
Determinations
(8)
Determining responsibility
(37)
Disclosure requirements
(7)
Discussions during solicitation
(10)
Disposal of surplus property
(3)
Effective enforcement requirement
(35)
Effective procurement management
(5)
Effective specifications
(36)
Emergency procurement
(14)
eProcurement
(5)
Equitable tolling
(2)
Evaluation of submissions
(22)
Fair and equitable treatment
(14)
Fair and reasonable value
(23)
Fiscal effect of procurement
(14)
Frivolous protest
(1)
Good governance
(12)
Governmental functions
(27)
Guam
(14)
Guam procurement law
(12)
Improper influence
(11)
Incumbency
(13)
Integrity of system
(31)
Interested party
(7)
Jurisdiction
(1)
Justification
(1)
Life-cycle cost
(1)
Limits of government contracting
(5)
Lore vs Law
(4)
market research
(7)
Materiality
(3)
Methods of source selection
(33)
Mistakes
(4)
Models of Procurement
(1)
Needs assessment
(11)
No harm no foul?
(8)
Offer & acceptance
(1)
Other procurement links
(14)
Outsourcing
(34)
Past performance
(12)
Planning policy
(34)
Politics of procurement
(52)
PPPs
(6)
Prequalification
(1)
Principle of competition
(95)
Principles of procurement
(25)
Private vs public contract
(17)
Procurement authority
(5)
Procurement controversies series
(79)
Procurement ethics
(19)
Procurement fraud
(31)
Procurement lifecycle
(9)
Procurement philosophy
(17)
Procurement procedures
(30)
Procurement reform
(63)
Procurement theory
(11)
Procurement workforce
(2)
Procurment philosophy
(6)
Professionalism
(17)
Protest - formality
(2)
Protest - timing
(12)
Protests - general
(37)
Purposes and policies of procurement
(11)
Recusal
(1)
Remedies
(17)
Requirement for new procurement
(4)
Resolution of protests
(4)
Responsiveness
(14)
Restrictive specifications
(5)
Review procedures
(13)
RFQ vs RFP
(1)
Scope of contract
(16)
Settlement
(2)
Social preference provisions
(60)
Sole source
(48)
Sovereign immunity
(3)
Staffing
(8)
Standard commercial products
(3)
Standards of review
(2)
Standing
(6)
Stays and injunctions
(6)
Structure of procurement
(1)
Substantiation
(9)
Surety
(1)
Suspension
(6)
The procurement record
(1)
The role of price
(10)
The subject matter of procurement
(23)
Trade agreements vs procurement
(1)
Training
(33)
Transparency
(63)
Uniformity
(6)
Unsolicited proposals
(3)
Showing posts with label Improper influence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Improper influence. Show all posts
Thursday, February 18, 2016
A(nother) contractor gets kicked back
Federal Government Contractor Sentenced To Prison For Accepting Kickbacks And Tax Evasion
Sunday, August 30, 2015
The problem with friends in high places
Lockheed Martin pays $4.7 million to settle charges it lobbied for federal contract with federal money
Over five years, starting in 2009, a Lockheed Martin subsidiary — which was being paid by the federal government to run Sandia National Laboratories — lobbied members of Congress and senior Obama administration officials for a seven-year extension of the contract, according to the settlement the Justice Department announced Friday.Read more of the story at the link above.
The case opened a window on the inner workings of power and influence in Washington. It’s not surprising that a big, politically connected defense contractor would lobby hard to keep a lucrative slice of federal business. But this case went further. Taxpayers, not Lockheed’s corporate lobbying arm in Bethesda, Md., were paying for the influence peddling.
Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Benjamin C. Mizer, head of the Justice Department’s Civil Division, alleges that Sandia Corp., the Lockheed subsidiary, used federal money to lobby Congress and other federal officials from 2008 and 2012 “to receive a non-competitive extension” of its contract in violation of federal law. ompany executives, who allegedly hired a former New Mexico congresswoman to help them, didn’t just press people with influence to continue a relationship worth $2.4 billion a year to Lockheed, as Energy Department Inspector General Gregory Friedman concluded in an investigation last fall. They also urged that the contract be closed to competition.
Lockheed has contracted with the Energy Department to run Sandia since 1993. The research lab is part of the government’s nuclear weapons complex, with facilities in Albuquerque and Livermore, Calif. Wilson, who left Congress in 2009 after an unsuccessful run for the Senate, has publicly denied that she took part in any lobbying involving the Sandia contract.
To clinch the contract extension, Sandia labs officials hired high-priced consultants — including Heather A. Wilson, the former New Mexico congresswoman, who allegedly was paid $226,000 — to write up a “contract extension strategy.” Among the tactics allegedly suggested by Wilson was “working key influencers” by targeting then-Energy Secretary Steven Chu’s staff, his relatives and friends, and his former colleagues at another federal lab — all with the goal of keeping Lockheed Martin in charge of Albuquerque-based Sandia.
Wilson, who left Congress in 2009 after an unsuccessful run for the Senate, has publicly denied that she took part in any lobbying involving the Sandia contract.
Energy Department Inspector General Gregory Friedman alleged that Sandia hired Wilson’s consulting firm and two unnamed former employees of Energy’s National Nuclear Security Administration, which oversees the nuclear labs. Wilson’s company, Heather Wilson LLC, gave explicit guidance to the Sandia team on how to influence important people in Washington who would decide whether Lockheed’s contract would be renewed, authorities say. “Lockheed Martin should aggressively lobby Congress, but keep a low profile,” she advised, according to meeting notes authorities say were obtained by the inspector general’s investigation.
The inspector general said that Sandia’s push for a long-term no-bid contract extension under the Obama administration was not the lab’s first lobbying attempt at taxpayers’ expense. “Perhaps [Sandia] felt empowered because it had improperly directed Federal funds to similar activities in the past,” investigators wrote last fall.
Heather Clark, spokeswoman for Sandia National Laboratories, said the lab “has agreed to settle with the Department of Justice to put the matter behind us, take action on what we learned and focus on our important national security mission.” She said Sandia executives “believed our actions for a contract extension fell within allowable cost guidelines,” but now realize that they “acted too early and too independently in planning for a possible contract extension.”
The investigation has “clarified” Sandia’s understanding of “our legal obligations on interacting with public officials,” Clark said.
Tuesday, August 25, 2015
Who's your Daddy?
State Auditor: SCC contract award OK, but purchasing rules still unclear
The State Corporation Commission is essentially the state's fourth branch of government, created by the state constitution and not subject to all the same rules as the rest of Virginia state government. It regulates businesses, including utilities.It seems to be a repetitive story that the more we take the procurement leg irons off any particular government spenders, the more the paranoia rises that we should put hand cuffs on them. No-bid contracts are the chief vehicle for creating this distrust, which is lodged in basic and simple notions of fair and equitable treatment, accountability and transparency.
A 2009 "eFile" contract for technological services with CGI, a major IT company, increased via eight modifications from $2.9 million to $6.9 million. The SCC determined that there was "no outside influence exerted" in the approval of a $28.5 million "Commission 2.0" contract, awarded last year to CGI for a major SCC systems upgrade.
Four former SCC employees specifically said the executive head of the SCC steered contracts to CGI, approved large post-award price increases and rebuffed their concerns over protocol. The latest State audit found no evidence of favoritism in the State Corporation Commission's award of the major technology contract, but repeats a more than 2-year-old suggestion that the commission "clarify what procurement rules and regulations apply to them as an independent department of government."
SCC spokesman Ken Schrad said "Legal considerations remain that must be addressed because of the constitutional nature of the SCC as an independent department of state government." Schrad pointed to multiple reviews, both internal and from the state auditor, that found no evidence of contract tampering.
Friday, January 30, 2015
Reverse all auctions, full steam ahead
There is one main theme here, and a case study that gave rise to it. The main theme is the light shown on the so-called "reverse auction" fad.
The business about the FedBid business is just to add a bit of salacious spice to the otherwise drab story line. Most procurement story lines are drab. But that doesn't diminish their importance, as this blawg hopes to point out.
First, the juicy bits:
Air Force moves to debar FedBid
So, read on.
The real dirt:
FedBid barred from new government contracts after watchdog report
Continuing with the WaPo story immediately above:
The business about the FedBid business is just to add a bit of salacious spice to the otherwise drab story line. Most procurement story lines are drab. But that doesn't diminish their importance, as this blawg hopes to point out.
First, the juicy bits:
Air Force moves to debar FedBid
On Jan. 26, the Air Force suspended and moved to debar FedBid from providing reverse auctions for federal agencies contracts, on the grounds that there was "adequate evidence" of a "lack of business honesty or integrity" at the company.So far, this is not that juicy. Just how juicy is a "cultural" problem, anyway? Blaming the culture means no one is at fault. Can't convict a culture, can we?
Most recently, the company split its federal auction and commercial operations into separate companies. FedBid founder and former chief executive Ali Saadat is now head of the private sector business, but remains chairman of the FedBid board, while Jordan was named CEO of the federal side.
Saadat was also suspended by the Air Force while the service considers whether to debar the company.
In the immediate wake of the report, the company's board of directors appointed a special committee to determine any response or actions the company should take related to the report. That committee retained the law firm Arnold & Porter as outside counsel to conduct an independent review of company employees' actions. That review is said to have found "no legal wrongdoing by FedBid or its employees," though it did raise some concerns about how the company's internal culture dealt with third-party relationships.
So, read on.
The real dirt:
FedBid barred from new government contracts after watchdog report
The federal government has barred a fast-growing Northern Virginia contractor with deep ties to the Washington establishment from winning new work because of “conduct indicating a lack of business honesty or integrity.”The theme -- Reverse Auctions:
Last year, the company was the subject of an investigation by the Veterans Affairs inspector general, which found that an agency contracting official helped steer a contract to the company. When a more senior VA official became concerned about the contract and put a hold on it, FedBid mounted an aggressive campaign to have the moratorium overturned, the IG found. It concluded that FedBid executives were part of an effort to discredit the VA official who put the hold on the contract and to “unduly influence VA decision makers.”
“Need to assassinate his character and discredit him,” read an e-mail from a top executive in 2012, according to the IG. The firm also vowed to “unleash the hounds” and “take off the gloves” in its “storm the castle” campaign to win back the business.
Continuing with the WaPo story immediately above:
FedBid has built a thriving business over the past decade helping the government hold what are known as reverse auctions. Through FedBid Web sites, federal contracting officials post solicitations for items such as office supplies, computer equipment or furniture. Companies submit bids for the work and are told through the site whether they are the lowest bidder. If they aren’t the lowest bidder, they can try again with a reduced price, which ultimately should save taxpayer money.VA rips FedBid, questions value of reverse auctions
The government’s reliance on reverse auctions has recently exploded, with FedBid leading the way. The company said that from 2007 to last year, the federal government made 131,623 awards through FedBid, totaling $8.2 billion, which represented nearly $1 billion in savings. In 2013 alone, FedBid said, $1.8 billion in government contracts were awarded through its system.
FedBid's claims of sizable savings generated by the reverse auctions the firm provides for federal contractors are overblown and misleading, according to the Department of Veterans Affairs' Office of Inspector General. Furthermore, Maureen Regan, counselor to VA's IG, told FCW that reverse auctions can unduly complicate the contracting process and limit competition by squeezing out potential vendors.Review of the Veterans Health Administration’s Use of Reverse Auction Acquisitions (RAs)
What Regan told FCW echoed a second IG report that says reverse auctions can inadvertently derail federal efforts to properly record contract documentation.
More significant, however, was the assertion by the OIG that the main purpose of reverse auctions -- to save money -- can be negated by multiple factors, including FedBid's fees and the Industrial Funding Fee customers paid to cover the General Services Administration's operation of the Federal Supply Schedules program.
Furthermore, the formula that reverse auction providers use to calculate savings -- subtracting the final award price from the "independent government cost estimate" -- was not reliable, the OIG argued, in part because of frequent mismatches between that independent estimate (which is required by VA policy) and the target price set by agency contracting officers. In addition, contract prices represent funds obligated at the time a contract was awarded, but many purchases were not fully funded at that time, resulting in inflation of the reported savings.
"We are enormously proud of the role that FedBid is playing, and will continue to play, in facilitating millions in cost savings for U.S. taxpayers," a FedBid spokesperson said in an emailed statement -- noting that "last year alone," the FedBid marketplace "enabled an estimated $160 million in savings for the government and taxpayers."
Regan, however, asserted that reverse auctions contain other costs, including GSA's Industrial Funding Fee, that might not be readily apparent to agencies.
The federal contracting schedules offer baseline pricing that agencies can use to negotiate lower costs, she said, adding that "it's not uncommon to get price reductions on schedule items," often by conducting a limited competition among schedule vendors. Regan said the OIG has had complaints from vendors, including a substantial number from health care supply companies, that FedBid's reverse auctions set up a "pay-to-play" system that is cost-prohibitive.
At the same time, other reverse auction vehicles might be getting short shrift. Regan said GSA offers services that comply with federal contract documentation requirements and include items on federal schedules.
Regan recommends that agencies "look at contracts and how people are buying things" before committing to the approach. "Reverse auctions were something of a fad in the 1990s," she said. "Everyone decided at the time they weren't really worth it."
We found that priority sources such as the FSS (Federal Supply Schedule) are not utilized as required by VA policy and VHA’s SOP (Standard Operating Procedure) for all RAs. Further, when RAs are used for FS S purchases, VHA is paying the Industrial Funding Fee (IFF) in addition to the FedBid RA fee when FedBid’s RA fee is not waived by FedBid.
We found instances where the CO would identify an FSS source for the required products; however the Invitation for Bid (IFB) would subsequently be issued for open market bids. These situations occurred without any documentation in the contract file to justify the use of other than priority sources. In addition, if the awardee is an FSS vendor, these sales may be considered non-FSS sales which deprive the Government of the IFF.
We found that the reported claimed savings, computed by subtracting the final award price from the target price, was not reliable in determining the success of using RAs for several reasons.
First, although the target price set by the CO should be equal to the Independent Government Estimate (IGE) as stated in VA policy and the implementing VHA SOP, we found that the target price was not always equal to the IGE, and that the basis for the target price was often not documented within the contract file.
Second, we found that the award price represented funds obligated at award and that many buys were not fully funded at the time of award, thereby inflating the reported savings. Lastly, we found that the target price could be changed by the CO during an active RA via a reposting of the IFB. Such changes were not always documented and justified within the eCMS contract file.
We also determined that COs run the risk of acquiring gray market items through RAs, because sellers are only required to self-certify that they are authorized distributors of the procured items. We found VHA was procuring items from unauthorized distributors through the use of RAs.
Monday, December 22, 2014
Procurement controversy -- Incorrect Corrections in Mississippi
State awards billions in no-bid contracts
State government spends billions of taxpayers' dollars — nearly $6.5 billion in the last four years — through "no-bid" contracts, with little oversight or transparency. It's a system ripe for overspending, malfeasance and cronyism. And it's one that apparently allowed corruption to fester for years, with the head of the state prisons system allegedly taking $2 million in bribes to hand out hundreds of millions of dollars in no-bid contracts. A Clarion-Ledger analysis of state records in the wake of that scandal discovered not only a lack of accurate data on no-bid agreements but numerous contracts with little or no explanation.MDOC Scandal Highlights Privatization Problems
These include contracts given to sole-source vendors, whose products and services state agency officials claim no one else can provide, contracts with those whose professions are exempt from bidding and "emergency" contracts. It also includes contracts with dollar amounts that fall below generous state thresholds for bidding.
Some state officials concede Mississippi government has a contracting system with thresholds for bidding that are too high and with too many exemptions. They also say there appears to be abuse of provisions for emergency contracts and overall lax oversight, provided primarily by a board of the same state agency leaders who are inking the contracts.
In general, state agency leaders within liberal limits can hire whomever they want for whatever price they decide. Need to hire a motivational speaker? No bidding is required as long as it's under $100,000. Need an accountant or engineer? No bidding or approval needed because their services are exempt. Need a media consultant? No bidding is required if you declare it an emergency.
"At this point, I do not have proof that there is corruption (beyond the prisons scandal), but I think the Legislature in the past that set up this review board and system made it awfully easy for corruption to exist," said House Accountability, Transparency and Efficiency chairman Jerry Turner, who's leading the charge for reform.
Facing a federal magistrate judge in Jackson, Chris Epps and Cecil McCrory made a curious pair. Despite receiving his appointment to one of the most visible posts in state government from Democratic Gov. Ronnie Musgrove, Epps was also able to survive Mississippi's hyper-partisan government, later serving under conservative Republicans Haley Barbour and Phil Bryant. McCrory, Epps' alleged co-conspirator, seemed to have been a key cog in that system. A former legislator who held a number of elected political positions as a Republican, McCrory knew all the ins and outs of state government. During his time in the Legislature, he served on the Joint Committee on Performance Evaluation and Expenditure Review (PEER), the very agency that would later raise questions about McCrory's business dealings with the state. At their arraignment before U.S. Magistrate Judge Keith Ball, both men pleaded not guilty on all counts.Prison review group examining no-bid contracts
The alleged activities outlined in the indictment began seven years ago, in November 2007, when Epps signed a no-bid contract with G.T. Enterprises for commissary services at state prisons. That year, McCrory paid Epps $3,000 to $4,000 on about 15 occasions in exchange for the contract that McCrory's company's had with MDOC. That contract was later transferred to St. Louis, Mo.-based Keefe Commissary Network LLC., which resulted in a large profit for McCrory, the indictment states.
Despite PEER's criticism of Epps' no-bid contract for commissary services in 2011, policymakers failed then to take action on the report. Rick Ward, a former official with the Mississippi Gaming Commission, called PEER, which performs thorough investigations but lacks any enforcement power, a paper tiger. "The problems is you've got members of the Legislature on the commission—that's like the fox guarding the henhouse," Ward said. "It's a waste of our taxpayer dollars."
Republican Gov. Phil Bryant appointed a bipartisan, five-member task force to examine the Mississippi Department of Corrections' spending practices after former Corrections Commissioner Christopher Epps and businessman Cecil McCrory were indicted last month on federal corruption charges.Lawyers: Epps said prison companies 'spread' money
"What we're going to do is try to review all the contracts that have been involved in this indictment and also all the other contracts for the Department of Corrections to see if we can change some of the practices, maybe close some of the loopholes that caused this big mess," said one of the members, former Attorney General Mike Moore. "As you know, taxpayer money must be spent to serve the needs of the public, not to perpetuate ineffective contracts or enrich government officials," Bryant wrote.
During 2011 negotiations, then-Corrections Commissioner Chris Epps said he couldn't get rid of Mississippi's private companies running prisons "because of all the money they spread around Jackson," attorneys told The Clarion-Ledger. His remarks took place during the time when federal prosecutors say Epps was receiving more than $700,000 in bribes, including a beachfront condo.State contracts: Where should Miss. look for reform?
In early 2011, Margaret Winter, associate director of the ACLU, and Sheila Bedi, then-deputy legal director for the Southern Poverty Law Center, had a meeting with Epps, which they say was also attended by Department of Corrections officials, attorneys and consultants. Bedi said Epps gave her the impression he desired to hold the private prisons accountable, but his hands were tied. She said she thought, "This is a progressive reformer beating his head against the wall." Winter said she asked Epps point blank, "Why don't you just get rid of the private contractors? We all know they're part of the problem, not part of the solution." Bedi said Epps went on to say that it was impossible to get rid of the private contractors "because of all the money they throw around Jackson."
Christopher Epps, Former Chief of Prisons in Mississippi, Is Arraigned The indictment says that Mr. McCrory operated several companies that had contracts with the state, including for prison administration, commissary services and evaluating Medicaid eligibility across the state prison system. Mr. Epps, 53, had been Mississippi’s longest-serving corrections commissioner until he resigned Wednesday. He had been president of both the Association of State Correctional Administrators and the American Correctional Association until his resignation. Mr. McCrory resigned as president of the Rankin County School Board on Wednesday within hours of Mr. Epps’s resignation.
In addition to owning companies with state prison contracts, Mr. McCrory was a paid consultant to firms seeking such deals in Mississippi, including the Management & Training Corporation, a private company based in Utah that operates the East Mississippi Correctional Facility in Lauderdale County, Miss. According to the indictment, around the time that Mr. Epps signed a contract with the Management & Training Corporation to run the prison in August 2012, Mr. McCrory — the company’s consultant — wired $34,000 to Wells Fargo Home Mortgage as a payment on a condominium Mr. Epps had recently bought in Biloxi, Miss. Mr. Epps, according to the indictment, had suggested that Management & Training Corporation hire Mr. McCrory as a consultant, and had also negotiated Mr. McCrory’s fee. “I got us $12,000 per month,” Mr. Epps told Mr. McCrory, according to the indictment. Prosecutors say the two men split the money after calculating how much tax Mr. McCrory would have to pay on the fee. Mr. Epps eventually signed a number of contracts with the management corporation to provide various prison services, including a no-bid contract in October 2012 — just weeks after Mr. McCrory paid another $14,000 on Mr. Epps’s condominium, the indictment said.
Mr. McCrory’s initial payment to Mr. Epps, according to prosecutors, was in 2007, after Mr. Epps had awarded a no-bid contract to G. T. Enterprises, a firm owned by Mr. McCrory, to supply commissary services to the prison system. Mr. McCrory went on to pay Mr. Epps $3,000 to $4,000 15 different times, and Mr. McCrory later sold the commissary business at a substantial profit, prosecutors said.
Past legislation aimed at reform — which was killed — is being revived and has a much better chance at passage. The state also can look to others that have reformed no-bid spending and contracting, which can be a breeding ground for corruption and overspending. "There are some opportunities here for changes in the way the state does business," said former Attorney General Mike Moore, a member of the task force. He and others on the task force said they will look for "best practices" in other states.Website not designed to track no-bid contracts
One of those might be in Washington state. State law there requires agencies requesting a sole-source contract to make that request public for at least 10 days prior to the contract start date. The Washington Department of Enterprise Services publishes the proposed no-bid contracts on a website. Washington, D.C., has a similar 10-day public posting of intent to award a no-bid contract.
In Iowa, such requests for sole-source contracts also are made public, and the agency must fill out a lengthy questionnaire explaining why a particular vendor is the only one who can provide a good or service and detailing what research went into this finding. The request is posted for at least five business days on Iowa's bid opportunities website, which would allow other vendors to see the request and potentially make bids.
In Pennsylvania, Gov.-elect Tom Wolf made enacting a ban on no-bid contracts with private law firms part of his campaign platform. He vows to issue an executive order banning what he called "crony contracts" with law firms, placing a cap on fees paid to lawyers and making the process transparent online.
The scope and scale of the state's multibillion-dollar business with preferred vendors remains shrouded in darkness despite a 2008 law demanding transparency in government spending.
Mississippi agencies awarded nearly $6.5 billion in no-bid contracts to at least 1,807 individuals and businesses in the past four years alone, according to a Clarion-Ledger investigation. But the public would never know this by viewing the state Transparency website, which the law requires to house agency contract information.
Built and maintained on a shoestring budget by the state Department of Finance and Administration, the website contains countless contract inaccuracies caused by software glitches and human error, making it nearly impossible to know the true number and value of no-bid contracts. It's also impossible to view a list of just no-bid contracts — accurate or not — because the website doesn't track or store them that way. Neither does the Department of Finance and Administration, which, when asked for a list of such contracts, pulled it directly from the website.
But the biggest problem is that no one anticipated the need to examine no-bid contracts on a statewide scale. "The concept of no-bid is an entirely new concept to me that came out of the Epps scandal," said DFA Executive Director Kevin Upchurch, referring to the recent federal indictment of former state Corrections Commissioner Chris Epps.
It took more than two weeks of exhaustive analysis and fact checking by The Clarion-Ledger and several records revisions by the DFA — which provided assistance in the effort — to produce a viably accurate list of no-bid state contracts. Sortable by vendor, agency, contract date and dollar value, the list shows not only who gets the most cash without having to compete for it but also which agencies ink the most agreements and why. But the list is stagnant. Contracts awarded after its completion won't appear unless someone continues to track them.
It's the basis for a series of questions about the way state government operates, and perhaps chief among them are these:
•Is this the first comprehensive list of no-bid state contracts ever created in Mississippi?
•Has no one in state government tracked this before — not just posted data on a website but really tracked and analyzed it?
•And if not, should someone start, especially in light of the Department of Corrections scandal?
Monday, August 5, 2013
The good, the bad and the corrupt-ish
Taiwan Is Angry But Is It Also Corrupt?
Proudly democratic Taiwan with the world’s 26th largest economy is demanding that the graft-detection group Transparency International do a recount after placing it on the NGO's corruption list. It has also sent the Berlin-based NGO two letters of protest. But Transparency International, which calls its barometer the biggest ever survey on global public opinion on corruption, says it stands by its findings and has no plans to scrap or redo its research on graft in Taiwan.
The standoff between Taiwan and Transparency International leaves open the question of how corrupt this global exporter in the West Pacific really is. Public records laws let the public see a lot of government in action. The news media have ample freedom. No one is charging the government with systematically stealing wads of public money to spend on itself. Taiwan’s leaders are no African kleptocrats.
At the same time, despite the liberal democratic reforms put in motion since martial law was lifted in 1987, Taiwan is hardly free of corruption. Based on local news reports and discussions with lawyers, it’s safe to call payoffs and unholy alliances core part of government business. Government procurement is considered shady. And it’s widely suspected that contractors pay officials under the table and that some don’t even need contracts.
Some projects are so “off the wall” that the public must imagine a hidden financial motive, says Robin Winkler, who founded his Taipei-based law firm in 2002. He says lawmakers may also raise construction bid prices to get more from themselves and others in their camp.
Friday, August 2, 2013
Procurement controversies -- Daytona Beach, Florida
There is a lot to this story, and much more including a larger story than extracted here, so you should probably best just click the link and go straight to it. I've decided to categorize this as another in the procurement controversies series because it seems such a common drama as to almost represent a genre of procurement controversy in which undue influence and conflict of interest, or the appearance of it, becomes central.
But remember, I do not validate or imply the veracity of these stories, using them only as hypothetical contexts in which procurement issues can be dissected and studied.
If it is not obvious at the start, bear in mind that this involves a public hospital, thus public contracting principles are involved.
Vendor sues Halifax Health over bid
But remember, I do not validate or imply the veracity of these stories, using them only as hypothetical contexts in which procurement issues can be dissected and studied.
If it is not obvious at the start, bear in mind that this involves a public hospital, thus public contracting principles are involved.
Vendor sues Halifax Health over bid
Hospital denies vendor claim of favoritism, and says the goal is to save money
The enabling act that governs the public hospital’s procedures requires purchases over $10,000 to be subject to competitive bidding.
John Johnson, board chairman, said Halifax Health’s administration has an obligation to look for ways to reduce costs, and Johnson believes that’s what the hospital is trying to do in this case. “My highest priority has always been patient care, and I do not see that this particular issue is impacting that,” Johnson added.
Spinal Resources Inc. alleges Halifax Health has illegally steered business to an entrepreneur with ties to the hospital’s biggest donor. The company requested the injunction to stop the planned purchase of spinal implants and instrumentation by Halifax Health. Spinal Resources Inc. allege in their legal filing that the hospital shut out their company and others in favor of a startup launched five months ago called Cognitive Kinetics. The startup may receive more than $1 million from the deal, while becoming the main supplier of spinal implants to Halifax Health, according to documents The News-Journal obtained as part of a public-records request.
That startup’s founder is Bill Christy, a longtime executive in the medical supply field. He’s also known locally to have a personal association with Lesa France Kennedy, the CEO of International Speedway Corp., which owns Daytona International Speedway and 12 other tracks across the United States. The France family made the largest donation in Halifax Health’s history when they gave $10 million in 2009 to build a 10-story tower that bears the family name.
In its legal filing, Spinal Resources alleges the invitations to bid “were developed and issued with no actual intention of fairly considering the bids.” Halifax Health had already decided well in advance in favor of Cognitive Kinetics, the complaint alleges. Although Cognitive Kinetics was notified about the bid process, other vendors were not, and the specifications for the bid were written with information provided by Cognitive Kinetics, the legal filing states.
In the complex world of hospital finance, where lives are at stake and the pressure to hold down costs is immense, hospital officials said they feel a responsibility to explore every opportunity that helps them meet both goals. Reducing the number of vendors and giving the hospital more control over the process is an example of that, and Christy was the best man to pull it together, said John Guthrie, a spokesman for Halifax Health. “It’s driven by the fact we need to find a new cost model,” Guthrie said.
Spinal Resources’ legal filing claims Halifax Health’s neurosurgeons were told in May or early June by top-level administrators, including Halifax Health CEO Jeff Feasel, that they would no longer be able to use their preferred vendors because the hospital had already selected a new vendor for spinal implants.
Christy dismissed Spinal Resources as a “disgruntled vendor” that is disparaging a community leader in “a desperate attempt to throw as many allegations against the wall” as possible. France Kennedy was never involved in any discussions regarding Cognitive Kinetics or business at the hospital, he said.
Christy said Tom Beall, Halifax Health’s director of supply chain management, approached him in the fall of 2012 when the hospital was exploring how to reduce costs and streamline the process of spinal implant surgeries. Christy incorporated Cognitive Kinetics on Feb. 22 and signed a nondisclosure agreement with Halifax Health three days later. Although doctors are “strongly encouraged” to use Cognitive Kinetics, they are not being forced to use a specific company, Guthrie said.
In a Feb. 27 email on the subject, Beall wrote that hospital officials were interested in “a totally different type of relationship” in which the hospital or one of its corporations would partner with private investors and perhaps physicians to create a distributorship for spinal and orthopedic implants. “It is a very unique type of corporation which really has not been done anywhere in the country that I am aware of but it has the potential to save us millions in supply costs,” Beall wrote in an email to Shelly Shiflet, the hospital’s assistant general counsel. “Mr. Christy has ties to manufacturers and venture capitalists that would be crucial to the success of this type of venture.”
In a May 22 letter to the health system’s chief financial officer — labeled “personal and confidential” — Christy outlined “preliminary understandings and good faith intentions” on the potential purchase of an ownership interest by Halifax Health in his company. The News-Journal obtained the letter as part of a public records request. According to the letter, Halifax Health would have the option to purchase 85 percent of Cognitive Kinetics’ units of membership for $1.15 million, which would be paid in cash immediately upon transfer of the ownership interest.
Guthrie said the hospital planned to submit the details of a potential partnership with Christy to the Board of Commissioners once the details were ironed out.
Cognitive Kinetics also began holding training sessions at the hospital before bidding had closed, according to schedules obtained by The News-Journal. three days before the bid process closed – on July 5 – the hospital signed an agreement with Cognitive Kinetics
A contract cover sheet indicates the hospital planned to purchase $461,448.65 in implants and $109,259 in instruments. Halifax Health is eligible to receive a rebate equal to 50 percent of Cognitive Kinetics’ earnings before interest and taxes, according to the agreement. Guthrie said that while the hospital bought the implants from Cognitive Kinetics, it has not purchased the instrumentation.
On July 17 – days after Spinal Resources raised questions about the bid process – Halifax Health reissued the bid to include both spinal instrumentation and implants, according to the legal filing. That call for bids closed last Friday. Guthrie said Halifax Health doesn’t need to competitively bid purchases of implants, although it must bid purchases for instruments. Halifax Health chose to extend its bid to include implants to give every vendor a chance to win the hospital’s business, Guthrie said. For the most part, instruments are implant-specific and can only be used with a specific manufacturer’s products.
Halifax Health banished Spinal Resources and two other vendors from the hospital before bidding closed. In a July 24 letter, the hospital criticized the vendors for removing “critical instrumentation” without notifying operating room staff or senior management, an action the hospital considered “unethical” and potentially jeopardizing patient safety. As a result, Beall wrote in the letter, Halifax Health would no longer do business with the vendors.
“The evidence in this case is overwhelming,” said Smith, who filed the complaint in Circuit Court. “I think this is a classic case of favoritism in the bid process and is exactly why we have case law in Florida that prevents this kind of bid steering.”
For the hospital and Christy, it isn’t a case of bid steering. It’s about protecting the taxpayers and patients. “We are really interested in reducing these costs — that’s the bottom line,” Guthrie said. “If it’s the right thing to do for safety and expense for the hospital we’ve got to do it.”
Tuesday, July 23, 2013
2 stories
Two stories from today's press via Google News. This first story poses a question.
Official: Rotate contracting officers between government, private sector
Former government contracting official sentenced to prison
Official: Rotate contracting officers between government, private sector
Joseph Jordan, the White House’s top contracting policy chief, floated the idea Tuesday of having contracting professionals rotate between government and the private sector. “There are all sorts of issues, I know,” said Jordan, who is the administrator for the Office of Federal Procurement Policy. “But I refuse to say this is off the table.”Does this second story hint at a reason this might not be such a great idea?
The Obama administration has placed tight rules clamping down on the so-called revolving door between government and special interests among political appointees, though Jordan’s remarks were aimed an audience of career workforce professionals.
“Is there a way where we can have people kind of bounce back and forth ... between industry and agencies?” Jordan said in remarks here at the National Contract Management Association conference.
Former government contracting official sentenced to prison
A former government contracting official, Robert Edwin Steele, 38, of Alexandria, was sentenced Friday to 48 months in prison for 14 counts of unauthorized access to a protected computer. In addition to his 48-month term of imprisonment, Judge Lee also ordered Steele to serve two years of supervised release, imposed a fine of $50,000, and required restitution $335,977.68.Of course, you need to read both stories in full for context, but why would you need to hack for information if you can just bounce back and forth and gather as you go?
When Steele left Company A on December 15, 2010, he gave verbal and written assurances to officials of Company A that he would not access its systems after his departure, and even urged them to shut down his existing accounts. That same day, however, Steele began logging into Company A’s e-mail systems using a secret administrative account which he learned about during his work for Company A. Steele immediately began downloading hundreds of proprietary documents using this administrative account.
Shortly after resigning, Steele joined another government contractor, Company C, that directly competed with Companies A and B for government contracts. At Company C, Steele worked as “Director of Law Enforcement” and prepared bids for government contracts on law enforcement projects. In that position, Steele undercut Company A’s bid on a government contract by approximately $100,000, while downloading Company A’s documents on the same contract. Although his attempt to win the bid failed, Steele continued to methodically sift through thousands of valuable documents stored on computers for Company A.
Tuesday, February 19, 2013
When the cat's away ...
... the mice will play.
Having recently raised concern about "fast-tracked" ways around prudent procurement strictures, this news item reported on The Hawai'i Procurement Institute website begs to be repeated.
But first, this bit of background. Hull: Building the campus at Palamanui
Having recently raised concern about "fast-tracked" ways around prudent procurement strictures, this news item reported on The Hawai'i Procurement Institute website begs to be repeated.
But first, this bit of background. Hull: Building the campus at Palamanui
How exciting for the UH-Hilo campus … $66 million on three separate construction projects: a new student complex; a new campus student service building for $18, million; and a new permanent Ka Haka Ula Keelikolani College of Hawaiian Language for $20 million.Now, the news item. UH official gave work to firm that built flawed softball field
I am pleased for Hilo. This project was fast tracked after Gov. Neil Abercrombie released funding in December of 2011, according to Brian Minaai, VP/UH System for Capital Improvements.
At the Jan. 9 All Campus Meeting at the University of Hawaii Center in Kealakekua, VPCC John Morton announced the $21 million low bidder on Palamanui Campus withdrew the bid and the next lowest bid is $25 million for the long-proposed Hawaii Community College-Palamanui. We do have the funding of $7.5 million from the state bond issue and $9.7 million in private funds, but it seems like the project will be unable to proceed to break ground due to the almost $8 million needed for the $25 million bid.
At this meeting President MRC Greenwood told the attendees to contact Abercrombie and the Legislature to find the rest of the funds.
Dennis Mitsunaga, who owns Mitsunaga and Associates, said the actions of UH’s associate vice president for capital improvements, Brian Minaai, on a Hilo dormitory project Mitsunaga is involved with would have been criminal had the university not had a temporary exemption from the state’s procurement code.Read more at The Hawai'i Procurement Institute web link above.
Mitsunaga, a major Democratic political donor and supporter of Gov. Neil Abercrombie, made the startling accusations in written testimony submitted Thursday to a Senate committee considering a bill about UH construction projects.
The measure, Senate Bill 1383, would shift procurement oversight of construction contracts from UH and return it to the Department of Accounting and General Services, which handles that responsibility for most other state agencies. The bill passed the Senate Higher Education Committee on Thursday but was killed later that day by the Senate Economic Development Committee. UH opposed the bill while the Abercrombie administration supported it.
In his written testimony in support of the bill, Mitsunaga said Minaai’s process for selecting consultants for nonbid projects is highly suspect and, with the exception of Mitsunaga’s firm, said Minaai picks only friends from a pool of hundreds of qualified Honolulu architects and engineers. Mitsunaga said working with Minaai on the Hilo dorm has been a nightmare for his staff. He accused Minaai of ordering the replacement of two project consultants and hiring of a third one after the selection process had been completed, adding to the cost. Minaai directed Mitsunaga’s firm to hire the third company, Palekana Permitting and Planning, to do permit processing, even though that work usually is part of the engineer or architect’s basic service and normally doesn’t involve a separate charge. Palekana’s fee for this service is $23,000.
Asked about Mitsunaga’s testimony, UH spokeswoman Lynne Waters said in a written statement that the university leadership was aware of the serious nature of some of the Mitsunaga allegations. “Please note these accusations have not been proven,” Waters wrote. “Nevertheless, a thorough investigation of the allegations will be conducted.”
When Minaai gave the general construction contract to Kobayashi, that company subcontracted what is normally considered the general contractor’s work to Isemoto Construction, the largest contractor in Hilo, according to Mitsunaga. By not awarding the contract directly to Isemoto, the state probably has to pay an extra $3 million to $4 million, he estimated.
Louis Kiang, formerly with a company that settled a breach-of-contract lawsuit against UH tied to its soon-to-open cancer center, said Mitsunaga’s testimony is consistent with experiences he had with Minaai. Kiang said he believes Minaai is trying to subvert procurement rules to benefit friends and patrons. “It’s deliberate,” Kiang said. “These things go beyond incompetence.”
Thursday, July 22, 2010
Appearances are (almost) everything
Note: OCI is the abbreviated Federal term for Organizational Conflicts of Interest.
As previously mentioned, the US Dept. of Defense has proposed a new rule for identifying and dealing with OCIs. The proposed rule is intended to incorporate principles derived from caselaw dealing with OCI, to expand the utility of the examples the rule previously provided.
The stated policy of the proposed rule is:
DOD proposes new conflict of interest rules
As the proposed rule explains (in § 203.1205-3), there are generally "three methods of resolution: avoidance, limitation on future contracting (neutralization), and mitigation." The following article from Washington Technology discusses certain objections to the "mitigation" rules.
DOD ethics rule short on mitigation, industry complains
As previously mentioned, the US Dept. of Defense has proposed a new rule for identifying and dealing with OCIs. The proposed rule is intended to incorporate principles derived from caselaw dealing with OCI, to expand the utility of the examples the rule previously provided.
The stated policy of the proposed rule is:
203.1203 Policy.It is worth reading the whole rule yourself. But since the language of such rules can be daunting, secondary sources are useful if incomplete guides, and WashingtonTecnhology.com has provided a few helpful articles on the subject.
(a) Organizational conflicts of interest can impair--
(1) The Government's ability to acquire supplies and services that
are the best value to the Government. For example--
(i) A contractor with an organizational conflict of interest may
influence the Government to pursue an acquisition outcome that is more
compatible with the contractor's interests than with the Government's
interests.
(ii) A contractor that properly had access to non-public
information while performing under a Government contract, grant,
cooperative agreement, or other transaction may be able unfairly to use
the non-public information to its advantage to win award of a future
contract.
(2) The public trust. The Government must avoid the appearance of
impropriety which taints the public view of the acquisition system.
Organizational conflicts of interest, by their mere appearance, call
into question the integrity and fairness of the competitive procurement
process. This concern exists regardless of whether any individual
contractor employee or contractor organization ever actually renders
biased advice or benefits from an unfair competitive advantage.
(b) The vast preponderance of contracting done within DoD is done
free of actual or potential conflict of interest. However, there are
circumstances under which potential or actual conflict of interest
could exist. In those instances, it is the Government's policy to
protect its interests by identifying and resolving organizational
conflicts of interest. To that end, in every acquisition in which the
contracting officer determines that contractor performance of the
contemplated work may give rise to one or more organizational conflicts
of interest, the contracting activity shall ensure that--
(1) Offerors are required to disclose facts bearing on the possible
existence of organizational conflicts of interest both prior to
contract award and on a continuing basis during contract performance;
(2) All identified organizational conflicts of interest are either
resolved or waived prior to the award of a contract (including
individual task or delivery orders); and
(3) The contract establishes a process by which the parties will
resolve any organizational conflicts of interest that arise during
contract performance.
(c) Except as may be otherwise prohibited within this regulation,
it is DoD policy that, generally, the preferred method to resolve an
organizational conflict of interest is mitigation (see 203.1205-1). It
is recognized, however, that mitigation may not be advisable in every
instance. In accordance with 203.1205-1(c), in those cases where the
contracting officer determines that mitigation is not likely to be
effective and the conflict of interest cannot otherwise be resolved,
the contracting officer shall select another offeror or request a
waiver in accordance with 203.1205-4.
DOD proposes new conflict of interest rules
Defense officials have proposed definitions and explained new types of conflicts, in order to update and address issues that have arisen since the rules last underwent a major overhaul. DOD’s new proposal seeks to clarify terms such as "contractor" to note that it means the entire company. It also adds new terms such as “marketing consultant,” because conflicts now stretch beyond contracts, according to a notice in today’s Federal Register.
The proposal lays out various types of conflicts, such as impaired objectivity and unfair access to information no one else has. Current rules in the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR) describe the conflict types by task, a point that has caused criticism of how conflicts are identified.
The proposed policy notes that contracting officers must “identify and evaluate [potential conflicts] prior to contract award, using common sense and good judgment, and the DOD preference for mitigation.”
As the proposed rule explains (in § 203.1205-3), there are generally "three methods of resolution: avoidance, limitation on future contracting (neutralization), and mitigation." The following article from Washington Technology discusses certain objections to the "mitigation" rules.
DOD ethics rule short on mitigation, industry complains
The Defense Department's proposed ethics regulations have left the defense industry feeling shortchanged. The proposal offers few details about mitigation and its use.
To protect the image of federal contracting, the government must avoid the appearance of impropriety, which taints the public view of it, according to the proposed policy. “Organizational conflicts of interest, by their mere appearance, call into question the integrity and fairness of the competitive procurement process,” it states.
In the proposed policy, officials define mitigation as a means to minimize an OCI to an “acceptable level.” The contracting officer can use a firewall to reassign company employees who may have had access to certain information or keeping a company’s supervisors from influencing an acquisition, the policy states. The contracting officer could also release the information to the rest of the bidders. Finally, a company could be required to have a subcontractor carry out the conflicted portion of the work. But the details basically end there.
[Criticizing the new proposal:] “Contracting officers may err on the side of avoiding even the appearance of an OCI and reject workable OCI mitigation plans, to the collective detriment of DOD, the public and the contractor community,” the American Bar Association wrote in its response to the proposed policy.
[Complementing the new proposal:] Industry experts said mitigation offers DOD access to more companies with expertise. It keeps competition in the acquisition process and promotes transparency. Moreover, mitigation allows contracting officers to use their expertise and experience to make decisions about the conflict, according to the Coalition for Government Procurement.
Monday, July 5, 2010
Of give and take
This is not a story about negotiation.
It is a story with a moral somewhat like paying the piper and calling the tune, and echos back to a prior post about the University of South Carolina.
Navy criticizes close relationship between Academy and donor
It is a story with a moral somewhat like paying the piper and calling the tune, and echos back to a prior post about the University of South Carolina.
Navy criticizes close relationship between Academy and donor
An anonymous donor whose close relationship with the U.S. Naval Academy caused problems for the school's finance chief is connected to a Texas company that is a defense contractor, Navy investigators concluded in a report.
The donor was known to insiders at the academy as a generous alumnus who once provided nearly $100,000 so "fine wines" could be served during receptions at the superintendent's house, the report said. He maintained such a close relationship with Robert Parsons, the academy's deputy for finance, that he kept a sport utility vehicle at Parsons' home for use when the Texas donor was in Annapolis.
The donor's role became public last week when the Navy released a report into financial irregularities at the academy.
Parsons noted that the donor often bought items from the academy's store, doing "a lot of buying and giving, most of it for his own company." That company is identified in the report as the Richardson Trident Company in Richardson, Texas.
Richardson Trident owner Thomas Bentley is a 1954 academy graduate.
The donor was known for spending up to $50,000 at a time at the Midshipman Store at the academy.
"When you go to his plant and you go to his ranch, everybody that works in his plant is wearing Navy stuff because he gives it to them," Parsons told investigators.
Investigators said one of the principal problems with the relationship was that it caused Parsons to commit multiple regulatory violations relating to the acceptance of gifts. The Navy concluded that Parsons didn't do due diligence because he failed to determine the donor's "status as a defense contractor and prohibited source."
"He's a benefactor, a donor, but he's getting special treatment and handling because of his eccentricities and the relationship that you have established with him over time," a Navy investigator said to Parsons during an interview transcribed in a 110-page report.
The report found Parsons improperly solicited gifts to the Naval Academy when he used his relationship with the donor to influence him. The gifts, including watches, sunglasses, coats and purses, went to football coaches and their families as part of a strategy to retain the coaching staff.
In the report, an investigator questions Parsons about the donor's desire to be anonymous, pointing out donors can't be anonymous because donations "might be something we want to reject."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)