Labels and Tags

Accountability (71) Adequate documentation (7) ADR in procurement (4) Allocation of risks (6) Best interest of government (11) Best practices (19) Best value (15) Bidder prejudice (11) Blanket purchase agreement (1) Bridge contract (2) Bundling (6) Cancellation and rejection (2) Centralized procurement structure (12) Changes during bid process (14) Clarifications vs Discussions (1) Competence (9) Competition vs Efficiency (29) Competitive position (3) Compliance (35) Conflict of interest (32) Contract administration (26) Contract disputes (4) Contract extension or modification (9) Contract formation (1) Contract interpretation (1) Contract terms (3) Contract types (6) Contract vs solicitation dispute (2) Contractor responsibility (20) Conviction (4) Cooperative purchasing (3) Corrective action (1) Cost and pricing (13) Debarment (4) Determinations (8) Determining responsibility (37) Disclosure requirements (7) Discussions during solicitation (10) Disposal of surplus property (3) Effective enforcement requirement (35) Effective procurement management (5) Effective specifications (36) Emergency procurement (14) eProcurement (5) Equitable tolling (2) Evaluation of submissions (22) Fair and equitable treatment (14) Fair and reasonable value (23) Fiscal effect of procurement (14) Frivolous protest (1) Good governance (12) Governmental functions (27) Guam (14) Guam procurement law (12) Improper influence (11) Incumbency (13) Integrity of system (31) Interested party (7) Jurisdiction (1) Justification (1) Life-cycle cost (1) Limits of government contracting (5) Lore vs Law (4) market research (7) Materiality (3) Methods of source selection (33) Mistakes (4) Models of Procurement (1) Needs assessment (11) No harm no foul? (8) Offer & acceptance (1) Other procurement links (14) Outsourcing (34) Past performance (12) Planning policy (34) Politics of procurement (52) PPPs (6) Prequalification (1) Principle of competition (95) Principles of procurement (25) Private vs public contract (17) Procurement authority (5) Procurement controversies series (79) Procurement ethics (19) Procurement fraud (31) Procurement lifecycle (9) Procurement philosophy (17) Procurement procedures (30) Procurement reform (63) Procurement theory (11) Procurement workforce (2) Procurment philosophy (6) Professionalism (17) Protest - formality (2) Protest - timing (12) Protests - general (37) Purposes and policies of procurement (11) Recusal (1) Remedies (17) Requirement for new procurement (4) Resolution of protests (4) Responsiveness (14) Restrictive specifications (5) Review procedures (13) RFQ vs RFP (1) Scope of contract (16) Settlement (2) Social preference provisions (60) Sole source (48) Sovereign immunity (3) Staffing (8) Standard commercial products (3) Standards of review (2) Standing (6) Stays and injunctions (6) Structure of procurement (1) Substantiation (9) Surety (1) Suspension (6) The procurement record (1) The role of price (10) The subject matter of procurement (23) Trade agreements vs procurement (1) Training (33) Transparency (63) Uniformity (6) Unsolicited proposals (3)
Showing posts with label Principle of competition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Principle of competition. Show all posts

Sunday, June 21, 2020

NASA Adminsitrator bounced by an unusually cozy relationship with federal regulators

Although federal procurement directives are moving towards acquisitions of supplies and services described in terms of common commercial standards, some needs of the government can only be met by particularized specifications and contractors. Take, for instance, spaceships (although we are now seeing the development of private sector contractors even in the space field, a circumstance not dreamed of when space exploration began in the era of Sputnik).

Why commercial standards? In a word, competition. As the American Bar Association Model Procurement Code elucidates,
"Fair and open competition is a basic tenet of public procurement. Such competition reduces the opportunity for favoritism and inspires public confidence that contracts are awarded equitably and economically." Code § 3-201, Commentary 3.
Indeed, an fundamental purpose and policy of the Model Procurement Code is "to foster effective broad-based competition within the free enterprise system". §1-101((2)(g). And, this is not a mere aspiration. "It is the general policy of this [State] to procure standard commercial products whenever practicable. In developing specifications, accepted commercial standards shall be used and unique requirements shall be avoided, to the extent practicable." MPC Regulation § R4-201.01.2 "All specifications shall seek to promote overall economy for the purposes intended and encourage competition in satisfying the [State's] needs, and shall not be unduly restrictive." MPC § 4-205. Further, in general, "Correction or withdrawal of a bid because of an inadvertent, non-judgmental mistake in the bid requires careful consideration to protect the integrity of the competitive bidding system, and to assure fairness. If the mistake is attributable to an error in judgment, the bid may not be corrected." MPC § R3-202.11.1

One of the big impediments to preferring standard commercial products and standards is the pushback and lobbying of entrenched contractors, the "good old boy" network. The basis for such a network is understandable from the standpoint of preferring the devil we know, but it runs foul of the demands of procurement when we become enamored of those well-known devils.

This post, and the article from the Washington Post that inspired it, illustrate the kind of relationship that can, and often does, call such discrimination into question. Once again, I caution that I slice and dice, rearrange, omit, and shade original articles to fit the didactic intent and space of this blawg, to be read as a hypothetical for educational purposes, and not as evidence or insinuation of guilt or wrongdoing. So, you are IMPLORED to link to and read the source material cited, and do not to rely on the rendition here.

Boeing tried to amend bid after guidance from NASA official, raising concerns it received inside information
After a top NASA official contacted a senior Boeing executive about a bid to win a contract potentially worth hundreds of millions of dollars, the company attempted to amend its proposal past the deadline for doing so, according to the article. That raised alarm bells inside the space agency, where officials were concerned that Boeing was attempting to take advantage of inside information. The conversation at the root of the investigation was between Loverro and Jim Chilton, the senior vice president of Boeing’s space and launch division, putting one of the company’s top executives in the middle of the probe.

Federal procurement regulations encourage the government to communicate with contractors about their bids to help agencies get the products and services that best fit their requirements. “The question becomes when is it okay to have those discussions, and more importantly, whether you have to have the exact same discussions with all potential bidders,” said David Berteau, the president and chief executive of the Professional Services Council, a trade group that represents federal contractors. According to the article, a person with direct knowledge of the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the ongoing investigation said: “I can tell you with 100 percent confidence that no laws were broken. What we are talking about are conversations that occurred outside the normal dictated channels but didn’t violate the sanctity of the procurement process.”

According to a congressional aide with knowledge of the matter, NASA procurement officials grew concerned earlier this year when Boeing contacted the agency, saying it wanted to change parts of its bid for the lunar lander contract. Not only was it late in the process, but the specificity of Boeing’s proposed changes raised “red flags” inside NASA that the company had received inside information improperly. NASA officials wondered, “How did they know to raise this issue or try to fix this issue?” according to the aide, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the ongoing investigation.

NASA officials have stressed that the agency has gone to great lengths to ensure the integrity of the contract awards, worth $1 billion combined, that went to teams led by Jeff Bezos’s Blue Origin and Dynetics, as well as Elon Musk’s SpaceX.

Ultimately, the matter was referred to NASA’s inspector general office, and NASA’s leadership last month forced Doug Loverro to resign from his position as the associate administrator of NASA’s human spaceflight directorate. In his resignation letter, Loverro wrote that he took “a risk earlier in the year because I judged it necessary to fulfill our mission. Now, over the balance of time, it is clear that I made a mistake in that choice for which I alone must bear the consequences.” The inspector general investigation could be another headache for Boeing, under fire for having an unusually cozy relationship with federal regulators, especially if it identifies wrongdoing on the part of Boeing senior executives.

In an interview with The Post last month, Loverro said he was trying to speed up the Artemis moon program to meet a White House mandate to return astronauts to the lunar surface by 2024. “It had to do with moving fast on Artemis, and I don’t want to characterize it in any more detail than that,” he said.

But the probe is also focusing on Boeing, officials said. “This certainly goes both ways. It’s one thing to have a mistake that violated the Integrity in Procurement Act,” the aide said. “It’s another if the company took that information and acted on it.”
FURTHER READING:
• Special Compliance Requirements for Government Contractors Part 1, and Part 2

• FAR 52.203-13 Contractor Code of Business Ethics and Conduct.

Wednesday, December 11, 2019

How do you determine prospective contractor responsibility if you don't know who the contractor really is?

The ABA Model Procurement Code, as do most other procurement regimes, require the government to know who it is doing business with.  "It is important that the bidder of offeror will be a responsible contractor -- that the contractor has the financial ability, resources, skills, capability, and business integrity necessary to perform the contract."  (MPC 3-401, Comment 1)

"The unreasonable failure of a bidder or offeror to promptly supply information in connection with an inquiry with respect to responsibility may be grounds for a determination of nonresponsibility with respect to such bidder or offeror".  (MPC 3-401(1))

Since the time the MPC was enacted in 1979, other laws were being developed to facilitate cloaks of invisibility for entities to hide the identities of the money, ownership, assets and control of  businesses organized under such laws.  The most recent has been the promulgation of a Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (ULLCA) in 1995.  Use of LLCs to provide ownership anonymity of assets, and businesses, is easy (see "How to Hide Ownership of a Company?") and notorious (see, "Anonymous Owner, L.L.C.: Why It Has Become So Easy to Hide in the Housing Market").  The ULLCA, both in original form and in a revised 2006 Model, has been adopted on Guam and many U.S states.

This is becoming a problem, both in the U.S. and Europe, and presumably elsewhere, as indicated in the following article published by the Association of Certified Financial Crime Specialists (ACFCS):

Report roundup: EU calls U.S. a ‘secrecy haven,’ GAO highlights commercial owner opacity, and more, posted March 16, 2017.
This week’s Report Roundup has a common theme running through hundreds of pages of reports: the risk of opaque ownership structures and how, in the United States and beyond, the inability for countries to collect beneficial ownership information is a magnet for bad actors.

In the U.S., that means a major ally in the European Union (EU) calling out a longstanding gap in the country’s anti-money laundering (AML) defenses: the federal government allowing certain states like Delaware to sell corporate secrecy as a service – an ultimate irony as this country aggressively chases and chastises other jurisdictions for doing the same thing, according to the report.

That vulnerability is made doubly dangerous when it intersects the international trading sector due to the knowledge that organized criminal groups, corrupt kleptocrats and terror financiers currently hide, funnel and legitimize trillions of dollars in illicit gains, per estimates, through a myriad of trade trickery, including under and over-invoicing items, falsifying documents and other tactics.

In that same vein, U.S. government watchdog group the Government Accountability Office (GAO) noted in a report that because this country doesn’t broadly require ownership information to be made available, that can open the door to national security risks when government operations are housed in buildings owned by foreign entities who may or may not be a shell for prying, spying eyes bent on espionage.

Lastly, another report by United Nations Security Council highlighted that the issue of anonymous shell companies globally allows rogue regimes like North Korea to flout international sanctions and get access, as analysts prognosticate, to banned technology and weapons systems on its path to wreak worldwide havoc by creating weapons of mass destruction.
The article goes on to elaborate on some of those reports.

It is interesting that the article mentioned a report by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), being critical of lack of ownership information in the national security context, because the GAO has now, again, turned its eyes to the subject, in the context of procurement, in its November 2019 report below.  In its letter to Congress transmitting the report, it noted, 
DOD awards contracts to companies in the private sector to provide a wide variety of services for U.S. military forces. Of the thousands of contractors doing business with DOD, some companies are what are known as shell companies — that is, companies that exist but conduct either no business or minimal business. Shell companies can be used for legitimate purposes; for example, they may be formed to obtain financing before starting operations. However, companies sometimes use shell companies to form opaque ownership structures designed to disguise the beneficial owner — the natural person or persons who directly or indirectly own and control, or receive substantial economic benefit from, a company.

These opaque ownership structures can be used to facilitate fraud and other unlawful activity in commerce, including contracts with DOD. For this report, we define opaque ownership as structures of business governance that may conceal or obfuscate entities or individuals who own, control, or benefit financially from a business.
Ongoing DOD Fraud Risk Assessment Efforts Should Include Contractor Ownership  (some excerpts of the letter an other parts of the report, sliced and diced to meet the didactic goal and limited space of this blog; you should read the whole report for original meaning and intent):  In the letter mentioned above, it further noted:
We researched legal databases and news articles involving DOD contractors to identify federal court cases and agency decisions. We reviewed GAO bid-protest decisions to identify cases in which contractors may have failed to disclose foreign ownership or concealed beneficial-owner information to obtain contracts that they were not eligible to receive.  We examined known risks identified through our case-study research and interviews with DOD officials.  We further examined the risk that contractors could be disguising their ownership to create the appearance of competition.

We contacted several government contractors’ associations to gain members’ perspectives on reporting beneficial ownership information and received feedback from 16 members of three government contractors’ associations. The perspectives gained from our queries are not generalizable to all contractors.
In the body of the report, GAO found:  
As the number of layers of ownership increases, ownership information becomes more opaque. This opacity can make it difficult for DOD to determine which entities and individuals ultimately own or control its contractors.

In the United States, no centralized information source or national registry maintains company ownership information. In 2014, the National Association of Secretaries of State found that most states collect minimal ownership data. The association reviewed key information collected by the 50 states and the District of Columbia during the entity-formation process and in annual or periodic reports. During both the entity-formation process and in annual or periodic reporting, the association found that very few states collect some form of entity ownership or control information from limited liability companies or corporations.  The Securities and Exchange Commission collects some ownership information on publicly traded companies. Any person or group of persons that acquires beneficial ownership of more than 5 percent of a publicly traded company’s registered voting securities must register.

GSA’s System for Award Management (SAM) is a federal government-wide database for vendor data that is used across all federal agencies. Any entity that wishes to do business with the government must register in SAM to be eligible to receive a contract award, except in specific circumstances. To increase procurement transparency and traceability, entities that wish to do business with the federal government are now required to provide additional ownership information through the annual registration process in SAM. The required ownership information includes the “immediate” and “highest” level ownership of an offeror.

Responsibility Determination

Contract award decisions are based on evaluation factors and significant subfactors that are tailored to the procurement, at the discretion of procurement officials. At a minimum, these factors must include: price/cost, quality, and past performance. A prospective contractor must affirmatively demonstrate its responsibility, including, when necessary, the responsibility of its proposed subcontractors. Contracting officers must then determine the responsibility of prospective contractors, including whether prospective contractors can perform the terms of a contract. To be determined responsible, a prospective contractor must have adequate financial resources to perform the contract (or the ability to obtain them); be able to comply with the required delivery or performance schedule; have a satisfactory performance, integrity, and ethics record; have the necessary organization, experience, accounting and operational controls, and facilities to carry out the contract (or the ability to obtain them); and be otherwise qualified and eligible to receive an award under applicable laws and regulations.

Before awarding a contract over the simplified acquisition threshold, a contracting officer must review the prospective contractor’s performance and integrity information available in the Federal Awardee Performance and Integrity Information System (FAPIIS). FAPIIS is a federal government-wide database designed to assist contracting officers with making a responsibility determination by providing integrity and performance information of covered federal agency contractors and grantees. FAPIIS provides a prospective contractor “Report Card” that includes information pertaining to the prospective contractor’s past performance (if applicable), such as any administrative agreements, contract terminations, nonresponsibility determinations, and exclusions, among other things. It also includes the ability to view the company relationship information, which details the ownership information that prospective contractors are required to report in SAM. When making a responsibility determination, the contracting officer must consider all the information available through FAPIIS with regard to the prospective contractor and any immediate owner, predecessor (an entity that the prospective contractor replaced by acquiring assets and carrying out affairs under a new name), or subsidiary identified for that prospective contractor in FAPIIS. The contracting officer must document in the contract file how the information in FAPIIS was considered in any responsibility determination, as well as the action that was taken as a result of the information.

Contractors with Opaque Ownership Pose Financial Fraud Risks Including Price Inflation

Concealing relationship with subcontractor to inflate prices. Contractors can subcontract with companies they own or control to inflate prices for financial benefit. For example, in one case the contractor purchased goods from a company that its owners created, controlled, and used to make fraudulent markups appear legitimate. Contractors or subcontractors can also bill for work not performed by creating fictitious invoices that add costs to a contract. For example, in four court cases we examined, multiple DOD subcontractors were actually shell companies that did not have the inventory they purported to ultimately provide to the government or perform the work indicated in the contract requirements. Contractors or subcontractors can conceal conflicts of interest for financial benefits. For instance, in one case a DOD contractor employee and his spouse formed a company and concealed their interests by not listing their names but listing the names of family members on formation documents. This company became a subcontractor to the company that employed the DOD contractor. The contractor employee, in his official position, wrote letters justifying awards of purchase orders to the subcontractor he owned and approving recommendations that the awards be made to the subcontractor. The co-owner of the subcontractor concealed her involvement by signing contracts using a different name. We also identified the potential risk of companies creating the appearance of competition by submitting bids from fictitious companies. We identified one case that involved a DOD contractor whose executives admitted as part of their plea agreements to creating fictitious, inflated bids that were not from actual businesses to ensure that the contractor’s own bid would be selected by DOD as the supposed lowest.

Contractors with Opaque Ownership Can Also Pose Nonfinancial Fraud Risks


Contractors can pose nonfinancial fraud risks to DOD by concealing their ownership structure to bid on and obtain contracts that they are not eligible to receive. These nonfinancial risks may not pose a direct financial cost to DOD, but they can allow ineligible companies to contract with DOD while potentially denying eligible companies from contracting with DOD. These risks can also lead to additional vulnerabilities. One contractor that fraudulently obtained set-aside contracts claimed it was owned by a service-disabled veteran; however, that veteran had virtually no involvement with the contractor. Some contractors have been found not eligible to receive the set-aside contracts because they were not at least 51 percent controlled by the eligible individuals and the eligible individuals did not make long-term decisions for the companies. Rather, the contractors were controlled by an ineligible individual who owned and controlled a separate company that actually performed work on the set-aside contracts.

Contractors with opaque ownership structures can also pose the risk of circumventing eligibility requirements for contracts that are only designated for domestic companies, which can lead to other vulnerabilities that affect warfighter readiness. We identified four cases in which individuals created domestic shell companies for foreign manufacturers and bid on contracts designated for domestic companies. In three of the four cases, the individuals behind the shell companies also had ownership interests in the foreign manufacturing companies. Foreign manufacturers received payments from the contracts, despite the contracts only allowing domestic manufacturers to be eligible, and one such manufacturer ultimately supplied DOD with defective and nonconforming parts that led to the grounding of at least 47 fighter aircraft.
I'm sure you get the drift here. There's much more in the GAO report, much more. Have a look. Of particular importance is the lengthy discussion of things that are needed to improve the system of contractor selection. In brief, in its conclusions, the report summarizes,
We recognize that collecting additional ownership information, including beneficial-ownership information, could pose compliance burdens for contractors; and regulatory trends have generally focused on easing the burden to do business. Additionally, verifying contractor ownership can be challenging and time-consuming. Nevertheless, having a thorough assessment of contractor-ownership risks will better position DOD to make informed decisions on how best to use its resources and help ensure that the department’s fraud risk management program is organized and targeted to manage risks in a prioritized manner.

POST SCRIPT: In another new development along the lines of tracking who is whom, note the following article reprinted in Lexology:

Government Contractors Beware: DOJ Announces Creation of Interagency Procurement Collusion Strike Force
On November 5th, the Department of Justice (“DOJ”) Antitrust Division doubled down and announced the formal launch of the Procurement Collusion Strike Force (“PCSF”), an interagency partnership consisting of prosecutors and investigators focused on deterring, detecting, investigating, and prosecuting antitrust crimes, such as bid-rigging conspiracies and related fraudulent schemes in government procurement, grant, and program funding.





Thursday, July 12, 2018

He spoke proocurement reform, but got bespoke procurement

It looked good on paper, and, of course, after the horse had bolted:
• Watchdog groups are calling on the Legislature to pass, and for Governor Cuomo to sign, comprehensive “clean contracting” legislation
In 2016, an investigation into a sprawling alleged pay-to-play scheme connected to the Governor Cuomo’s Buffalo Billion economic development program resulted in charges against nine men, including a former top aide to Cuomo, Joe Percoco, and the former president of SUNY Polytechnic Institute, Alain Kaloyeros, a close government partner of Cuomo’s, on bid-rigging, bribery, and other charges.

The organizations -- including Reinvent Albany, New York Public Interest Group, Citizens Union, League of Women Voters, Fiscal Policy Institute, Common Cause, and Citizens Budget Commission -- are also urging state leaders to reduce the potential for conflicts of interest by exploring options to limit campaign contributions from anyone seeking a state contract. Nineteen states and New York City -- but not the state -- already have these anti-pay-to-play laws in place.

“The moment of truth has arrived. State and federal prosecutors say $800 million in state economic development contracts were rigged, but so far, the Legislature and governor have yet to act,” said John Kaehny, executive director of Reinvent Albany, standing in the state Capitol. “It’s time they pass common sense legislation that includes independent oversight over state contracts, uniform contracting rules, and transparency that will prevent corruption and abuse before it happens.”
• Governor Cuomo Announces 35th Proposal of the 2017 State of the State: Restoring the Integrity and Accountability of State Government Through Comprehensive Ethics Reform
The comprehensive package of reforms includes:

Advancing a constitutional amendment limiting outside income and creating a full-time legislature;
Advancing a constitutional amendment imposing term limits for elected officials;
Requiring members of the Legislature to obtain an advisory opinion before earning outside income;
Advancing legislation to close the “LLC Loophole;”
Instituting Public Financing and enacting a number of other campaign finance reforms;
Subjecting local elected officials to financial disclosure requirements;
Promoting Increased Transparency Through Comprehensive Reforms to the State Freedom of Information Law;
Expanding the State Inspector General's authority to SUNY and CUNY not-for-profits;
Creating new Inspectors General for the Port Authority and the State Education Department; and
Ensuring greater oversight of the state's procurement process.
• Statement from Governor Andrew M. Cuomo on Proposed Ethics Reforms Scandal seldom begins with evil, but with temptation, and temptation usually begins with a lack of watchfulness. I will create and appoint separate Inspector Generals for both SUNY and CUNY. They will be charged with identifying and investigating conflicts of interest, fraud, corruption and abuse. They will review contracts and hiring for both improper and illegal actions. They will look for personal benefit to any executive or legislative employee or improper actions with a third party. They will review all campuses and all affiliated entities. The IGs will have the authority to bring any report of improper conduct directly to law enforcement.

I will also appoint a Chief Procurement Officer for the Executive branch. That person will be charged with reviewing all state contracts, with an eye towards eliminating any wrongdoing, conflicts of interest or collusion. And just so there is no confusion, I do mean all contracts. Any contract or agreement that entails the disbursement of state funds will be subject to review. Any question of collusion, political benefit or personal connections will be thoroughly examined. The Chief Procurement Officer will have investigative and prosecutorial experience, and will be authorized to refer problematic issues directly to law enforcement for further action.
Alas, "Procurement reform became a hot-button issue following the arrest of several Cuomo allies on bid-rigging charges."

The rig was up, but not that many dominoes seemed to fall.

N.Y. developer pleads guilty ahead of 'Buffalo Billion' corruption trial
Kevin Schuler, formerly an executive at Buffalo-based LPCiminelli, admitted on Friday to wire fraud and conspiracy charges before U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni in Manhattan, less than a month before a scheduled trial. Schuler said he was involved in a bid-rigging scheme that allowed his company to win a lucrative contract as part of “Buffalo Billion,” a signature economic development project of New York Governor Andrew Cuomo to revitalize the region around Buffalo, New York.
And then: Architect of Cuomo’s Buffalo Billion Project Is Convicted in Bid-Rigging Scheme
Alain E. Kaloyeros, a principal architect of Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo’s signature economic development initiative, was convicted on Thursday in a bid-rigging scheme that steered hundreds of millions of dollars in state contracts to favored companies in Buffalo and Syracuse. Dr. Kaloyeros, 62, was found guilty of wire fraud and conspiracy in the fourth week of a federal trial in Manhattan that invited harsh scrutiny of Mr. Cuomo’s ambitious plan to revitalize upstate and western New York, known as the Buffalo Billion. Dr. Kaloyeros, the former president of SUNY Polytechnic Institute, had been credited with helping to create a high-tech industry in the capital region, which led Mr. Cuomo, a Democrat, to place him in charge of the Buffalo Billion project. The governor had praised Dr. Kaloyeros as a genius and “New York’s secret weapon.” Soon, the money began to flow to Buffalo; waterfront parks, gleaming modern factories and a cluster of medical and technology facilities were built.

Mr. Cuomo, who has not been accused by prosecutors of any wrongdoing, said after the verdict that he had “no tolerance for those who seek to defraud the system to advance their own personal interests. Anyone who has committed such an egregious act should be punished to the full extent of the law.”

But at the trial, the prosecution presented evidence that Dr. Kaloyeros and Todd R. Howe, a former lobbyist with ties to Mr. Cuomo, conspired to defraud Fort Schuyler Management Corporation, a nonprofit real estate arm of SUNY Polytechnic, by steering lucrative contracts to two firms whose executives were significant donors to Mr. Cuomo’s campaign. As part of the scheme, Dr. Kaloyeros and Mr. Howe tailored requests for proposals, or RFPs, to fit the specific qualifications possessed by the two companies — LPCiminelli, a Buffalo construction management firm, and COR Development, a Syracuse-area firm — and ensure that they be chosen by Fort Schuyler for the projects. LPCiminelli, for example, received a contract to build what became a $750 million solar-panel plant on the banks of the Buffalo River, while COR received contracts worth more than $100 million for other projects. Both firms were clients of Mr. Howe’s.

Michael C. Miller, a lawyer for Dr. Kaloyeros, said after the verdict that his client would appeal. “Alain Kaloyeros is innocent,” Mr. Miller said. “He did not rig bids. Not a penny was lost. Not a bribe was paid. He did the best job that he could for the State of New York and for Fort Schuyler, and we’re just utterly disappointed with the outcome of this case.”

Government watchdog groups said that the verdict, like dozens of previous cases touching on corruption in the state capital, was the result of a lack of strong ethics laws and enforcement.
Jury convicts Ciminelli, Kaloyeros in Buffalo Billion bid-rigging scheme
The jury obviously agreed with the government's key witness, former LPCiminelli vice president Kevin Schuler, who took a plea deal and testified against his former boss early in the trial. Prosecutors dropped their charges against former LPCiminelli executive Michael Laipple.

Schuler spelled out for the jury how he, Ciminelli and Kaloyeros conspired to make sure that LPCiminelli emerged as the winning bidder by designing the request for proposals, or RFP, to favor Ciminelli's company. "We had significant influence over the project, influence over the RFP and influence over the process that was going to select a winner," Schuler told the jury.

Most notably, potential bidders were told in 2013 that they had to have 50 years' worth of construction experience in the Buffalo area in order to qualify for the project. That prompted Schuler to show the jury a shirt, produced in 2011 celebrating LPCiminelli's 50th anniversary. "I think someone put this in to help us ... and I'd never seen a requirement like that," Schuler testified. State officials later shrank the requirement to 15 years of Buffalo experience, saying that the 50-year provision was a typographical error.
Of course, it's another election season, when procurement reform is a can to be kicked through a political goal post.  When procurement reformation is the lipstick slapped on political deformation.

As Governor Cuomo himself said in his Statement quoted above, "Democrats, Republicans, Conservatives, Liberals, Independents – no party or group is immune."

Tuesday, May 8, 2018

Look-see called for in not a good look government contract

The first thing you need to know, if you don't already, about this article is that it involves an Australian political party whose very name is a deceit. The "Liberal" Party is actually notoriously conservative. Oh, and it currently controls the Federal Government.

'Not a good look': Calls for transparency after Liberal Party donor wins Pacific cable contract
The Federal Government has been called on to publicly explain its decision to award a multi-million-dollar contract to a company that has previously donated tens of thousands of dollars to the Liberal Party.

Telecommunications company Vocus was last year awarded a $2.8 million contract to carry out a three-month scoping study on the planned undersea high-speed internet cable for Papua New Guinea and Solomon Islands. Vocus donated $44,000 to the Liberal Party of Australia in 2013, and a further $50,000 in 2016.

The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) awarded the scoping study contract through a limited tender, a process where only one or more potential suppliers are approached to apply.

Marc Purcell, the chief executive of the Australian Council for International Development, told the ABC's Pacific Beat program the combination of the donations and the limited tender were "not a good look". "The Government does have the ability under the Commonwealth Procurement Guidelines to have a limited tender," he said. "While it has that power, the issue is the lack of transparency and what I think will raise eyebrows in Canberra is the fact that the preferred provider Vocus is a donor to the Coalition."

The company said the political donations were made by its former board and management team.

DFAT said Vocus was awarded the scoping study contract on account of its "extensive, recent experience with similar infrastructure projects", and that the company was "assessed as being best placed to explore potential cable solutions".

Australia made an offer to help with the Pacific cable project last year after the Solomon Islands signed a deal with Chinese communications giant Huawei. That deal unnerved security experts concerned about China's growing influence in the region, and the prospect of a Chinese company gaining access to Australia's internet infrastructure.

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

For the times, they are a'changing -- or are they?

Here is the first of a couple of intriguing and thought-provoking current articles, each from very good sources (or so I've observed), considering aspects of the current "changes" in federal government acquisition. The second will be in the next post (see here). 

Remember, I take indecent liberty with articles advanced here, to provide context to students of local government procurement, and Guam's in particular. Thus, I slice and dice, omit great swaths of critical data, paraphrase, rearrange, and perhaps tilt to one side or the other, the original information in these articles. It is imperative that you read the articles in their original form and the authors' intent, and not rely on my iteration of them.



“Other Transaction Authorities” might seem like a risky new acquisition method, but it’s been around longer than the Federal Acquisition Regulation.
Before there was a Federal Acquisition Regulation regime describing the many procurement laws adopted at the federal level in the last three decades plus, there were “other transaction authorities,” also known by the shorthand OTAs or OTs. This contracting method, outside the usual federal process, is not widely used and even less understood. But that’s beginning to change. “Even though it’s been around for a fairly lengthy period of time, it’s just not been used very much. So, people are afraid of it because they haven’t seen how it’s worked,” Douglas Maughan, director of the Homeland Security Department's Science and Technology Directorate’s Cyber Security Division, told Nextgov.

It comes across as new and scary but is potentially a game-changing acquisition model and it is catching fire across government. After all, it has no structure, no built in roadmaps, accountability or paper trails. But, it doesn’t have to be scary and is not really all that new, if you are a big believer in getting to the future by going back before the dawn of modern procurement rules-based practices. It has roots going back to the 1950's, long before the FAR and the Competition in Contracting Act. Three decades later that same language came to be used to grant the Defense Department similar authorities. “Under these authorities, agencies may develop agreements that are not required to follow a standard format or include terms and conditions that are typically required when using traditional mechanisms,” according to a Government Accountability Office definition. In other words, OTAs rely more on principles than rules.

By 1994, that authority had been broadened beyond research to include prototyping and then updated again in 2017 to enable contracts to move into production after successful prototypes. Over that time, several departments have been granted other transaction authorities, including Defense, Energy, Health and Human Services, Homeland Security and Transportation. Under these departments, five component agencies have also been given explicit OT authority: the Federal Aviation Administration, Transportation Security Administration, National Institutes of Health, Domestic Nuclear Detection Office and Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy, or ARPA-E.

Homeland Security’s Science and Technology Directorate awarded its first OT contract for cybersecurity in February 2016 after launching its Silicon Valley Innovation program. While the primary focus for OTs is on research and development, not all agencies are using them for that express purpose. For instance, TSA and NASA use them for other services, such as airport security, education and outreach, according to GAO.

The reluctance to use OTs is based on “fear of giving people a lot of discretion,” said Nash, the procurement law expert. “If you’re in a government agency and you’ve got an inspector general and you’ve got congressional oversight … there’s a tendency to be pretty cautious about how you do business.”

That said, “It’s the same oversight you have over any other transaction where you’re giving a company money,” Nash said. “The problem is, if you have a lot of discretion, you take away a lot of the rules, but you still have basic ethics problems. If you gave an OT to your father without telling anybody else about it, you’d have the same ethical violation you’d have with a contract or a grant.”

The other major roadblock is the fear of funding projects that don't pan out, Nash said. “People have a hard time understanding that when you fund research, over half the time you’re funding failure,” Nash said. “You do not get 100 percent payout from research; and you shouldn’t expect it.” If you were to see a 100 percent success rate in funding research, that would just mean you weren't looking far enough into the future. “There’s nothing wrong with failure,” Nash said.

Homeland Security’s Maughan agreed. “We have a lot of successes we can talk about with return on investment, but even the failures” have some return, he said. He cited a program to downsize a Defense Department radar system to fit on smaller drones used by U.S. Customs and Border Protection. The company awarded a contract ultimately failed to produce a working prototype, but everyone involved still consider it a successful venture. The company was able to get funding to move their research forward and CBP learned what is feasible for the size of drones they use. “They were still really happy about being part of the program,” Maughan said. “We helped them move the technology down the roadmap toward a smaller device and that will help them in some of their DOD missions.”

“I think there’s still some return on investment," Maughan added. "Our investment was less than $400,000 with them, so I think it falls into the category of: If you’re going to fail, fail quickly."

Had the office used a traditional contracting method for this project, it likely would have taken six to 12 months just to make an award, let alone discover that the idea would not work. Under the Science and Technology Directorate's OT authority, the time from application to award can be as short as 60 to 90 days.

Broadening OTs beyond research seems to increase their use accordingly. GAO reports that while most agencies do fewer than 75 OT transactions a year, TSA and NASA conducted 640 and 3,220, respectively, in 2014 alone.

Many in government have been reluctant to use their OT authorities precisely because of the lack of regulations governing their use. Since the contracts exist outside of the Federal Acquisition Regulation, they can be written with far less stringent requirements. But that also means there are fewer protections along the way to avoid a catastrophic contracting failure—one that could land a government official in front of a congressional committee.

“Even though it’s not FAR-based, we still have to do procurement documentation, we have to do a source-selection plan that says what are the criteria by which we’re going to evaluate proposals. For the most part, it’s the same as a traditional FAR-based contract, it’s just that the vehicle you’re using is not a FAR-based vehicle,” Maughan said. Despite appearances, “It’s not the wild, wild west,” Maughan added. “You still have to make sure the government is making the decisions on what gets awarded. Even still, we have a contracting officer—who’s called an ‘other transaction authority officer’—so you’re still doing the same kinds of things with the contracting folks as part of the team.”

The company was able to get funding to move their research forward and CBP learned what is feasible for the size of drones they use. “They were still really happy about being part of the program,” Maughan said. “We helped them move the technology down the roadmap toward a smaller device and that will help them in some of their DOD missions.”

“I think there’s still some return on investment," he added. "Our investment was less than $400,000 with them, so I think it falls into the category of: If you’re going to fail, fail quickly."

Had the office used a traditional contracting method for this project, it likely would have taken six to 12 months just to make an award, let alone discover that the idea would not work. Under the Science and Technology Directorate's OT authority, the time from application to award can be as short as 60 to 90 days.

“It’s not a solution for every case,” Maughan said. “It’s not the answer for all things,” he added. “If you’re trying to get startups with new innovation, then an OT might be good for you as an organization. There’s a little bit of risk working with a startup company—if you’re really just looking for a solutions provider and you’re not willing to take some risk, then an OT might not be for you.”

Nash agreed and offered some advice to agencies interested in getting in on OTs. “Let’s say you find a company out there that’s never done business with the government and that has some fascinating technology. You go to them and you say, ‘How could we sponsor you to do this? And we’ll give you all the money.’ Well, they may say, ‘The only way we’ll deal with you is this, this, this and this,’” Nash said. “We’re talking about intellectual property issues; we’re talking about accounting issues. And a normal contracting office might be pretty darn uncomfortable when they hear that because that’s not their norm.”

“You’ve got accounting problems. You want to make sure the company spends the money for what you gave them the money,” which can be particularly difficult, as one advantage of an OT contract is the company does not have to abide by government accounting standards. “But you need to make sure they have some systems.

“You need to worry about intellectual property—who’s going to have rights to it. And that would mean that if they said, ‘We’ll only do it if you take zero rights,’ that would be a problem. You might do it but you certainly would know that that’s a flashpoint that you would worry about. And then, of course, you’ve got to worry about audit rights because the government always wants to be able to audit and the contractor might not want to be audited.
Additional reading for this subject: Acquisition Disruption - Innovative Concepts in Government Contracting
Excerpt:  "This term is not defined by statute or regulation; it is best defined by what it is not. An OTA is not a procurement contract, grant, or cooperative agreement. It is a different type of agreement with the government – one that is not subject to the strict regulatory regimes that characterize other types of contracting." 

In my mind, adherence to principles is absolutely necessary for a successful procurement regime, but principles are not, in themselves, sufficient, any more than rules alone are.  See, The ethics of paper work.

Sunday, March 18, 2018

Putting brakes on a mule. Whoa, Mule!!

US military says robotic pack mules are too noisy to use (2015)
The US military has reportedly shelved development of its robotic pack mule — the Boston Dynamics-built Legged Squad Support System or LS3. According to a report from Military.com, there are no "future experiments or upgrades planned" for the mechanical beast of burden, with the program in need of new contracts or support from senior military figures before it can be resurrected. And the reason for this parting of ways? LS3 was apparently too noisy to make a good soldier. Over the course of its development, LS3 was given updates to make it more autonomous, able to automatically follow humans and even respond to basic voice commands like "follow," "sit," and "stay." But, it seems it never really became all that quiet. In videos of the barrel-chested robot in action during military trials last summer, it sounds as loud as a sit-on lawnmower — definitely not the sort of companion you'd want bumbling alongside you on a nighttime patrol.

Army on Accelerated Path to Buy as Many as 5,700 Robotic Mules (2/9/2018)
Requirements for robotic mules go back at least to 2001 when the now canceled Future Combat Systems was conceived.An autonomous multifunctional utility logistics and equipment vehicle survived the FCS cancelation and was transferred to the follow-on Brigade Combat Team Modernization program, but that effort was eventually scrapped as well. Since then, development of robotic mules continued, with four of the vehicles reaching Afghanistan in 2012 for a battlefield assessment. The Lockheed Martin-built squad mission support system was deployed there for about five months. When the Army put out a call for robotic mules to take part in a vendor solution assessment in September and October, seven robot manufacturers were able to bring technically mature, off-the-shelf robotic mules.

After more than a decade of experimenting with robotic mules designed to take the load off overburdened foot soldiers, the service is on an accelerated path to field up to 5,700 squad multi-purpose equipment transport robotic vehicles in a winner-takes-all competition that may wrap up as early as 2019. Over the course of its development, LS3 was given updates to make it more autonomous, able to automatically follow humans and even respond to basic voice commands like "follow," "sit," and "stay." But, it seems it never really became all that quiet. In videos of the barrel-chested robot in action during military trials last summer, it sounds as loud as a sit-on lawnmower — definitely not the sort of companion you'd want bumbling alongside you on a nighttime patrol.

The program is using an “other transaction authority” contracting vehicle to rapidly transition the technology from experiments to a program of record. OTAs are normally used to bring in nontraditional contractors to make prototypes. The Army is in the middle of selecting a contractor after bringing in seven vendors with eight different vehicles in 2017 to perform operational tests. “That is significantly faster than we have been able to do previous efforts,” Maj. Gen. John George, director for force development, Army G-8, told reporters. “That is the beauty of the new OTA process. If you have a competition though OTA, you can go to procurement and turn it into a program of record,” George said. A typical program of this kind would take upwards of 10 years, he said. “The Army wants to go faster. It wants and needs to go faster,” he added.

But this is a “good news story,” he said. “We are doing that because we have learned to hack our own system” and by using the revised other transaction authority rules. “What has changed is that the transition mechanism provided in 10 USC 2371b (h), added by the 2016 NDAA, provides a greatly simplified way of transitioning the contracting. The follow-on production effort after a successful prototype OT can be executed as a production OT or awarded as a non-competitive procurement contract,” according to Richard Dunn, founder and consultant with the Strategic Institute for Innovation in Government Contracting.
Army Revamps Strategy to Acquire Robotic Mules (3/24/2017)
The Army intends to buy 20 robotic mules from manufacturers and send them out with brigades for a year-long operational test and evaluation, the service’s program manager in charge of unmanned ground systems said March 23. Bryan McVeigh, project manager for force protection, said a recent Army Requirements Oversight Council looking at the squad multipurpose equipment transport (SMET) vehicle put the breaks on the program, which was heading for fielding in the early 2020s. The council said, “Wait a minute guys, You’re laying out a standard program of record. This is taking too long. This is way too much testing. We’re not even sure this is what we want,” McVeigh said. Chief of Staff of the Army Gen. Mark Milley instructed the PEO to go back and look at the things that really matter and get rid of the rest, McVeigh said.

Earlier in the conference, a senior service official said the proposed prices they had seen for SMETs had given officials “sticker shock.” “I’m not telling you what to bid on your price. But I am telling what we think it should cost,” McVeigh said. The vehicle after it reaches its assembly point will then have to switch over to an unmanned mode. “How do I pull what seems to be mutually exclusive design characteristics together?” McVeigh asked. That will be a tough problem for the manufacturers, he acknowledged.

The Army wants two basic configurations: one similar to the vehicles that have been tested and another that will have a seat and steering wheel so it can be optionally manned, he said. The reason for the optionally manned version is one of logistics. “How do I get from an airport to an assembly area? That kind of leads me to an optionally manned solution. There are not enough prime movers to tow all the systems that are supposed to be issued to the brigade,” he said.PEO force protection will proceed with an SMET rodeo as early as August, McVeigh said at the National Defense Industrial Association’s Robotic Capabilities conference in Springfield, Virginia. How is it going to be operated? Will it use a cord, a joystick or follow soldiers using breadcrumbs? Can it be towed at 20, 30 or 50 miles per hour without flipping over? The more capability the robot makers offer, the higher the score on their evaluation, he said.

A request for information will be published “shortly,” he said. “I need your feedback to make sure what I have in mind is executable. This is absolutely critical.” He needs to know how long it will take to get a prototype built. As for delivering the models by August: “I need you to tell me if I’m on drugs,” he said. Companies participating will be reimbursed for their expenses.

There are four possible scenarios, McVeigh said. The first is that one of the manufacturers “hits it out of the park” and gives the Army exactly what it wants. He has the authority to then go into limited production with a traditional acquisition contract. Another scenario is that a couple of the models do well, but are not quite right. There would be new requirements written, some changes, and then a down-select to one vendor. The third outcome is: “Thank you all for playing. Pick up your trophies on the way out. We learned that what we were asking for isn’t in the art of the doable.” The Army would return to an engineering, manufacturing and development phase and open up the contract again. The fourth option simply is that the Army decides it doesn’t need this capability, he said.
A note to newbies to this blog: I almost always slice and dice articles, leave out critical material, paraphrase, and add comment for purposes of turning real life situations into teachable procurement examples. Do not rely on my renditions to know the full story, or intent, of the article -- read the original at the link(s) provided.

Monday, December 25, 2017

Crikey! Wot a rort!

I remind my reader to click the links to the articles presented and read the originals, as I slice and dice the material for didactic purposes in order to try to present a "teachable moment". These posts are mostly to be considered as hypothetical procurement case studies, not news or other literary content, and omit, paraphrase and rearrange a lot of original material. You've been warned, again.

Allegations of systemic fraud sparked Defence Department internal audit
Confidential documents drafted by a senior defence department investigator reveal allegations of systemic fraud spanning several years inside the government's biggest spender. The 10-month investigation, which finished in February this year, was prompted by an anonymous disclosure about fraud and corruption made to the department in April 2016.

One of the most concerning aspects involved the department awarding companies contracts without a competitive tender process and only a flimsy justification they met "value for money" requirements. In other cases the department was unable to tell whether a contract breached procurement rules or not because important paper work could not be found.

In 2015-16 the Department of Defence reported the largest yearly contract spend of any agency within the public service. The department dialled-up a bill of $30.5 billion on contracts, amounting to 54 per cent of total government contractor spending.

The investigation raised serious questions about the department's use of "single source" tenders, where a single company is awarded a contract without having to compete against other providers. "It is questionable whether true value for money is achieved when [redacted] continually conduct single source limited tenders," Dr Clarke wrote. "Whilst there is less administration and quicker decision making with this approach, it provides limited opportunity for Defence to achieve the best possible outcome. "Single source limited tenders increase the risk of contractor underperformance and corruption."
Defence spending data unreliable, incomplete, national audit office says
Transparency and accountability for billions of dollars of annual defence spending remains suspect despite recent reforms, the Australian National Audit Office (ANAO) has found.

Last year, the Defence Department spent $8.3 billion on keeping its equipment in working order, known as "sustainment" in military jargon. Yet, the audit office found that despite small recent improvements, information about where that money went and whether it was being spent wisely was often unreliable or not available.

The report also questions a claim from Defence that reforms to its sustainment policies had saved $2 billion. "Defence has not been able to provide the ANAO with adequate evidence to support this claim, nor an account of how $360 million allocated as 'seed funding' for Smart Sustainment initiatives was used," it read.

Auditors were also critical of inconsistencies between figures given to the Government during the budget process and those provided in the department's annual report. "It's absolutely not good enough," Andrew Davies, director of defence and strategy at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, told AM.
Oz military megahack
An Australian Signals Directorate (ASD) presentation to the Australian Information Security Association (AISA) conference yesterday detailed the hack. Suffice to say that a medium-sized defence contractor was breached and gigabytes of aerospace data and commercial arrangements for military aircraft and naval vessels were delivered into the hands of the attackers. The ASD used it as a case study for the AISA conference yesterday.

The government has since said the information was commercial-in-confidence, but not classified. This is not an isolated incident: in Australia, as elsewhere, attackers thwarted by a network's defences then seek out third-party contractors as an easier mark.

This suggests a problem in sub-contractor oversight – you can win a government contract without proving you have adequate network security.

Minister for Defence Industry Christopher Pyne seems to agree. This morning, he told Radio National's Breakfast programme that the government can't be held responsible for a contractor's lax security.
Fat and mismanaged public sector is eating us alive
In a Crikey article, carried by the Community and Public Services Union, Eric Beecher chronicles appalling mismanagement in service delivery.

Then there’s the $11 billion spent by the Defence Department managing 119 bases around Australia which the ANAO says is well in excess of the $9.3bn “expected value” of the 10 services contracts, signed in 2014, to do the work. The department has defended its performance, saying the vast project to renegotiate the contracts has delivered value for money, when considered against increased service demands and changing expectations of the ADF. Yet a new $120 million IT system, meant to manage contracts ­between Defence and the private companies servicing the bases, was $39m over budget and five years late.

There’s also the flawed tendering and contracting processes overseen by the Immigration ­Department, which resulted in the waste of “tens and possibly, hundreds of millions of dollars”. Given these practices were subject to a scathing ANAO report, they could hardly be ignored.

We’re reminded of last year’s Australian Bureau of Statistics census “stuff-up”, the Australian Taxation Office’s massive and damaging IT outage, the Department of Health’s decade-long mismanagement of e-health records, and the embarrassing release of identifiable Medicare information. There’s also the Department of Finance’s lax oversight of ministerial travel arrangements. But not raised is the $576m public service travel bill — a blowout of $75m in just four years.

While this shocking record is acknowledged, Beecher argues the blame lies mainly with outsourcing to powerful private contractors.
Outsourcing failures expose weaknesses in both government and business
The problems of dealing with private sector providers and contractors are a persistent theme in the analysis of government shortcomings. For example, recent Australian National Audit Office reports highlighted contracting problems in Air Services Australia, the Defence Department and the Immigration Department. Contract management issues were at the heart of last year's failed online census and have been a constant factor in the turbulent administration of Australia's controversial offshore detention centres. Over-reliance on contracted consultants was a major cause of the botched home insulation scheme.

Given the extent to which governments rely on private contractors for a large range of goods and services, it is unsurprising that contractors are often in the frame when things go wrong. But many of the recurring issues arise out of factors specific to the contracting process.

A common complaint is that the use of contractors has caused agencies to run down their in-house expertise and technical resources. As a result, it can be argued, agencies lack the capacity to assess whether the contracts they are agreeing to give the government and taxpayer adequate value for money. Without their own professional judgment, grounded in technical knowledge and practical experience of the area in question, public service managers are ill-equipped to decide matters of all-round quality. Instead, they tend to fall back on generic checklists of assessment criteria that emphasise easily specifiable factors, such as cost and timeliness.

Alternatively, if funds allow and time permits, they may contract in an external consultant or commissioner to give an expert opinion on a proposed contract. But such advice carries the risks of perverse incentives attached to all forms of external contracting and consulting. The consultants' objective is to gain future contracts, which encourages them to say what they think governments want to hear in preference to what they ought to hear. Once again, without the professional judgment to tell the difference and without their own in-house, trusted staff to advise them, public service managers are at the mercy of self-interested outsiders. This vulnerability is compounded by the lack of transparency that surrounds contracting. Overuse of commercial-in-confidence provisions has shielded public servants from the bracing effects of public scrutiny.

The lack of in-house capacity can affect not only the initial process of drawing up contracts but also the oversight of how contracts are implemented. However, as the constant stream of scandals illustrates, many commercial providers are more interested in profit than in good service and cannot be trusted to do the right thing. As a result, governments are being driven to impose tighter controls and regulations. Even then, in the face of determined rorting and corner-cutting, most government agencies lack the resources to prevent opportunistic contractors from wrongfully expropriating public funds.

After two decades of wholesale outsourcing, some general conclusions are clear. Contracting out is an efficient and effective alternative to in-house provision where the objectives are clear and easily monitored, and where there is a competitive market of alternative providers. It also works well for more complex services where providers can be trusted to pursue public-interest objectives for their own reasons. However, where these conditions of either simplicity or trust do not apply, the risks that governments will not receive value for money start to build. Moreover, extensive experience with outsourcing has itself compounded these risks by reducing governments' capacity to effectively draw up and monitor outsourcing contracts. Some complex service contracts that could have been safely contemplated a generation ago are now beyond the professional expertise of public servants to administer.

politicians need to recognise that outsourcing complex government services requires the development of trust between the parties, which means looking beyond the short-term bottom line and not always preferring the cheapest option. In addition, successful contracting depends on well-resourced government agencies with the skills and experience necessary to manage ongoing relationships with contractors. Running down government staffing levels while relying more on private contractors is a recipe for continuing policy failure.

Contractors, for their part, must earn the right to be treated as trusted partners. They must be prepared for the long haul and willing to learn from experience. They must also be ready to submit to the level of public scrutiny and accountability that public servants take for granted. Indeed, given that the commercial private sector is not imbued with the same commitment to serving the public interest, there is a case for subjecting private contractors to more scrutiny than the public service, not less.

Wednesday, August 23, 2017

Alternatives to competitive bidding, designed to save time or money, reduced accountability

New Mexico, USA

Audit: State contracts lack competition
New Mexico state procurement rules designed to ensure competition on contracts for goods and services are being circumvented unnecessarily amid exemptions that cover $6.5 billion in spending each year, the State Auditor’s Office said Tuesday. A special audit by the office of State Auditor Tim Keller found some state agencies used emergency exemptions in ways not permitted by law and that sole source contracting remains common.... New Mexico spends between $10 billion $13 billion in state funds and federal aid each year on procuring goods and services.

Health care contracts signed by the Human Services Department accounted for the bulk of exemptions to the state procurement code — more than $5 million in the fiscal year ending in June 2016.

State Auditor Tim Keller said current alternatives to competitive bidding were designed to save the state time or money, but have ended up reducing accountability in government and fairness to outside businesses. The audit also found limited oversight of political campaign contributions from contractors hired by the state.

The report recommends reforms to rein in exemptions to competitive bidding and to streamline contract approvals under a single procurement oversight authority. Agencies typically spend over six months to approve a contract, making it more likely that agencies will look for short-cuts, the audit stated.

In a letter to Keller, Department of Finance and Administration Secretary Duffy Rodriguez called the methodology behind the audit “questionable” and described as conjecture concerns about the general overuse of non-competitive procurement. Keller said, “We’re supposed to protect against pay-to-play and fraud, waste and abuse, and also I think just be accountable for where those dollars are going. What our audit showed is that, by and large, for billions of dollars, we are not doing that in one way or another. We’re either violating our own laws or we’re not tracking the data.”

Auditor’s report reveals state overreliance on no-bid contracts
The study, to be formally released Tuesday, found state agencies, in violation of the government procurement law, used emergency exemptions from purchasing rules when there was no urgency to bypass the competitive bidding process.

The Auditor’s Office reviewed 11 small contracts, too. Less oversight is required for purchases of less than $60,000 in many cases, but the report found a state agency amending small contracts several times to include much larger sums.

The report examined 13 larger sole-source contracts and found 10 did not meet the state’s rules for such purchases. The State Auditor’s Office said agencies are skipping the competitive bidding process out of convenience and based on assumptions about price. The report also examined 14 emergency purchases and found only three fit the definition of an emergency; an agency said it needed to fix what the report described as a contamination issue even though the agency had learned of the issue one year earlier.

State Auditor Tim Keller said the study’s findings show a government too reliant on contracts that are not put out to bid, as well as a purchasing system that is complex, decentralized and rife with loopholes. “The spirit of procurement is to safeguard tax dollar funded contracting from fraud, waste and abuse,” Keller said in a statement. “Strong directive executive leadership and a reworking of the law to make bidding more effective and efficient would have a game-changing impact on creating local jobs, cutting red tape, and providing essential services to New Mexicans at the best value.”

The biggest share of state spending outside the usual purchasing process goes to goods and services that are bought by one state agency from another or from a local government. Those purchases are usually exempt from competitive bidding. And certain health care spending, a major expense for the state, also falls under what is known as “sole source procurement,” which is when an agency gives the contract to one company without competitive bids.

State agencies can buy goods and services from private companies without a competitive, open bidding process only when one company sells a particular product or an emergency requires officials to move quicker than the time it takes for competitive bids. However, agencies must make an effort to find other vendors and detail the reasons for an emergency. The state’s rules warn that agencies are not supposed to bypass the usual purchasing process because staff believes one particular option is best or the least expensive.

The report raised concerns that the General Services Department and the Department of Finance and Administration “do not always provide adequate scrutiny.” As a result, the report said, agencies can get away with no-bid contracts that do not meet the state’s rules.

The State Auditor’s Office suggested consolidating oversight of the purchasing process, which the Legislative Finance Committee has long recommended. The report also called for additional training of all state personnel involved in procurement and suggested legislators comprehensively review the exemptions and exceptions in the state’s purchasing law.

Sen. Sander Rue, R-Albuquerque, has sponsored legislation reforming the procurement process but said lawmakers may need to revisit the language of the current rules. Rue said the state should open up the process even further by, for example, making public how officials choose winning contracts.

“The more transparent and open procurement is,” he said, “the less you are to have mistakes, errors and perhaps mischief.”
Note: New Mexico is one of a couple of dozen states, including the Territory of Guam, that use the principals and are guided by the processes of the ABA Model Procurement Code.

Wednesday, June 21, 2017

California procurement database found to be off base

California Audit Report 2016-124, Department of General Services and California Department of Technology

Among the key findings: General Services does not have complete and accurate contracting data, and it did not implement controls to avoid these shortcomings with its contracting data.
The previous contract and procurement database system used through 2015 had severe limitations—we found many key data entry errors, and more than a third of the contracts and amendments we reviewed were missing from the system, including one with eight amendments worth $163 million.

Of the 27 approved noncompetitive requests we reviewed, nine lacked justification for bypassing the competitive bid process and 14 did not demonstrate that the vendor’s prices were reasonable.
Among the highlights of the report:

• General Services and Technology did not provide adequate oversight of the billions of dollars state agencies awarded through noncompetitive contracts from fiscal years 2011–12 through 2015–16.
vices did not ensure that a statewide contract database contained complete and accurate information about the State’s contracts for use by key decision makers.

• Although General Services transitioned to the new Financial Information System for California (FI$Cal) as its statewide contract database, it is unclear if FI$Cal will fully solve the State’s lack of comprehensive contracting data.

• Neither General Services nor Technology has established formal plans to regularly analyze the new FI$Cal data to identify instances of abuse or misuse of statewide noncompetitive procurements.

• General Services and Technology approved noncompetitive requests that lacked adequate justification for bypassing the competitive bid process, such as demonstrating that it conducted market research to substantiate that no competition existed.

• Nine of the 27 noncompetitive requests we reviewed could have been avoided if the agencies had engaged in sufficient planning.

• Although both General Services and Technology have enforcement mechanisms, they rarely employed them, allowing agencies to continue inappropriately using noncompetitive requests.
Billions in no-bid contracts mismanaged, state auditor says, By Adam Ashton (Excerpts; read full report at the link)
It didn’t take long for the cost of a technology contract in California’s unemployment office to increase twelvefold.

Two changes to the contract – added without bidding – swelled the deal to $8 million within a year. Then, the Employment Development Department submitted a request to add another $2 million worth of work to the arrangement without soliciting new bids from other companies.

That project is one of nine that State Auditor Elaine Howle highlighted in a new report released on Tuesday that urges California government to be more cautious in awarding high-value contracts without seeking competitive bids.

The report estimates that the state spent $44 billion on noncompetitive contracts worth $1 million or more between 2011 and 2016, a substantial sum that auditors said underscored the need for better management.

“The sheer magnitude of the value of the state’s noncompetitive contracts during this period emphasizes the importance of ensuring that the state provides adequate oversight of agencies’ contracting practices,” the report says.

State rules allow departments to award contracts without bidding in emergencies and under other special circumstances. But Howle’s auditors found that the state departments in charge of monitoring spending – the Department of General Services and the Department of Technology – have missed opportunities to challenge requests for noncompetitive contracts, failed to ensure that contract databases have accurate information and rarely disciplined other government agencies for misusing noncompetitive contracts.

The audits were based in part on a sampling of 27 noncompetitive contracts that state departments awarded over five years. Nine of them should have gone out to bid, auditors wrote.

Examples included:

▪ A $3 million contract extension that the California High-Speed Rail Authority presented just 17 days before its existing contract was scheduled to expire. High-Speed Rail did not describe why the vendor it chose had unique services that merited a noncompetitive contract.

▪ An $835 million noncompetitive contract amendment in 2013 for the company that manages Medi-Cal dental benefits. It was the seventh amendment to the original contract.

▪ A $75.5 million noncompetitive contract extension at the Department of Motor Vehicles on top of what was a $62.8 million for work on the state’s driver’s license production system.

▪ A fourth amendment to a Cal Fire aviation contract that was worth $27.8 million.

One $163 million contract that was missing from databases highlighted shortcomings in the state’s accounting system. It was the eighth change to a contract from the Department of Developmental Services, and no one entered it in the program the Department of General Services uses to follow spending.

State government is in the midst of a major overhaul of its accounting system with departments gradually adopting a new program called the Financial Information System for California (FI$Cal). When it’s in full use, the Department of General Services and the Department of Technology should be able to follow instantly any contract awarded by a state entity.

Until then, different state departments are using a hybrid system for accounting. Most use the system that FI$Cal is replacing; about a third of them use FI$Cal.

Howle’s office says it’s too early to tell whether FI$Cal will work as intended. “It is unclear if FI$Cal will fully solve the state’s lack of comprehensive contracting data,” auditors wrote.

Read more here: http://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/the-state-worker/article157239494.html#storylink=cpy

Sunday, June 11, 2017

Procurement controversy du jour - PI seeks to expand emergency procurement before and after emergency

New purchase rules eyed during crises
Speaker Pantaleon Alvarez has filed a bill proposing to loosen restrictions on negotiated procurement in cases of “extreme urgency and necessity,” and allow the government to skip public bidding in purchasing cheaper goods. House Bill No. 5521 seeks to amend several provisions of Republic Act No. 9184 or the Government Procurement Reform Act, which was enacted in 2003.

The (current) law considers negotiated procurement and direct contracting as alternative procurement methods to public bidding. The former (negotiated procurement) refers to the method used in extraordinary circumstances such as during the failure of bidding and in times of emergency.

Under Alvarez’ bill, negotiated procurement will be allowed “before, during, or after a calamity.” Currently, this mode is applicable “during a state of calamity,” which requires an actual declaration by the affected government unit.

Alvarez said that current regulations “unduly delay and hamstring the delivery of services” in times of calamity.

The proposed measure also provides for an additional criteria to resort to direct contracting, which currently sees the agency ask for a price quotation from the exclusive supplier of goods of critical or proprietary nature.

Read more: http://newsinfo.inquirer.net/904623/new-purchase-rules-eyed-during-crises#ixzz4jkiZKcEF
Sounds like a step onto a slippery slope to a procurement system without accountability, competition, transparency or integrity, as I've illustrated before: When corners are cut, even for great reasons (e.g., war), the way is opened for fraud. Also, refer to the tags/labels associated with this post, just below.

Monday, June 5, 2017

No emergency, just a desire to act quickly, like business

The procurement issues here raise issues of noncompetitive acquisitions, the requirement to obtain a fair and reasonable price before acquiring anything, even by sole source, and the contrast between government acquisition and private business. Government contracting requires market research to have independent knowledge of source alternatives in the market, prices and costs, as part of the acquisition process before a selection process is even chosen.

The governance policies of government acquisition are intended to assure transparency and the pursuit of effective competition within the free enterprise system. It is meant to avoid the secretive and arbitrary selection of colleagues and strong-arm "horse trading" linked to matters far afield from the instant acquisition that is the norm in private business ("you scratch my back and I'll scratch yours").

Government procurement is concerned with public confidence, fair and equitable treatment of market participants, maximization of public funds, and safeguards to establish and maintain a contracting system of integrity with accountability to the public. It's not meant to trade products or services for votes or favors or other "godfather offers".

In these respects, government procurement is intentionally designed to be the antithesis of private business, especially private business whose only concern is the welfare of the business owner. Not that there is anything wrong with that in the context of people betting their own money in their own smoke-filled rooms or out on the golf course or the box seat of some entertainment venue. 

But, private business has no concern about other people's money, whereas government must be concerned with other people's money or face a fractious public, as well as a mutinous supply of vendors. 
 
Again, I advise readers of articles I present to read the articles themselves, at the link provided. I omit, rearrange, slice, dice, paraphrase, editorialize and generally use the general fact situation of articles to provide teachable moments concerning procurement practice and principle. My version may or may not reflect the article's author's intent, and likely do not to my re-working of the following story, so read the original; click the link at the title.


No competition, no cost estimate as Kansas City firm picked for coveted VA contract McClatchy Washington Bureau
The federal government typically awards contracts to private companies after a competitive bidding process in order to keep costs low and avoid conflicts of interest. “When you have competitive bidding it prevents government officials from throwing contracts to their friends or keeping them from people they don’t like,” said Richard Painter, chairman of the board of Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, a nonpartisan watchdog group.

But, the Trump administration picked Kansas City-based Cerner Corp. for a coveted contract to modernize veterans health records, and there will be no competition for the taxpayer-funded project. Cerner partnered with defense technology contractor Leidos, Accenture Federal Services and Intermountain Healthcare in its bid for the $4.3 billion, 10-year defense contract. Other health IT companies didn’t have a chance.

VA Secretary David Shulkin told reporters his decision to waive competition and acquire Cerner’s software directly was motivated by President Donald Trump’s desire to act quickly. “From the outset that when the president selected me to be secretary, he made clear to me that he expected us to act with faster decisions, to act like business, and to really make sure that we are really doing the right thing to change veterans’ health care. And that's exactly what we’re trying to do today,” Shulkin said.

Shulkin said there was a “public interest exception” to allow awarding the Cerner contract without a “full and open competition.” The VA still must draw up a justification for waiving open and public competition, and Tester’s office will be following up with VA for those documents, said his spokesman, Dave Kuntz.

Sen. Jon Tester of Montana, the top Democrat on Senate’s Veterans Affairs Committee, was supportive of Shulkin’s announcement but his spokesman said he has some questions and concerns about timing and costs that the secretary did not answer. Neither Cerner nor the Department of Veterans Affairs could say how much the contract will cost, however.

“The challenge here is that by giving up competition, the VA has given up all control to the company” when it comes to price, said Phillip Carter, a senior fellow at the Center for a New American Security who teaches government contracts law at Georgetown University Law Center. “At the end of the day ... they’re probably going to pay whatever Cerner asks,” Carter said.

The new VA health records system won’t be identical to the Defense Department’s, but its core will be Cerner’s Millennium software, Shulkin said on Monday. He said Cerner’s work on the Pentagon’s system, now known as MHS Genesis, pushed his decision in Cerner’s favor. Adoption of the same system “will ultimately result in all patient data residing in one common system,” the secretary said.
To me, adopting a system that will ultimately result in "all data residing in one common" (but proprietary) software will assure everyone else will become locked out. There are historical precedents, such as Motorola's lock on emergency radio systems, and Microsoft's lock on desktop software systems. See, Sure, Kid, first one's free.


The US government has been trying hard to break free of such locks.  This procurement seems to also go against the US Government's Federal Source Code Policy: Achieving Efficiency, Transparency, and Innovation through Reusable and Open Source Software:
When Federal agencies are unable to identify an existing Federal or commercial software solution that satisfies their specific needs, they may choose to develop a custom software solution on their own or pay for its development. When agencies procure custom-developed source code, however, they do not necessarily make their new code (source code or code) broadly available for Federal Government-wide reuse.

Even when agencies are in a position to make their source code available on a Government-wide basis, they do not make such code available to other agencies in a consistent manner. In some cases, agencies may even have difficulty establishing that the software was produced in the performance of a Federal Government contract.
These challenges may result in duplicative acquisitions for substantially similar code and an inefficient use of taxpayer dollars.

This policy seeks to address these challenges by ensuring that new custom-developed Federal source code be made broadly available for reuse across the Federal Government. This is consistent with the Digital Government Strategy’s “Shared Platform” approach, which enables Federal employees to work together—both within and across agencies—to reduce costs, streamline development, apply uniform standards, and ensure consistency in creating and delivering information. Enhanced reuse of custom-developed code across the Federal Government can have significant benefits for American taxpayers, including decreasing duplicative costs for the same code and reducing Federal vendor lock-in.
Note also the internationally informed Open Source for Government component of the Open Spouse Initiative.

Other article(s) on this topic: VA to dump Vista for DOD's electronic health record system











Monday, May 29, 2017

Late paying government brings out the worst in vendors

$2.4M state warehouse lease renews procurement questions
Controversy surrounding a former furniture store in Springfield highlights the problems of a state lease procurement system dogged by bureaucracy, reliance on old-fashioned paper files and a state unable to pay its bills.

Climate Controlled Holdings LLC of Chicago bought an abandoned furniture store and refurbished it to meet the needs in the City of Springfield for a climate controlled warehouse for the Illinois Department of Human Services records. Although the details of the contracting process are fuzzy in this article, it appears Climate Controlled Holdings ended up with a five year lease worth $2.4 million. Climate Controlled Holdings and the five-year, $2.4 million lease since have become the focus of controversy over political influence in state leases, bureaucracy, reliance on paper records in a digital age, and the difficulty of determining whether the state is getting its money’s worth from public documents in private storage.

Allegations of improper political connections were raised in April when Champaign-based WCIA-TV reported on links between Springfield businessman Bill Cellini and Climate Controlled Holdings. Cellini has been dubbed “The King of Clout” for extensive business and political ties to state government through the years. He served about nine months of a one-year, one-day prison sentence on a 2011 federal corruption conviction for a failed attempt to shake down a Hollywood film producer for a $1.5 million contribution to the campaign of former Gov. Rod Blagojevich.

The Champaign station also highlighted the longtime Cellini friendship with Springfield businessman Frank Vala, who is chairman of the Illinois Procurement Policy Board. That board, which reviews state leases, allowed the South Grand Avenue lease to be approved in January without a vote. Secretary of State’s records show Climate Controlled Holdings agent Thomas Storniolo is also the agent for multiple Cellini-controlled New Frontier Management companies with Cellini’s children, William Jr. and Claudia, listed as presidents. But it was part-ownership in Climate Controlled Holdings by Claudia Cellini’s husband, Raffi Vartnaian, that raised questions of political influence and the Valla friendship with Cellini. Climate Controlled Holdings submitted the only bids for the lease through two separate companies.

Vala did not return messages, but Hurwitz said on behalf of the building partnership that the lease has been unfairly portrayed in media accounts and by state lawmakers. In addition to the $575,000 purchase price, she said the partnership invested approximately $1.25 million – a figure confirmed by state records -- to bring the building up to specifications required by the state, including construction of a loading dock, legal services, new lighting, security, new heating and air conditioning, roof work and electrical upgrades.
The partnership also is responsible for monthly management fees, property taxes, maintenance, insurance and other operational costs.

Hurwitz also said she learned of the state request for storage space thorough regular public notices sent out by the Department of Central Management Services, the state agency in charge of state buildings. “We did everything by the book and by the law, and we won the bid,” Hurwitz said.

“It’s an OK deal, if the state pays us,” Hurwitz said.

Hurwitz said there is reluctance among developers to take on the risk of state leases when Illinois is months behind in payments on dozens of local buildings, but that such deals remain attractive at a time when the commercial-leasing market continues to struggle.

“We went to another developer in town, but he turned it down because he was not willing to risk money on a state lease,” said Hurwitz, who added that the deal keeps the building on property tax rolls. Property taxes total just over $33,800 for 2017, according to county records.

Former state Sen. Susan Garrett, now chairwoman of the Illinois Campaign for Political Reform, said the state still needs stricter disclosure rules on companies involved in state leases. “It appears as if they’re shell companies,” Garrett said. “There are just so many loopholes there that allow this to happen.”

Ed Bedore has been a member of the Policy Procurement Board for 19 years, including when the Barney’s building lease was approved without a vote in January. Bedore said he understood at the time there had been two competitive bids, rather than separate bids from the same company.

He said he recently toured the facility and found it only about 40 percent to 50 percent full, though state officials indicate additional files would be moved to the site. In addition to questioning storage of public records in private buildings when so many state properties are vacant, Bedore said he has been pushing for years for the state to begin moving away from paper documents to digital records.

“We’re not in the 21st century, we’re not even in the 20th century, we’re in the 19th century,” said Bedore, who added that the transition could be done gradually to minimize costs.

Central Management Services Acting Director Mike Hoffman, who has insisted rules were followed on the Barney’s building lease, said after a legislative hearing on Thursday that it is common to receive only one or two bids on state leases, given the complexity of the process. He added that the bureaucracy often limits bids to companies that know how to work the system.

In an understatement, “The state also is not making payments,” Hoffman added, “and a limited number of people are willing to go through that process.”
Just a quick reminder: I edit, slice and dice articles discussed here for didactic focus and emphasis and personal viewpoint, so you absolutely must read the article at its source via the link in the title.

There is no point, though, in full disclosures, published notices and much of the effort involved in trying to "foster" competition, as the ABA Model Procurement Code requires (as does Guam's, which follows in the footsteps of the MPC: 5 GCA § 5001(b)(6)), if the government does not timely pay its vendors.

Slow and other delinquent payments, or even nonpayment, is the single most salient factor in dissuading vendors to bid. the fewer vendors there are who are willing to do business with the government, the higher prices will be. The more often government business is done with the same "boys' club", the more they will take advantage. The fewer competitive bidders there are, the less effective the policing of the procurement process is, because the only real time policing of the process is through a fair and expeditious protest system.

Government can do a lot to improve its systems to achieve lower costs.  But before fussing around with all the bureaucratic rigmarole, first pay the vendors promptly. That will save you more money in the long run than all that other distraction.