Labels and Tags

Accountability (71) Adequate documentation (7) ADR in procurement (4) Allocation of risks (6) Best interest of government (11) Best practices (19) Best value (15) Bidder prejudice (11) Blanket purchase agreement (1) Bridge contract (2) Bundling (6) Cancellation and rejection (2) Centralized procurement structure (12) Changes during bid process (14) Clarifications vs Discussions (1) Competence (9) Competition vs Efficiency (29) Competitive position (3) Compliance (35) Conflict of interest (32) Contract administration (26) Contract disputes (4) Contract extension or modification (9) Contract formation (1) Contract interpretation (1) Contract terms (3) Contract types (6) Contract vs solicitation dispute (2) Contractor responsibility (20) Conviction (4) Cooperative purchasing (3) Corrective action (1) Cost and pricing (13) Debarment (4) Determinations (8) Determining responsibility (37) Disclosure requirements (7) Discussions during solicitation (10) Disposal of surplus property (3) Effective enforcement requirement (35) Effective procurement management (5) Effective specifications (36) Emergency procurement (14) eProcurement (5) Equitable tolling (2) Evaluation of submissions (22) Fair and equitable treatment (14) Fair and reasonable value (23) Fiscal effect of procurement (14) Frivolous protest (1) Good governance (12) Governmental functions (27) Guam (14) Guam procurement law (12) Improper influence (11) Incumbency (13) Integrity of system (31) Interested party (7) Jurisdiction (1) Justification (1) Life-cycle cost (1) Limits of government contracting (5) Lore vs Law (4) market research (7) Materiality (3) Methods of source selection (33) Mistakes (4) Models of Procurement (1) Needs assessment (11) No harm no foul? (8) Offer & acceptance (1) Other procurement links (14) Outsourcing (34) Past performance (12) Planning policy (34) Politics of procurement (52) PPPs (6) Prequalification (1) Principle of competition (95) Principles of procurement (25) Private vs public contract (17) Procurement authority (5) Procurement controversies series (79) Procurement ethics (19) Procurement fraud (31) Procurement lifecycle (9) Procurement philosophy (17) Procurement procedures (30) Procurement reform (63) Procurement theory (11) Procurement workforce (2) Procurment philosophy (6) Professionalism (17) Protest - formality (2) Protest - timing (12) Protests - general (37) Purposes and policies of procurement (11) Recusal (1) Remedies (17) Requirement for new procurement (4) Resolution of protests (4) Responsiveness (14) Restrictive specifications (5) Review procedures (13) RFQ vs RFP (1) Scope of contract (16) Settlement (2) Social preference provisions (60) Sole source (48) Sovereign immunity (3) Staffing (8) Standard commercial products (3) Standards of review (2) Standing (6) Stays and injunctions (6) Structure of procurement (1) Substantiation (9) Surety (1) Suspension (6) The procurement record (1) The role of price (10) The subject matter of procurement (23) Trade agreements vs procurement (1) Training (33) Transparency (63) Uniformity (6) Unsolicited proposals (3)
Showing posts with label Uniformity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Uniformity. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

For the times, they are a'changing -- or are they?

Here is the first of a couple of intriguing and thought-provoking current articles, each from very good sources (or so I've observed), considering aspects of the current "changes" in federal government acquisition. The second will be in the next post (see here). 

Remember, I take indecent liberty with articles advanced here, to provide context to students of local government procurement, and Guam's in particular. Thus, I slice and dice, omit great swaths of critical data, paraphrase, rearrange, and perhaps tilt to one side or the other, the original information in these articles. It is imperative that you read the articles in their original form and the authors' intent, and not rely on my iteration of them.



“Other Transaction Authorities” might seem like a risky new acquisition method, but it’s been around longer than the Federal Acquisition Regulation.
Before there was a Federal Acquisition Regulation regime describing the many procurement laws adopted at the federal level in the last three decades plus, there were “other transaction authorities,” also known by the shorthand OTAs or OTs. This contracting method, outside the usual federal process, is not widely used and even less understood. But that’s beginning to change. “Even though it’s been around for a fairly lengthy period of time, it’s just not been used very much. So, people are afraid of it because they haven’t seen how it’s worked,” Douglas Maughan, director of the Homeland Security Department's Science and Technology Directorate’s Cyber Security Division, told Nextgov.

It comes across as new and scary but is potentially a game-changing acquisition model and it is catching fire across government. After all, it has no structure, no built in roadmaps, accountability or paper trails. But, it doesn’t have to be scary and is not really all that new, if you are a big believer in getting to the future by going back before the dawn of modern procurement rules-based practices. It has roots going back to the 1950's, long before the FAR and the Competition in Contracting Act. Three decades later that same language came to be used to grant the Defense Department similar authorities. “Under these authorities, agencies may develop agreements that are not required to follow a standard format or include terms and conditions that are typically required when using traditional mechanisms,” according to a Government Accountability Office definition. In other words, OTAs rely more on principles than rules.

By 1994, that authority had been broadened beyond research to include prototyping and then updated again in 2017 to enable contracts to move into production after successful prototypes. Over that time, several departments have been granted other transaction authorities, including Defense, Energy, Health and Human Services, Homeland Security and Transportation. Under these departments, five component agencies have also been given explicit OT authority: the Federal Aviation Administration, Transportation Security Administration, National Institutes of Health, Domestic Nuclear Detection Office and Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy, or ARPA-E.

Homeland Security’s Science and Technology Directorate awarded its first OT contract for cybersecurity in February 2016 after launching its Silicon Valley Innovation program. While the primary focus for OTs is on research and development, not all agencies are using them for that express purpose. For instance, TSA and NASA use them for other services, such as airport security, education and outreach, according to GAO.

The reluctance to use OTs is based on “fear of giving people a lot of discretion,” said Nash, the procurement law expert. “If you’re in a government agency and you’ve got an inspector general and you’ve got congressional oversight … there’s a tendency to be pretty cautious about how you do business.”

That said, “It’s the same oversight you have over any other transaction where you’re giving a company money,” Nash said. “The problem is, if you have a lot of discretion, you take away a lot of the rules, but you still have basic ethics problems. If you gave an OT to your father without telling anybody else about it, you’d have the same ethical violation you’d have with a contract or a grant.”

The other major roadblock is the fear of funding projects that don't pan out, Nash said. “People have a hard time understanding that when you fund research, over half the time you’re funding failure,” Nash said. “You do not get 100 percent payout from research; and you shouldn’t expect it.” If you were to see a 100 percent success rate in funding research, that would just mean you weren't looking far enough into the future. “There’s nothing wrong with failure,” Nash said.

Homeland Security’s Maughan agreed. “We have a lot of successes we can talk about with return on investment, but even the failures” have some return, he said. He cited a program to downsize a Defense Department radar system to fit on smaller drones used by U.S. Customs and Border Protection. The company awarded a contract ultimately failed to produce a working prototype, but everyone involved still consider it a successful venture. The company was able to get funding to move their research forward and CBP learned what is feasible for the size of drones they use. “They were still really happy about being part of the program,” Maughan said. “We helped them move the technology down the roadmap toward a smaller device and that will help them in some of their DOD missions.”

“I think there’s still some return on investment," Maughan added. "Our investment was less than $400,000 with them, so I think it falls into the category of: If you’re going to fail, fail quickly."

Had the office used a traditional contracting method for this project, it likely would have taken six to 12 months just to make an award, let alone discover that the idea would not work. Under the Science and Technology Directorate's OT authority, the time from application to award can be as short as 60 to 90 days.

Broadening OTs beyond research seems to increase their use accordingly. GAO reports that while most agencies do fewer than 75 OT transactions a year, TSA and NASA conducted 640 and 3,220, respectively, in 2014 alone.

Many in government have been reluctant to use their OT authorities precisely because of the lack of regulations governing their use. Since the contracts exist outside of the Federal Acquisition Regulation, they can be written with far less stringent requirements. But that also means there are fewer protections along the way to avoid a catastrophic contracting failure—one that could land a government official in front of a congressional committee.

“Even though it’s not FAR-based, we still have to do procurement documentation, we have to do a source-selection plan that says what are the criteria by which we’re going to evaluate proposals. For the most part, it’s the same as a traditional FAR-based contract, it’s just that the vehicle you’re using is not a FAR-based vehicle,” Maughan said. Despite appearances, “It’s not the wild, wild west,” Maughan added. “You still have to make sure the government is making the decisions on what gets awarded. Even still, we have a contracting officer—who’s called an ‘other transaction authority officer’—so you’re still doing the same kinds of things with the contracting folks as part of the team.”

The company was able to get funding to move their research forward and CBP learned what is feasible for the size of drones they use. “They were still really happy about being part of the program,” Maughan said. “We helped them move the technology down the roadmap toward a smaller device and that will help them in some of their DOD missions.”

“I think there’s still some return on investment," he added. "Our investment was less than $400,000 with them, so I think it falls into the category of: If you’re going to fail, fail quickly."

Had the office used a traditional contracting method for this project, it likely would have taken six to 12 months just to make an award, let alone discover that the idea would not work. Under the Science and Technology Directorate's OT authority, the time from application to award can be as short as 60 to 90 days.

“It’s not a solution for every case,” Maughan said. “It’s not the answer for all things,” he added. “If you’re trying to get startups with new innovation, then an OT might be good for you as an organization. There’s a little bit of risk working with a startup company—if you’re really just looking for a solutions provider and you’re not willing to take some risk, then an OT might not be for you.”

Nash agreed and offered some advice to agencies interested in getting in on OTs. “Let’s say you find a company out there that’s never done business with the government and that has some fascinating technology. You go to them and you say, ‘How could we sponsor you to do this? And we’ll give you all the money.’ Well, they may say, ‘The only way we’ll deal with you is this, this, this and this,’” Nash said. “We’re talking about intellectual property issues; we’re talking about accounting issues. And a normal contracting office might be pretty darn uncomfortable when they hear that because that’s not their norm.”

“You’ve got accounting problems. You want to make sure the company spends the money for what you gave them the money,” which can be particularly difficult, as one advantage of an OT contract is the company does not have to abide by government accounting standards. “But you need to make sure they have some systems.

“You need to worry about intellectual property—who’s going to have rights to it. And that would mean that if they said, ‘We’ll only do it if you take zero rights,’ that would be a problem. You might do it but you certainly would know that that’s a flashpoint that you would worry about. And then, of course, you’ve got to worry about audit rights because the government always wants to be able to audit and the contractor might not want to be audited.
Additional reading for this subject: Acquisition Disruption - Innovative Concepts in Government Contracting
Excerpt:  "This term is not defined by statute or regulation; it is best defined by what it is not. An OTA is not a procurement contract, grant, or cooperative agreement. It is a different type of agreement with the government – one that is not subject to the strict regulatory regimes that characterize other types of contracting." 

In my mind, adherence to principles is absolutely necessary for a successful procurement regime, but principles are not, in themselves, sufficient, any more than rules alone are.  See, The ethics of paper work.

Tuesday, June 2, 2015

Special needs and higher education

I'm not quite sure what it is about public universities and their yearning freedom from a scrutable contracting regime that is good enough for the rest of tax-supported government enterprise. The prior post was about plans to exempt Illinois colleges from common procurement practices of the state. Today I read of another such move afoot in Wisconsin:

UW funding cut trimmed
Lawmakers on the powerful budget committee trimmed Gov. Scott Walker’s proposed $300 million two-year funding cut to the University of Wisconsin System and introduced significant changes to faculty tenure and shared governance that will take away some power from faculty, students and staff and give more power to campus chancellors and the UW System Board of Regents, who are appointed by Walker. The proposed changes by the Joint Finance Committee also officially put an end to Walker’s proposal, supported by top System officials, to spin the system off from state control to be operated as a public authority.

The lawmakers restored at least in part two key operating flexibilities that were included in Walker’s public authority model. They’d be exempt from state oversight on purchasing and procurement once the regents develop their own rules governing them. They’d also be exempt from state rules on building projects provided the projects are funded entirely through gifts or grants.

The first proposal reminds me of a prior post about the University of Hawaii, and the second one of a post about the University of South Carolina.

The situation in Hawaii is particularly worth recalling.

UH’s procurement privilege could release $337M, May 23, 2010
The University of Hawaii system will be exempt from following the state’s public procurement code, which it has largely blamed for its backlog of deferred maintenance and capital improvement projects, under a new law that takes effect July 1.

University officials say the exemption, effective for two years, will help the 10-campus system operate more efficiently and with greater flexibility in awarding contracts for goods and services, including construction work. The university system has pointed to the existing code, which requires larger contracts to be awarded through a competitive sealed bidding process, for tying up projects and increasing costs as a result.

“This will allow the university to get construction projects started more efficiently and at a faster pace — and it has the added benefit of saving taxpayers’ money by allowing us to take advantage of current construction costs, which are coming in 30 [percent] to 40 percent lower in some cases.”

House Bill 347, which Gov. Linda Lingle signed into law May 6 as Act 82, allows the statewide public university system to come up with its own procurement process “in lieu of” the state procurement code. This was the sixth consecutive year that UH asked lawmakers for the exemption. It previously had flexibility from 1998 through 2004.
And how did that work out for them?

UH to lose procurement exemption as bill flops Apr 27, 2012

University of Hawaii Procurement Under Fire for Wasting Millions of Dollars on Fraud and Corruption March 12th, 2013
Local construction industry leaders are questioning as the University doles out a total of $622 million in contracts including $206 million for major contracts now underway, $229 million of major projects being procured and $187 million in health, safety, code and repairs and maintenance projects.

Dennis Mitsunaga, a successful and politically connected government contractor who has worked for virtually every state agency over the last 40 years, sent shock waves through his industry when he testified at a recent Senate hearing about waste, fraud and abuse that he witnessed firsthand in the University’s procurement system. Mitsunaga, a practicing structural engineer since 1969 and a general contractor since 1971, has worked on several projects including the University of Hawaii Chemistry building, the University of Hawaii Cancer Research Center, the Rainbow Baseball Stadium, and the University of Hawaii- Hilo Housing Project, Phase 1.

He focused much of his criticism on Brian Minaai, a University administrator who has overseen the capital improvement projects for all of the campuses since March 2008. “Brian’s process for selection of non-bid contracts is highly suspect. His selection committee consists of two ‘yes men’ assistants and a third member from the department involved in the project. In essence he controls two out of the three votes he himself makes each selection. He selects only friends from a pool of hundreds of qualified architects and engineers in Honolulu. An investigation will show that the consultants he selected were very small and not the best qualified for the projects he gave them,” Mitsunaga added.

Mitsunaga, who has two companies, Mitsunaga and Associates and Mitsunaga Construction, said Minaai directed him to replace his own civil engineering company on the job with Minaai’s pick, Wesley Segawa, even though Mitsunaga and Associates had applied for and was selected for the project as the civil engineer of record. Segawa charged the University another $293,260 for the civil engineering work and Mitsunaga and Associates had to add a 10 percent coordination fee of $29,326 plus General Excise tax; boosting the cost of the project by $30,000.

Minaai also directed Mitsunaga and Associates to replace Kimura International as the environmental assessment consultant with Wilson Okamoto and directed Mitsunaga and Associates to use Palekana Permitting and Planning to do the permit and processing at a cost of $23,000. “That work is usually covered by the companies involved so the $23,000 was an additional cost, plus a 10 percent coordination fee and GE Tax,” Mitsunaga said.

On another job for the University of Hawaii Cancer Research Center in Kakaako, Palekana Permitting and Planning charged $120,000 to process the permits even though the Kakaako district is currently exempt from such permitting.

Other architects and engineers have privately confirmed Mitsunaga’s claims. One claimed on average on University construction jobs, a construction management firm will charge 10 to 28 percent of the construction contract instead of 5 to 6 percent other state agencies would allow for the same service. Similar allegations were made public when the University of Hawaii agreed to pay $2.5 million to settle a lawsuit that alleged cronyism played a role in the award of a key development contract at the $120 million Cancer Research Center of Hawaii.

The University of Hawaii received a great deal of autonomy in 1999 from Legislature, including management of its own legal affairs, tuition and salaries and contracting.

But some senators said their own investigations have shown the University administration is failing in all of these areas. In addition, students have complained about tuition skyrocketing at the school, making it unaffordable for many local residents, because tuition has been increasing by 141 percent over the last 11 years.

Senate President Donna Mercado Kim proposed several bills this session that would take some of the power away from the University administration and its president, MRC Greenwood, including procurement responsibilities, and help bring what some legislators believe is excessive spending under control. However, during two recent Senate hearings, University officials opposed the plan to transfer procurement responsibilities to the state, and maintained autonomy is necessary.

The procurement bill passed the Senate Higher Education Committee this session, but was killed by Senators,







Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Procurement reforms du jour

Scotland.  Local preference and training.

Scottish procurement reform bill sent to Parliament
Changes to public procurement rules in Scotland that will make it easier for small businesses to bid for public contracts have moved closer, as a reform bill goes to Parliament. The Procurement Reform Bill sets out how European legislation will be interpreted and put into practice in Scotland.

First minister Alex Salmond said the bill would generate new training and employment opportunities. The Bill will require public bodies to consider how procurement activity can improve the economic, social and environmental wellbeing of local communities.

“Our Bill here in Scotland will give Parliament the opportunity to go further than Wales, by taking the power to regulate how companies are selected to bid and how their suitability should be assessed,” he said. “These regulations will address blacklisting, working within the framework of EU law.”
Namibia.  Centralization and effective review.

Namibia introduces legislation as part of procurement reform
The country seeks to streamline large public sector procurement, help SMEs and reduce loopholes.
Namibian procurement reform edges closer
The Public Procurement Bill would create a Central Procurement Board to centralise the management of high-value contracts across the public sector, while a review panel would give aggrieved bidders a route for redress without having to go to the courts.

Minister of finance Saara Kuugongelwa-Amadhila said as she tabled the bill: “The intention is to provide for the speedy resolution of such complaints, which will minimise the frequency of bidders’ recourse to court actions.”

The bill also seeks to stimulate economic growth by giving preference to local businesses and socially disadvantaged groups, according to the state-owned New Era newspaper.

The new law also repeals the Tender Board Act of 1996, which is described as “no longer sufficient or adequate to achieve the country’s developmental objectives”.

Unlike the tender board, which dealt with almost all public sector contracts, the new board would only deal with contracts over a certain threshold value, with lower value contracts dealt with by the public body concerned.
Singapore.  Integrity enhanced.

Trust in public service crucial to success of govt policies: PM Lee
Singapore Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong has emphasised that a major determinant of success in implementing government policies that improve the lives of people is trust in the government, and in particular, the public service. He said it is important that Singaporeans trust that the government understands their needs, is committed to the people, and will remain a steward of the public good.

He said: "Ultimately, integrity is not about systems and processes but values. The government must have a culture that doesn't tolerate any wrongdoing or dishonesty and the public officers must have the right values -- service, integrity, excellence -- and each officer and the service as a whole must take pride in being clean, incorrupt. "This is your command responsibility, you cannot devolve it to your subordinates, you cannot leave it to your procurement or financial officers. You are the boss, you are in charge."

Mr Lee also stressed that critical to maintaining public trust is upholding the highest standards of integrity -- something which has been painstakingly built up over many years. Mr Lee said because there is integrity, businesses can compete fairly instead of relying on improper influence. And because there is integrity, public officers can be given the discretion to exercise judgement when managing multi-million dollar projects.

The Prime Minister emphasised that one reason why Singapore has been able to maintain a clean system is that it pays public servants properly in line with the quality of the officers and the value of their contributions. He stressed that this policy will continue. In return he said, Singapore insists on the high standards of performance and integrity, and if an officer is discovered to have been dishonest, he will be punished to the full extent of the law.

Mr Lee said this principle will be maintained even when it may be embarrassing to the government. Mr Lee acknowledged that the past year has seen a string of high-profile cases involving public officers, including some senior ones in sex for favours scandals, procurement lapses and fraud cases.

He said beyond these individual cases, the public service must strengthen its systems to uphold reputation for integrity and incorruptibility, and dispel any doubts that standards have fallen. Head of Civil Service, Peter Ong, said Mr Lee's presence at the annual seminar was a clear demonstration of the type of leadership he is encouraging public sector leaders to show - that is to lead by example and model the right values for staff.
Singapore officials to declare casino trips after graft scandal
Singapore civil servants must declare casino visits starting Tuesday, authorities said, months after a senior anti-graft official was charged with embezzling state money to fund his gambling habit. Civil servants must declare within seven days if they have visited the city-state's two casinos more than four times a month, or if they purchase an annual pass that allows unlimited access, the government's Public Service Division (PSD) said.

Government officials in certain positions where "misconduct will have significant reputational risk to the Public Service" must declare every visit within seven days, it said in a statement. Singapore pays its civil servants some of the highest government salaries globally in what it says is a deterrent to corruption.

Civil servants involved in gaming enforcement as well as others who represent the government in business dealings with the two casino operators will remain barred from visiting the casinos unless in an official capacity.

The agency said it was also bringing in compulsory job rotations and block leave for some officials holding positions that "are more susceptible to being suborned and exploited if the incumbent were to remain in the same job for too long". "Officers are expected to maintain the highest standards of personal conduct and integrity, and their actions must not bring the Public Service into disrepute or call into question its impartiality," PSD said.

The move follows a string of high-profile corruption cases in the city-state, including one involving Edwin Yeo Seow Hiang, an assistant director at the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB), the country's graft-busting agency. Large-scale graft cases remain rare in Singapore, a thriving business hub and financial centre, and the government has jealously guarded its reputation as among the least corrupt in the world.
New Zealand.  Uniformity.

New government procurement rules come into effect
The new rules replace 44 different pieces of legislation, Cabinet directives and miscellaneous guidance released by a multitude of government agencies over many years. The emphasis will shift from who can deliver the lowest upfront costs to who can deliver the best value for money and other direct financial benefits over the life of a contract.

“By... making the tendering process consistent across the public service, we expect to make our procurement business more accessible to smaller local firms who previously may have been discouraged by the process,” Economic Development Minister Stephen Joyce said in April when announcing the changes.

The new procurement rules will apply to all Public Service departments, the New Zealand Police and the Defence Force. Other State Sector agencies and the broader Public Service will also be encouraged to adopt them.


Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Protests: Rare and worth it

You will gain more by reading the linked articles than accepting this rendition at face value.

Steven Maser Authors Study on the Federal Bidding Process
Steven Maser, Professor of Public Management and Public Policy, recently authored a study funded by the Acquisition Research Program at the Naval Postgraduate School and distributed for practitioners through the IBM Center for the Business of Government. It evaluated the way government agencies manage the bidding process when they purchase products or services.

What Maser found was eye-opening. In the past few years the number of bid protests, where a rejected bidder complains to the Government Accountability Office, has been on the rise although the total number is small. Maser found that in most cases bid protests were not sustained.

However, bid protests aren’t necessarily bad. Maser argues that they provide an important benchmark. "In general, the system serves a very good purpose of helping the government actually police itself," he said during an interview with Federal News Radio. The study notes that the more transparency and disclosure that’s built into the process, the less likely a bid protest will occur. It recommends that agencies should simplify the requirements they create for the products and services they need and adequately train staff members who will evaluate proposals.


Bid Protests Are Worth Their Costs, Ex-Procurement Chief Says>
Contractors on the losing side of a competitive bidding who protest to the Government Accountability Office do not hurt or game the procurement system as some critics allege, says a forthcoming study.

The percentage of contracts that spark protests is also comparatively small, while the overall impact of the protest procedure is healthy, according to Dan Gordon, the former Obama administration head of the Office of Federal Procurement Policy and now associate dean for government procurement law studies at George Washington University Law School.

In an article set for publication this spring in the Public Contract Law Journal, a copy of which was provided to Government Executive, Gordon wrote that “there exist a number of misperceptions concerning bid protest statistics that deserve attention, because these misperceptions can taint judgments about the benefits and costs of protests. In particular, even people quite familiar with the federal acquisition system often believe that protests are more common than they really are, and they believe, inaccurately, that protesters use the protest process as a business tactic to obtain contracts from the government.”

Because of the difficulty of knowing precisely how many contracts the federal government awards each year, the reports of protest to GAO -- which reported 2,353 in fiscal 2011 -- are actually overstated, Gordon says. “Between approximately 99.3 percent and 99.5 percent of procurements were not protested,” even though the trend since the 1990s has been upward. That’s because of increases in procurement spending, the article says.

“It is, of course, true that very high-dollar procurements are much more likely to be protested: the higher the dollar value, the greater the likelihood of a protest,” he said. “For a company that loses the competition for a $100 million contract, with all the bid and proposal costs that competing entails, the additional cost of filing a protest may seem minimal, so that filing a protest can be very tempting.”

Of protests making it through the full GAO process in fiscal 2010, only a handful succeeded in winning the contract, according to Gordon’s calculations.

Overall, Gordon finds the bid protest process to be positive for the procurement system, citing several advantages:

>Protests introduce a relatively low-cost form of accountability into acquisition systems by providing disgruntled participants a forum for airing their complaints;
>They can increase potential bidders’ confidence in the integrity of the procurement process if the GAO is directly responsive to participants’ complaints, leading more players to participate;
>Protests can increase the public’s confidence in the integrity of the public procurement process; --The known availability of the protest avenue empowers those in contracting agencies who face pressure to act improperly;
>Protest decisions made public provide a high level of transparency into what is happening in the federal procurement system; and
>Protests provide guidance.
Bid protesting system helps agencies police themselves
It's nothing personal, but bid protests are one way of keeping the federal procurement system honest. Congress and the Government Accountability Office have been encouraging greater transparency in contracting. One way of doing that is giving the unsuccessful bidder the opportunity for a debriefing, in which the contracting agency describes how the bidder failed to secure the contract and how they could be more successful in the future.

"What the agencies have some fear of is the more they disclose, the more a company or an attorney for that company will find a basis for a bid protest."

According to Maser, if agencies were more open at the beginning of the bidding process, the likelihood of a bid protest could be reduced. "But again, there's some risk that's inherent in this that they'll never be completely eliminated," he said.

Friday, August 24, 2012

Canada procurement Ombudsman issues report card

Government-appointed watchdog highlights major problems with federal procurement
A federal watchdog’s new report highlights a series of problems in how Ottawa procures some of its $20 billion in annual goods and services, including complaints about sole-sourced contracts, government ignoring its own rules, and departments doing business with firms known for producing “inferior” work.

The ombudsman’s office is responsible for reviewing complaints on the awarding of federal contracts for goods below $25,000 and for services less than $100,000 (which amounts to 90 per cent of all federal contracts). However, the office can review any complaint on the administration of a federal contract for goods and services, regardless of dollar value, as well as examine the purchasing practices of federal departments and agencies to assess fairness, openness and transparency.

The document highlights two “unexpected areas of concern” with federal procurement, including vendor performance and “the disparate nature” of procurement documents. But it also identifies problems with lack of training among procurement officials, questionable sole-sourcing of contracts among more than 100 federal departments and agencies, and concerns that government favours certain suppliers with its purchasing.

Six years after an optional certification program was introduced, only 26 of the approximately 3,200 procurement specialists working in the federal government have been certified at the program’s first of three levels, and none have been completely certified.

Some small and medium-sized businesses complained the patchwork system of procurement rules throughout the federal government is a barrier to doing business, the report says, while government officials highlighted the inefficiencies of preparing different procurement documents for similar services.

“This fragmented approach within the federal government is allowing suppliers identified as underperforming by one department to successfully bid and be awarded contracts from other departments,” the report says.

NDP deputy finance critic Guy Caron said the report highlights a troubling trend in government sole-sourcing contracts, when more competition should be promoted to ensure government receives good value for the goods and services it purchases. “The fact that we have to have competition means that we should rely less and less on those advance contracts, and we do more and more, which to me signifies a problem,” Caron said.

“What this underlies is the need for more transparency and the need to actually lower the costs of those various goods and services towards competition. I really don’t understand why government is actually going toward more of those (ACAN) contracts.”

Similar:
Major flaws in Ottawa's contract bidding process

Tuesday, July 3, 2012

If not centralization, at least uniformity: Australia

The rules of public buying have changed
The old guidelines applied to all Financial Management and Accountability Act agencies and to certain Commonwealth Authorities and Companies Act bodies.
Since those guidelines were introduced, the Finance Department has noted that a ''wide range of procurement approaches'' have been used across agencies. This has proven both complex and unwieldy. A lack of clarity in the guidelines resulted in the use of different practices across otherwise similar procurements.

The Finance Department recently revised the Commonwealth Procurement Guidelines. The Commonwealth Procurement Rules, which replace the guidelines, came into effect this week, on July 1.

These new rules are intended to update and clarify the old guidelines, and streamline procurement procedures for Commonwealth agencies. The rules also focus on whole-of-government arrangements, notably coordinated procurement. While the core framework remains largely unchanged, the rules clarify requirements for the conduct of agency procurements.

The rules emphasise that agencies must use whole-of-government coordinated procurement panels where they exist. Exemptions to using these panels are limited

Finance has changed the terms that the guidelines used to describe methods of procurement, from ''select tender'' to ''pre-qualified tender'', and from ''direct source'' to ''limited tender'' (the term ''open tender'' remains unchanged). The new terms are also defined in more detail and align with the emphasis on value for money and ''economical'' use of Commonwealth resources.

Officials must maintain appropriate documentation for each procurement and retain those documents in accordance with the Archives Act. Agencies must also have appropriate documentation with the supplier (such as a contract).
All contracts and amendments must be reported on AusTender within 42 days of entering into (or amending) contracts if they are worth $10,000 or more for FMA Act agencies. All standing offers, regardless of value, must be reported.


The rules specify that the request documentation ''must include a complete description of the procurement, the conditions for participation, the minimum form and content requirements and all evaluation criteria'' (paragraph 10.6). Thus, it will not be possible to ''hide'' evaluation criteria or develop criteria during the evaluation process.
This is supported by the requirement in paragraph 10.8 that agencies must ensure that tenderers are dealt with fairly and in a non-discriminatory manner.

The shift in emphasis from guidelines to rules suggests the government is serious about maintaining its reputation as a ''respected, transparent and accountable procurer''.

Read more at article link above.