Labels and Tags

Accountability (71) Adequate documentation (7) ADR in procurement (4) Allocation of risks (6) Best interest of government (11) Best practices (19) Best value (15) Bidder prejudice (11) Blanket purchase agreement (1) Bridge contract (2) Bundling (6) Cancellation and rejection (2) Centralized procurement structure (12) Changes during bid process (14) Clarifications vs Discussions (1) Competence (9) Competition vs Efficiency (29) Competitive position (3) Compliance (35) Conflict of interest (32) Contract administration (26) Contract disputes (4) Contract extension or modification (9) Contract formation (1) Contract interpretation (1) Contract terms (3) Contract types (6) Contract vs solicitation dispute (2) Contractor responsibility (20) Conviction (4) Cooperative purchasing (3) Corrective action (1) Cost and pricing (13) Debarment (4) Determinations (8) Determining responsibility (37) Disclosure requirements (7) Discussions during solicitation (10) Disposal of surplus property (3) Effective enforcement requirement (35) Effective procurement management (5) Effective specifications (36) Emergency procurement (14) eProcurement (5) Equitable tolling (2) Evaluation of submissions (22) Fair and equitable treatment (14) Fair and reasonable value (23) Fiscal effect of procurement (14) Frivolous protest (1) Good governance (12) Governmental functions (27) Guam (14) Guam procurement law (12) Improper influence (11) Incumbency (13) Integrity of system (31) Interested party (7) Jurisdiction (1) Justification (1) Life-cycle cost (1) Limits of government contracting (5) Lore vs Law (4) market research (7) Materiality (3) Methods of source selection (33) Mistakes (4) Models of Procurement (1) Needs assessment (11) No harm no foul? (8) Offer & acceptance (1) Other procurement links (14) Outsourcing (34) Past performance (12) Planning policy (34) Politics of procurement (52) PPPs (6) Prequalification (1) Principle of competition (95) Principles of procurement (25) Private vs public contract (17) Procurement authority (5) Procurement controversies series (79) Procurement ethics (19) Procurement fraud (31) Procurement lifecycle (9) Procurement philosophy (17) Procurement procedures (30) Procurement reform (63) Procurement theory (11) Procurement workforce (2) Procurment philosophy (6) Professionalism (17) Protest - formality (2) Protest - timing (12) Protests - general (37) Purposes and policies of procurement (11) Recusal (1) Remedies (17) Requirement for new procurement (4) Resolution of protests (4) Responsiveness (14) Restrictive specifications (5) Review procedures (13) RFQ vs RFP (1) Scope of contract (16) Settlement (2) Social preference provisions (60) Sole source (48) Sovereign immunity (3) Staffing (8) Standard commercial products (3) Standards of review (2) Standing (6) Stays and injunctions (6) Structure of procurement (1) Substantiation (9) Surety (1) Suspension (6) The procurement record (1) The role of price (10) The subject matter of procurement (23) Trade agreements vs procurement (1) Training (33) Transparency (63) Uniformity (6) Unsolicited proposals (3)
Showing posts with label Procurement ethics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Procurement ethics. Show all posts

Thursday, July 12, 2018

He spoke proocurement reform, but got bespoke procurement

It looked good on paper, and, of course, after the horse had bolted:
• Watchdog groups are calling on the Legislature to pass, and for Governor Cuomo to sign, comprehensive “clean contracting” legislation
In 2016, an investigation into a sprawling alleged pay-to-play scheme connected to the Governor Cuomo’s Buffalo Billion economic development program resulted in charges against nine men, including a former top aide to Cuomo, Joe Percoco, and the former president of SUNY Polytechnic Institute, Alain Kaloyeros, a close government partner of Cuomo’s, on bid-rigging, bribery, and other charges.

The organizations -- including Reinvent Albany, New York Public Interest Group, Citizens Union, League of Women Voters, Fiscal Policy Institute, Common Cause, and Citizens Budget Commission -- are also urging state leaders to reduce the potential for conflicts of interest by exploring options to limit campaign contributions from anyone seeking a state contract. Nineteen states and New York City -- but not the state -- already have these anti-pay-to-play laws in place.

“The moment of truth has arrived. State and federal prosecutors say $800 million in state economic development contracts were rigged, but so far, the Legislature and governor have yet to act,” said John Kaehny, executive director of Reinvent Albany, standing in the state Capitol. “It’s time they pass common sense legislation that includes independent oversight over state contracts, uniform contracting rules, and transparency that will prevent corruption and abuse before it happens.”
• Governor Cuomo Announces 35th Proposal of the 2017 State of the State: Restoring the Integrity and Accountability of State Government Through Comprehensive Ethics Reform
The comprehensive package of reforms includes:

Advancing a constitutional amendment limiting outside income and creating a full-time legislature;
Advancing a constitutional amendment imposing term limits for elected officials;
Requiring members of the Legislature to obtain an advisory opinion before earning outside income;
Advancing legislation to close the “LLC Loophole;”
Instituting Public Financing and enacting a number of other campaign finance reforms;
Subjecting local elected officials to financial disclosure requirements;
Promoting Increased Transparency Through Comprehensive Reforms to the State Freedom of Information Law;
Expanding the State Inspector General's authority to SUNY and CUNY not-for-profits;
Creating new Inspectors General for the Port Authority and the State Education Department; and
Ensuring greater oversight of the state's procurement process.
• Statement from Governor Andrew M. Cuomo on Proposed Ethics Reforms Scandal seldom begins with evil, but with temptation, and temptation usually begins with a lack of watchfulness. I will create and appoint separate Inspector Generals for both SUNY and CUNY. They will be charged with identifying and investigating conflicts of interest, fraud, corruption and abuse. They will review contracts and hiring for both improper and illegal actions. They will look for personal benefit to any executive or legislative employee or improper actions with a third party. They will review all campuses and all affiliated entities. The IGs will have the authority to bring any report of improper conduct directly to law enforcement.

I will also appoint a Chief Procurement Officer for the Executive branch. That person will be charged with reviewing all state contracts, with an eye towards eliminating any wrongdoing, conflicts of interest or collusion. And just so there is no confusion, I do mean all contracts. Any contract or agreement that entails the disbursement of state funds will be subject to review. Any question of collusion, political benefit or personal connections will be thoroughly examined. The Chief Procurement Officer will have investigative and prosecutorial experience, and will be authorized to refer problematic issues directly to law enforcement for further action.
Alas, "Procurement reform became a hot-button issue following the arrest of several Cuomo allies on bid-rigging charges."

The rig was up, but not that many dominoes seemed to fall.

N.Y. developer pleads guilty ahead of 'Buffalo Billion' corruption trial
Kevin Schuler, formerly an executive at Buffalo-based LPCiminelli, admitted on Friday to wire fraud and conspiracy charges before U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni in Manhattan, less than a month before a scheduled trial. Schuler said he was involved in a bid-rigging scheme that allowed his company to win a lucrative contract as part of “Buffalo Billion,” a signature economic development project of New York Governor Andrew Cuomo to revitalize the region around Buffalo, New York.
And then: Architect of Cuomo’s Buffalo Billion Project Is Convicted in Bid-Rigging Scheme
Alain E. Kaloyeros, a principal architect of Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo’s signature economic development initiative, was convicted on Thursday in a bid-rigging scheme that steered hundreds of millions of dollars in state contracts to favored companies in Buffalo and Syracuse. Dr. Kaloyeros, 62, was found guilty of wire fraud and conspiracy in the fourth week of a federal trial in Manhattan that invited harsh scrutiny of Mr. Cuomo’s ambitious plan to revitalize upstate and western New York, known as the Buffalo Billion. Dr. Kaloyeros, the former president of SUNY Polytechnic Institute, had been credited with helping to create a high-tech industry in the capital region, which led Mr. Cuomo, a Democrat, to place him in charge of the Buffalo Billion project. The governor had praised Dr. Kaloyeros as a genius and “New York’s secret weapon.” Soon, the money began to flow to Buffalo; waterfront parks, gleaming modern factories and a cluster of medical and technology facilities were built.

Mr. Cuomo, who has not been accused by prosecutors of any wrongdoing, said after the verdict that he had “no tolerance for those who seek to defraud the system to advance their own personal interests. Anyone who has committed such an egregious act should be punished to the full extent of the law.”

But at the trial, the prosecution presented evidence that Dr. Kaloyeros and Todd R. Howe, a former lobbyist with ties to Mr. Cuomo, conspired to defraud Fort Schuyler Management Corporation, a nonprofit real estate arm of SUNY Polytechnic, by steering lucrative contracts to two firms whose executives were significant donors to Mr. Cuomo’s campaign. As part of the scheme, Dr. Kaloyeros and Mr. Howe tailored requests for proposals, or RFPs, to fit the specific qualifications possessed by the two companies — LPCiminelli, a Buffalo construction management firm, and COR Development, a Syracuse-area firm — and ensure that they be chosen by Fort Schuyler for the projects. LPCiminelli, for example, received a contract to build what became a $750 million solar-panel plant on the banks of the Buffalo River, while COR received contracts worth more than $100 million for other projects. Both firms were clients of Mr. Howe’s.

Michael C. Miller, a lawyer for Dr. Kaloyeros, said after the verdict that his client would appeal. “Alain Kaloyeros is innocent,” Mr. Miller said. “He did not rig bids. Not a penny was lost. Not a bribe was paid. He did the best job that he could for the State of New York and for Fort Schuyler, and we’re just utterly disappointed with the outcome of this case.”

Government watchdog groups said that the verdict, like dozens of previous cases touching on corruption in the state capital, was the result of a lack of strong ethics laws and enforcement.
Jury convicts Ciminelli, Kaloyeros in Buffalo Billion bid-rigging scheme
The jury obviously agreed with the government's key witness, former LPCiminelli vice president Kevin Schuler, who took a plea deal and testified against his former boss early in the trial. Prosecutors dropped their charges against former LPCiminelli executive Michael Laipple.

Schuler spelled out for the jury how he, Ciminelli and Kaloyeros conspired to make sure that LPCiminelli emerged as the winning bidder by designing the request for proposals, or RFP, to favor Ciminelli's company. "We had significant influence over the project, influence over the RFP and influence over the process that was going to select a winner," Schuler told the jury.

Most notably, potential bidders were told in 2013 that they had to have 50 years' worth of construction experience in the Buffalo area in order to qualify for the project. That prompted Schuler to show the jury a shirt, produced in 2011 celebrating LPCiminelli's 50th anniversary. "I think someone put this in to help us ... and I'd never seen a requirement like that," Schuler testified. State officials later shrank the requirement to 15 years of Buffalo experience, saying that the 50-year provision was a typographical error.
Of course, it's another election season, when procurement reform is a can to be kicked through a political goal post.  When procurement reformation is the lipstick slapped on political deformation.

As Governor Cuomo himself said in his Statement quoted above, "Democrats, Republicans, Conservatives, Liberals, Independents – no party or group is immune."

Monday, May 14, 2018

Reigning in the cozy relationships

The following article is interesting for the revelation of a statewide undeveloped procurement system that is finally seeing the light. It heralds new procurement reforms in the State of Arizona, "massive changes to how public schools will be allowed to hire builders for large construction projects, as well as harsh new penalties for malfeasance that occurs during the selection process". 

The things discussed in this article were mostly already dealt with long ago under Guam's procurement laws, taken from the ABA Model Procurement Code.

I only make reference to parts of this for its procurement lessons, so you should read the full article at the link.

Arizona upends school procurement laws in effort to cool cozy relationships with builders
Some in the construction industry, which was not consulted on the changes and fears a return to a system that prioritizes cost above outcomes, say the changes are a legislative overreaction to scandals that have roiled the Scottsdale Unified School District since late 2017.

The most significant change involves how construction companies will be selected. Beginning July 2019, instead of using a process that allows districts to subjectively score and select a construction manager to manage the entire project, builders will be selected based solely on who promises the lowest cost.
Comment: The new system can provide a lot of the accommodations allowed by the old one by use of the "multi-step" competitive sealed bid procurement method. It has been used extensively in recent times (some say too much so), which is known as the LPTA (Lowest Price, Technically Acceptable) source selection method. It involves two phases, the first of which is to assess the offers of the bidders to determine which qualify, followed by opening of sealed price bids. The first phase allows discussion to enable "potentially acceptable" bidders submit an acceptable bid.
Other provisions aim to prevent undue influence over the procurement process by restricting who gets to be part of the selection process and banning gifts given by contractors to district officials. Gifts from contractors to district procurement officials will be prohibited. “It was all aimed at trying to address corruption in financial management and procurement practices,” said House Speaker J.D. Mesnard, R-Chandler.
Comment: Guam law's ethics provisions prohibit the giving of gifts, gratuities and even "favors", deminimus benefits that may not even benefit a person but the organization. It is meant to stem paying to play relationships.
•Contracts will be awarded based on lowest price from a qualified bidder
•No contractor or subcontractor providing services to a district will be allowed to serve on a procurement selection committee
•Procurement officials will be prohibited from receiving a benefit to create a procurement specification in a particular way, such as to benefit a single company
•School districts must keep records that prove construction vendors are properly licensed.
The competitive sealed bid method is the preferred source selection model. Conflicts such as this are prohibited by ethics rules, and rules preventing non-government who consult in the preparation of specifications from being allowed to bid or have an interest in the bid. Procurement officials are required to keep extensive records related to procurements, which are public documents.
The Guam Supreme Court just published today a decision that held a solicitation had to be cancelled for failure to keep a the required record, thereby impeding a proper review of the conduct of the solicitation. Teleguam Holdings LLC v. Guam, 2018 Guam 5.
Charter schools will be exempt from the new rules.
Not on Guam, where the bulk of their money comes from public funds. Guam professes its purposes and policies of procurement to include to provide for increased public confidence in the procedures followed in public procurement; to ensure the fair and equitable treatment of all persons who deal with the procurement system; to provide increased economy in territorial activities and to maximize to the fullest extent practicable the purchasing value of public funds of the Territory; to foster effective broad-based competition within the free enterprise system; and, to provide safeguards for the maintenance of a procurement system of quality and integrity.

Monday, August 29, 2016

Transparency? You can't handle the transparency!

 NOTE: As usual, I have have changed the articles reported below, leaving material out, rearranging, and paraphrasing, to suit the purposes of this blawg. The obvious purpose here is the need to have adequate and effective transparency regimes in order to have and maintain good governance, in procurement as well as other aspects of government. You must read the full articles at the links to get the accurate version of the story.

Americans pay millions to whistleblower at BHP; we hound them out of their jobs
In Australia, those who flag corruption inside companies receive limited or no protection and are often sacked or mistreated, while in the United States, which paid for evidence that exposed alleged bribery by BHP Billiton, whistleblowers are encouraged to come forward. The calls for reform are being made as Fairfax Media can reveal new details of another whistleblower case that suggests serious ethical failings by a top Australian businesswoman and ABC board member, Kirstin Ferguson.

A Fair Work Commission complaint filed by the whistleblower alleges he was "victimised as a result of the disclosures" he made to Dr Ferguson about alleged corruption at mining services giant Thiess. Dr Ferguson is a director at Thiess' parent company, Leighton Holdings (now named CIMIC), and is responsible for company ethics as ethics committee chairwoman. Dr Ferguson declined to comment on detailed questions sent to her by Fairfax Media.

Key MPs Nick Xenophon, Jacqui Lambie and Andrew Wilkie, as well as the Greens and shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus have all said they will push in Parliament for stronger whistleblower laws to encourage reporting of corporate corruption.

In May, the US corporate watchdog, the Securities and Exchange Commission, revealed it would pay a bounty "to a company employee whose tip bolstered an ongoing investigation with additional evidence of wrongdoing". Legal sources have confirmed that the whistleblower was a BHP Billiton insider, paid US$3.75 million (about $4.96 million). The former employee provided detailed information to US investigators about the mining firm's activities overseas several years ago. The allegations remain the subject of an active Australian Federal Police bribery investigation.

It is the first time an employee of an Australian company has received a US whistleblower bounty. Under the US Sarbanes-Oxley Act, the SEC can reward whistleblowers by giving them a cut of a fine extracted from a company, with payouts often reaching many millions of dollars.

In May 2015, BHP Billiton agreed to pay $US25 million to the SEC to settle an inquiry into trips to the Beijing Olympics that the company gave to government officials. The officials represented countries where the miner was operating, and where it was sometimes seeking government permits. BHP Billiton said in a statement that, during that inquiry, the SEC had made no findings of bribery or corrupt intent against the company, and that the US Department of Justice had investigated but took no action. The company said it was not aware of the involvement of any whistleblower as part of either investigation. "We respect and fully support protections for all whistleblowers, and the importance of providing confidential avenues for reporting," the statement said.

Senator Lambie, who has taken up the cause of a Defence Department whistleblower, said she wanted "world's best practice" whistleblower laws which would "strengthen our democracy, prevent and uncover official corruption, decrease government waste, save lives, money and prevent damage to our environment".

Shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus said private sector employees should enjoy the same whistleblower protection as people in the public sector because their information is "just as valuable to our community, and they should not be treated differently under the law".

"Recently a string of brave private sector whistleblowers have come forward with valuable information, including those who have exposed wrongdoing in our banking sector. They deserve our protection," Mr Dreyfus said.

Mr Day says there was merit in compensating whistleblowers, although he cautioned against aspects of the US scheme. Senator Nick Xenophon has told Fairfax Media that "whistleblowers in the US get rewarded and protected, but here they get punished and ruined". Andrew Wilkie, who was recently elected as an independent MP in Tasmania, said Australia had a cultural problem in which whistleblowers were scorned as untrustworthy dobbers, or unhinged: "In the US whistleblowers are celebrated, but in Australia they're often vilified," he said.

"Greater whistleblower protection is one of the building blocks of a healthy democracy and ... of a healthy corporate culture."

ASIC executive Warren Day believes new whistleblowing laws could provide far greater clarity and protection for employees who wanted to report a range of misconduct, spanning financial crime and environmental or health and safety breaches although he cautioned against aspects of the US scheme. Minister for Financial Services Kelly O'Dwyer said the government was looking at strengthening Australia's corporate whistleblower regime. Minister O'Dwyer said that, as it looked to strengthen legislation, the government would "follow usual process, and will consult publicly".
The 'naively noble' man who could not get his voice heard
The words, coming from the chairwoman of the board's ethics committee, were intended to be reassuring: "I'm really glad to have you in that role. I really am," she said. Dr Kirstin Ferguson was speaking to "David" (not his real name) who for more than two years had been working to stamp out alleged corruption and misconduct within his company. David was suffering stress and anxiety because he feared - with good reason - that his boss was cutting him loose.

David's faith in his company was first shaken in November 2011. As one of Thiess' more senior figures, David came across a document, signed by his boss Bruce Munro more than three years earlier, as part of the company's 2008 tender for a $5.5 billion mining concession in India.

It quickly became clear that the deal might have had at its heart a corrupt arrangement. Documents and key emails suggested that Thiess' business partner in India would be paying $12 million to powerful Indian government officials - an apparently illegal payment under Australian law.

But two weeks after speaking to her, Ferguson's reassurances meant nothing. David was given three months' notice and told to go immediately on "garden leave".

The company was Thiess, part of Leighton group, which has been implicated in among the most serious foreign bribery and corruption cases in recent Australian history. David's boss was then Thiess managing director Bruce Munro, who later left the company under a cloud.

As for the ethics committee chairwoman, Dr Ferguson: she is still there, and still in the top integrity role at the firm, since renamed CIMIC. She has since scored one of the most high-profile jobs in Australia - she was appointed by the Coalition government as a director of the ABC board, where she is a member of its audit and risk committee, the body in charge of overseeing ethical behaviour.

David declined to speak to Fairfax Media, but his full story can now be told for the first time through documents held by Thiess and CIMIC, and leaked by a source close to both firms.

In the United States, someone who came forward with information about corporate malfeasance might be paid millions of dollars. In Australia, speaking out is a shortcut to dismissal, despair and unemployment. And so far in this country, whistleblowers cannot even console themselves that the bad guys will be held to account for the deeds exposed, given the difficulty often facing police or the corporate regulator in investigating, prosecuting and punishing large companies.

Inside Leighton, some were concerned the company might have a deep ethical problem. So a new confidential internal review, Project Mango, was ordered into whether Leighton might be exposed to corruption issues elsewhere. It turned up about 100 payments made by Thiess employees in Indonesia to the country's government, military and policing officials. Not everyone appreciated the revelation.

David's boss was then Thiess managing director Bruce Munro, who later left the company under a cloud. Munro was concerned that risk and compliance activities were cramping the style of those whose job it was to win contracts in difficult markets.

"I want you to ... have a look and tell them [senior management] that there is nothing to see here ... We are tying people up in paperwork. Our processes have gone too far".

In court documents linked to the whistleblower's case, it's alleged that Munro explained to the whistleblower that the sticklers for good process inside the firm would have "never let me sign it [a deal with the Indian partner]". Alarmed at what he had seen, David escalated the emails and Leighton senior management ordered an external investigation. It was codenamed "Project Orange."

When the Project Orange investigation was completed, it suggested Leighton may need to inform the Australian Stock Exchange of a foreign bribery matter. Munro had breached the company's code of ethics and internal policies, the report found. However, there was not yet enough evidence for criminal charges.

n March 2014, as Project Mango was underway, Leighton was taken over by a Spanish group and eventually renamed CIMIC. But if anyone hoped the change of management would lead to a more open culture, those hopes were quickly snuffed. The senior executives who had commissioned Project Mango were sacked and the new bosses wanted it shut down. The story about the payments to Indonesian soldiers was reported, via a leak, in Fairfax Media. But instead of performing a mea culpa, an internal witch hunt for the leakers began.

After that, precisely nothing happened. The market was not informed. Munro kept his job.

In July 2014, Dr Kirstin Ferguson, a former flight lieutenant in the air force, an expert in safety, a lawyer, a PhD in corporate governance and a professional company director, became the head of CIMIC's ethics committee.

Two weeks after her appointment, David rang her. He wanted to meet for coffee. He asked if she knew about what had happened in India, if she was aware of Project Orange. "If I were in your position, I would want to know this," he said of the "biggest ethical issue the company has and would be the biggest ever in Australia."

"I do. I really do," she replied, adding reassuringly: "I'm really glad that we have you in that role."

But a fortnight later, David received a call from the "manager of people" at CIMIC. He was told he "hasn't made it in the restructure". He'd lost his job, and was sent immediately on three months gardening leave.

Two days later, Dr Ferguson sent David a text. To a person humiliated, isolated and sacked for trying to report wrongdoing in front of him, the message rubbed salt into his wounds.

"Hi - just wanted to let you know I have been following up on your call and will be sure to call you when done," Dr Ferguson wrote. It might take another couple of weeks, she said.

David's lawyers later argued his conversation with Ferguson should have been a "protected disclosure" under Australia's flawed whistleblower regime.

Friday, August 12, 2016

Outsourcing pre-judicial review of administrative processing

The following article, and the case which it reports, is not exactly about procurement. It does, though, inform the discussion about how to determine which activities of a government are legislatively determined to be governmental functions that must be performed by the government. The function in controversy here is the initial review of a contested parking ticket.

The article bringing this to light was flagged by the State Bar of California's Daily News Digest August 12, 2016, and appeared on NBC Los Angeles News online.

City of Los Angeles Ordered to Change Parking Ticket Dispute Process
The California Court of Appeal has ordered the City of Los Angeles to change the way it handles parking ticket disputes. A three-judge panel said the city can no longer outsource the handling of the initial reviews of parking tickets requested by motorists, but must do those reviews themselves. The appeals court’s decision, handed down this week, says the state vehicle code requires cities, not outside contractors, to conduct all initial reviews of parking tickets.
The case is Weiss v. City of Los Angeles. Pieces of the case reflected below are my own editorializing, and cut, rearranged, left out, paraphrased and otherwise altered and (mis)construed, as is my practice in this blawg. Thus, you are better served by reading the case in its entirely at the link.
In this appeal by the City of Los Angeles (City) and Xerox Business Services, Inc. (Xerox,) we consider whether the City, as the “issuing agency” for notice of parking violations in the City, must conduct the “initial review” of challenged citations, or whether it may delegate that duty to Xerox, its “processing agency”. [The decision in the case required interpretation of the complex statutory scheme, which had evolved over time. As is the case with many such statutory evolutions, some genes change, some stay the same and some just disappear, making the interpretation process more complex than a simple reading of a single statute might suggest.]

Weiss got a parking ticket, which he contested. After an initial review performed by Xerox, Weiss received a letter advising him that an initial review had been performed and the citation would not be cancelled. [There followed a round-about means of getting the issue before the court, interesting for those studying writs of mandate, standing and the like, but not germane to this post, which is more about the question, how to determine if a particular governmental function can to delegated to a private contractor. Thus, I limit the discussion here to:"Weiss’ claim that the initial review process, as currently constituted, did not comply with the statutory obligations of the initial review under the Vehicle Code".] Since 1985, the City has contracted with Xerox to act as its processing agency. As part of Xerox’s processing duties, the City delegates the duty to conduct the initial review of contested citations. Xerox is paid based on the number of parking citations processed per month, but does not receive additional compensation to conduct initial reviews. Xerox performs the initial reviews through its Parking Violations Bureau (Bureau), which is staffed by a subcontractor. In fiscal year 2013, Xerox conducted 135,291 initial reviews [constituting about 5% of citations processed].

The initial review is conducted by Bureau clerks, who must adhere to 46 Business Processing Rules (BPR), drafted by the City (or by Xerox and approved by the City). When considering a contested citation, the Bureau clerk refers to the applicable BPR, if any; if that BPR permits dismissal of a citation, the clerk dismisses it. If no BPR addresses the particular challenge, but a motorist has presented sufficient evidence to overcome a citation, clerks are instructed to refer the matter to a supervisor for a decision. The motorist learns the result of the initial review through one of 97 form letters drafted and approved by the City, on City letterhead, sent to the motorist by Xerox.

The trial court below concluded that, setting aside the issue whether Xerox was authorized to conduct the initial review, the City’s system of initial review complied with the Vehicle Code requirements in the scope of the review, in the fairness of its procedure to the motorist, and in the fairness of its substantive decision-making process.

The question at issue in this appeal [and this post] is whether the state vehicle code requires that the City, as the issuing agency, conduct the initial review, rather than its processing agency, Xerox. In its ruling, the court below reviewed the statutory framework, its legislative history (including pertinent existing, amended and repealed Vehicle Code sections), and case law. Conceding that the question was close, the court concluded that legislative changes in 1995 to the statutory scheme reflected the Legislature’s intent to place a nondelegable duty to perform the initial review on the City, the public agency that issues parking citations.

The 1993 revision maintained the prior definition of a “processing agency”; ‘processing agency’ means the contracting party responsible for the processing of the notices of parking violations and notices of delinquent parking violations. It also contained an amended version of section 40200.5, which preserved the issuing agency’s authority to contract with a processing agency (“an issuing agency may elect to contract with the county, with a private vendor, or [others] . . . for the processing of notices of parking violations and notices of delinquent parking violations....

Prior to the 1995 revisions, the legislation allowed an issuing agency to contract with a processing agency for the processing of notices of parking violations, including investigating the circumstances of the citation and conducting the initial review as well as giving the processing agency the authority to make the decision whether to cancel the citation.

The 1995 revisions repealed the previous statutes which had expressly provided that the processing agency may conduct initial reviews, and gave the processing agency the authority to investigate challenged citations. It enacted a new provisions assigning responsibility for conducting the initial review to the “issuing agency,” giving that agency the authority to determine whether to cancel the citation, and requiring it to inform the processing agency of its decision, further eliminating any reference to the authority of the “processing agency” to conduct the initial review.

Legislative deletion of an express statutory provision “‘is presumed to effect a substantial change in the law’ [citation].” (Barajas v. City of Anaheim (1993) 15 Cal.App.4th 1808, 1814.) Considered in their entirety, the 1995 changes strongly suggest that by repealing section 40200.7 and former section 40215, and replacing them with a new section 40215, the Legislature intended to give sole authority to conduct the initial review to the issuing agency, and to preclude delegation of that duty to the processing agency. No other rational explanation comports with the breadth of the modifications eliminating references to the processing agency’s authority.

But, the 1995 revisions did not amend section 40200.5 to directly reflect the elimination of the processing agency’s authority to conduct the initial review. Thus it remains that the issuing agency could contract with a processing agency “for the processing of notices of parking violations and notices of delinquent parking violations, prior to filing with the court...." This might be read in isolation, without considering the 1995 changes, as suggesting that the issuing agency may contract with the processing agency to conduct the initial review because that review occurs before the judicial review.

However, given the history of the relevant statutes as we have traced them, it is unreasonable to assume that by failing to amend section 40200.5, the Legislature intended to retain the authority of the processing agency to conduct the initial review and undo the changes it so clearly made in the 1995 amendments.

The 1995 changes deleting any reference to the processing agency’s authority to conduct the initial review, compel the conclusion that the issuing agency (here, the City) must conduct the initial review, and cannot delegate that duty by contract to the processing agency (here, Xerox).

There are, at least, a couple of procurement questions that jumped out at me from the case. First, recall that Since 1985, the City has contracted with Xerox to act as its processing agency, and is paid based on the number of parking citations processed per month, but does not receive additional compensation to conduct initial reviews. I cannot believe that if another contractor held the contract for processing parking citations, that Xerox (or any other contractor) would conduct the initial reviews "for free", recalling again there were 135,291 such initial reviews conducted in 2013. I wonder what the cost of doing that "free" work would be if contracted out to another party, and if that "free" work is actually paid by inflated prices or costs in the "processing" portion of the work.

Second there is an aspect of Guam Procurement Ethics law that stands out. This "free work" is given as part and parcel of getting actual paid work. It is not a gratuity as typically defined because there is nothing paid to a particular person, and no particular person is benefited. But under Guam Procurement Ethics law (5 GCA § 5630(d)):
It shall be a breach of ethical standards for any person who is or may become a contractor ... to offer, give or agree to give any employee or agent of the Territory or for any employee or agent of the Territory to solicit or accept from any such person or entity or agent thereof, a favor or gratuity on behalf of the Territory whether or not such favor or gratuity may be considered a reimbursable expense of the Territory, during the pendency of any matter related to procurement, including contract performance warranty periods.

For purposes of this Section, a favor is anything, including raffle tickets, of more than deminimus value and whether intended for the personal enjoyment of the receiver or for the department or organization in which they are employed or for any person, association, club or organization associated therewith or sponsored thereby.
Guam legislators are (most of the time, on whole) sensitive to "buy in" and bundling and other evils that diminish competition and stain the integrity of the procurement system and undermine the peoples' trust in government.



Thursday, February 18, 2016

A(nother) contractor gets kicked back

Federal Government Contractor Sentenced To Prison For Accepting Kickbacks And Tax Evasion
An Enterprise, Alabama, resident was sentenced today in the Southern District of Florida to 48 months in prison to be followed by three years of supervised release for accepting unlawful kickbacks and tax evasion, announced Acting Assistant Attorney General Caroline D. Ciraolo of the Justice Department’s Tax Division.

According to court documents and statements made in open court, Victor Villalobos, 47, worked for a federal prime contractor at Fort Rucker, Alabama. In 2009, Villalobos approached Maxim Silinsky, a Florida-based subcontractor for this company, and solicited illegal kickbacks on the federal subcontracts that Silinsky held in connection with the federal prime contractor. Villalobos agreed that in exchange for kickback payments he would refrain from conduct that would unfavorably affect Silinsky’s business relationship with the federal prime contractor and help ensure that he obtained additional business.

As part of his plea, Villalobos admitted that from June 2009 to December 2014, he received approximately 57 separate wire transfers totaling more than $1.9 million in kickback payments from various foreign and domestic bank accounts controlled by Silinsky. At two separate meetings in 2015, Villalobos accepted envelopes from Silinsky containing cash kickbacks totaling $60,000. Between June 2009 and February 2015, Villalobos attempted to conceal his receipt of the kickbacks by forming nominee entities and opening nominee bank accounts. Villalobos also admitted that he evaded paying income taxes on the kickback payments by causing false federal income tax returns to be filed with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

In addition to his prison sentence, U.S. District Judge Daniel T.K. Hurley ordered Villalobos to pay $542,562 in restitution to the IRS. As part of his plea agreement, Villalobos also agreed to be permanently debarred from federal government contracting.

Silinsky pleaded guilty to filing a false tax return in November 2015 and cooperated in the investigation and prosecution of Villalobos. Silinsky was sentenced to one year and one day in prison on Feb. 2. Silinsky also cooperated in the investigation and prosecution of Trevor Smith, a retired U.S. Air Force Master Sergeant who pleaded guilty in October 2015 to unlawfully disclosing confidential procurement information and filing a false tax return. On Jan. 28, Smith was sentenced to 18 months in prison.

Monday, November 9, 2015

US States mostly flunk transparency and integrity audit: no political will, not a voter issue

Secrecy, corruption and conflicts of interest pervade state governments
The comprehensive probe reported in the 2015 State Integrity Investigation, a data-driven assessment of state government by the Center for Public Integrity and Global Integrity, found that in state after state, open records laws are laced with exemptions, and part-time legislators and agency officials engage in glaring conflicts of interests and cozy relationships with lobbyists while feckless, understaffed watchdogs struggle to enforce laws as porous as honeycombs.

When first conducted in 2011-2012, the State Integrity Investigation was an unprecedented look at the systems that state governments use to prevent corruption and expose it when it does occur. The 2015 grades are based on 245 questions that ask about key indicators of transparency and accountability, looking not only at what the laws say, but also how well they’re enforced or implemented. The “indicators” are divided into 13 categories: public access to information, political financing, electoral oversight, executive accountability, legislative accountability, judicial accountability, state budget processes, state civil service management, procurement, internal auditing, lobbying disclosure, state pension fund management and ethics enforcement agencies.

The results are “disappointing but not surprising,” said Paula A. Franzese, an expert in state and local government ethics at Seton Hall University School of Law and former chairwoman of the New Jersey State Ethics Commission. “It’s not the sort of issue that commands voters,” she said.

Aside from a few exceptions, there has been little progress on these issues since the State Integrity Investigation was first carried out in 2012. In fact, most scores have dropped since then, though some of that is attributable to changes made to improve and update the project and its methodology.

Since State Integrity’s first go-round, at least 12 states have seen their legislative leaders or top Cabinet-level officials charged, convicted or resign as a result of ethics or corruption-related scandal. Five House or Assembly leaders have fallen. No state has outdone New York, where 14 lawmakers have left office since the beginning of 2012 because of ethical or criminal issues, according to a count by Citizens Union, an advocacy group. That does not include the former leaders of both the Assembly and the Senate, who were charged in unrelated corruption schemes this year but remain in office while they await trial.

Though every state in the nation has open records and meetings laws, they’re typically shot through with holes and exemptions and usually have essentially no enforcement mechanisms, beyond the court system, when agencies refuse to comply. In most states, at least one entire branch of government or agency claims exemptions from the laws. Many agencies routinely fail to explain why they they’ve denied requests. Public officials charge excessive fees to discourage requestors. In the vast majority of states, citizens are unable to quickly and affordably resolve appeals when their records are denied. Only one state — Missouri — received a perfect score on a question asking whether citizens actually receive responses to their requests swiftly and at reasonable cost.

“We’re seeing increased secrecy throughout the country at the state and federal level,” said David Cuillier, director of the University of Arizona’s School of Journalism and an expert on open records laws. He said substantial research shows that the nation’s open records laws have been poked and prodded to include a sprawling list of exemptions and impediments and that public officials increasingly use those statutes to deny access to records. “It’s getting worse every year,” he said.
Florida bombs public integrity test

How Missouri got a D-minus in national ethics report

Kentucky gets D+ grade in 2015 State Integrity Investigation: yawning gaps in oversight remain


Texas Gets a D- in 2015 State Integrity Investigation

Maryland receives ‘F’ grade in public access to information

Hawaii gets D+ grade in 2015 State Integrity Investigation: Lobbyists thrive in land of sunshine

How does your state rank for integrity?
The investigation shows that states have their work cut out for them:

>>  Most states are still grappling with the provision of meaningful and responsive implementation mechanisms to provide citizens and journalists with access to public information. Some — if not most of these barriers — seem to be rooted in the lack of political will, rather than genuinely technical hurdles.
>>  ‘Open data’ is not yet a reality across state governments. While many governments do not make available any open data in particular sectors, electoral data and campaign finance data make a noticeable exception with a few state governments making data sets available in open formats.
>>  Many states fail to ensure their accountability institutions are truly independent. In other cases states reverse hard won gains. Instead, institutions such as independent ethics entities, audit institutions or access-to-information monitoring agencies regularly lack resources and/or their mandates are curtailed.

Unfortunately, the report does not look at US Territories, such as Guam. It would be interesting to see how the whole USA stacks up.

FOLLOW UP:

There is and will be more to this story, as it travels around the states, such as:

Michigan ranks last in laws on ethics, transparency
Michigan, which already had a distinction as one of only two states where both the governor and the Legislature are exempted from state open records laws, has moved backward since 2012.... Of the 245 "corruption risk indicators" in 13 categories examined in the study, Michigan ranked last for laws and systems related to executive accountability, legislative accountability, judicial accountability and management of pension funds. Michigan also received grades of F, but did not get ranked last in the nation, in categories related to public access to information, political finance, civil service oversight, procurement, lobbying oversight and ethics oversight.
EDITORIAL: Massachusetts public records reform can't wait

Trouble at the Statehouse: secrecy, questionable ethics and conflicts of interest

Ohio graded D+ in report on integrity — but that was 6th best among 50 states
“While Ohio has many appropriate ethics rules and a strong Sunshine Law, there are simply too many loopholes,” Catherine Turcer, a veteran government watchdog with Common Cause-Ohio, said in the report.

New report a blow to ethics reform in Georgia
The Georgia Legislature has done very little to improve our ethics laws in the past three years, enforcement of open meetings and records laws is non-existent, and we have experienced unprecedented scandals with our state ethics commission that included interference with ethics investigations by the Office of the Governor.

Meaningful ethics reform has not happened in our state in decades, and this 2015 State Integrity Investigation will be the death knell to ethics reform for many more years to come.


Wednesday, July 29, 2015

"Same old story ... failure to follow the rules"

Too many people blame the rules. They'd rather do without them. This is (another) story of how that works out for you.  Not surprisingly, this comes from Texas.

State auditors find problems with Land Office contracts
The Texas General Land Office had a conflict of interest when hiring the firm Grant Thornton LLP for oil and gas royalty audits. The July 2015 report said the land office’s former director of financial subsidiary operations had a “personal and professional association with her former supervisor,” who now works as a subcontractor to Grant Thornton. The land office employee served as a liaison between the two offices.

State Auditor Terry Keel’s office launched its audit in December 2014 after the three contracts were procured. The land office agreed with the state’s recommendations, which called for a cost analysis, a needs assessment and addressing any conflicts of interests prior to each procurement.

State procurement requirements call for agencies to disclose conflicts of interests during contract planning but the office failed to do so. [Some go further: disclosure only works when someone somewhere cares and pays attention. Some jurisdictions require recusal, and some fewer add bite to the requirement.]

Tom “Smitty” Smith of the group Public Citizen said, “It is the same old story of allegations of conflict of interest and failure to follow the rules for contracting.”

The state also found that the land office did not compare the cost of hiring full-time employees to conduct oil and gas royalty audits with the cost of contracting Grant Thornton LLP. According to the report, the office could have hired four employees to complete four audits for $426,813, but the Grant Thornton contract totaled more than $1 million.

A separate contract with IDEA Integration Corporation for information technology services was also not planned and monitored correctly, the audit found. The state’s Quality Assurance Team, which monitors major information resources projects for agencies, was not involved with the $1.9 million contract. Normally, if contract expenditures exceed $1 million it must be reviewed by the group.

In addition, the office assigned contract managers that had not obtained contract management training that is required by law.

This is not the first time state contracting practices have been under scrutiny, but Gov. Greg Abbott recently signed approved legislation that will strengthen state contracting regulations. The approval came after it was discovered that the Health and Human Services Commission handed a $110 million contract to Austin technology company 21CT. “It just goes to show you can’t trust the state agencies to do it without an outside agency to supervise their work,” Smith said. “This is the same story here — agency after agency failing to follow basic contracting provisions.”

Audit Finds "Significant Weaknesses" in GLO Contracting
The General Land Office’s contracting procedures are riddled with “significant weaknesses” that threaten the agency’s ability to ensure it is wisely spending its dollars, State Auditor John Keel said in a report made public Tuesday. “Due to significant weaknesses in its processes,” the audit said, the General Land Office “did not always plan, procure, form, and monitor” the contracts according to state rules and the agency’s own policies.

The GLO has a wide range of duties, including managing the rights to millions of acres of state-owned minerals, protecting the state’s coastline, handling billions of dollars for disaster recovery, preserving the Alamo and administering loans and other benefits to veterans.

For the nearly $2 million Grant Thornton contract, signed in 2013 and renewed in 2014, the auditor identified “significant deficiencies,” such as failing to study whether it needed to hire the firm in the first place. “The Office did not assess the need to hire Grant Thornton to provide supplemental staffing for the Office’s existing minerals audit department,” the report said. The agency researched rates at other firms, but only after it decided to hire Grant Thornton.

The agency initially told the state auditor that it removed the employee from the Grant Thornton contract, but it downplayed her involvement in brokering the contract. The auditor, however, concluded that the employee “had a significant role in the procurement,” including attending a relevant meeting, preparing a proposal for staffing mineral audits with Grant Thornton personnel and helping approve contracts with the company in 2013 and 2014.

The audit found other problems with the information technology contract with IDEA Integration Corporation. In that case, the report said, the GLO prepared an incomplete “statement of work,” and underestimated the roughly $1.9 million cost. The agency initially pegged the cost at about $93,000. While planning the deal, the agency "did not include key information, such as project time lines and applicable Texas Administrative Code information technology requirements," the report said.

Because of that error, the auditor said, agency staff did not complete disclosure forms designed to ward off nepotism, as required for contracts over $1 million.

In contrast, this:

UK: How To Guard Against Bribery And Corruption In The Tender Process
Any company caught paying bribes faces the prospect of a criminal conviction, an unlimited fine and terrible publicity. A further consequence for those supplying the public sector, is a discretionary ban from bidding for government contracts across the EU if the company is convicted of the offence of failing to prevent bribery under section seven of the Bribery Act 2010. The ban would be mandatory if one of the directors (or any person who has powers of representation, decision or control of the company) is involved and is convicted of bribing another person or a foreign public official under sections one or six of the Act. The stakes are high so it is important to have policies to prevent bribes being paid on your behalf.

For example taking a procurement manager for an expensive day out shortly before they decide on a tender. This could be unlawful if the intention was to influence their decision to favour your bid for reasons other than the relative merits of your tender. Timing is everything. The closer in time the hospitality is to a contract award the greater the likelihood that there will be an inference of impropriety.

What is required is a culture in which bribery is not tolerated at any level.

In a procurement setting you must understand the rules and stick to them.

Monday, December 22, 2014

Procurement controversy -- Incorrect Corrections in Mississippi

State awards billions in no-bid contracts
State government spends billions of taxpayers' dollars — nearly $6.5 billion in the last four years — through "no-bid" contracts, with little oversight or transparency. It's a system ripe for overspending, malfeasance and cronyism. And it's one that apparently allowed corruption to fester for years, with the head of the state prisons system allegedly taking $2 million in bribes to hand out hundreds of millions of dollars in no-bid contracts. A Clarion-Ledger analysis of state records in the wake of that scandal discovered not only a lack of accurate data on no-bid agreements but numerous contracts with little or no explanation.

These include contracts given to sole-source vendors, whose products and services state agency officials claim no one else can provide, contracts with those whose professions are exempt from bidding and "emergency" contracts. It also includes contracts with dollar amounts that fall below generous state thresholds for bidding.

Some state officials concede Mississippi government has a contracting system with thresholds for bidding that are too high and with too many exemptions. They also say there appears to be abuse of provisions for emergency contracts and overall lax oversight, provided primarily by a board of the same state agency leaders who are inking the contracts.

In general, state agency leaders within liberal limits can hire whomever they want for whatever price they decide. Need to hire a motivational speaker? No bidding is required as long as it's under $100,000. Need an accountant or engineer? No bidding or approval needed because their services are exempt. Need a media consultant? No bidding is required if you declare it an emergency.

"At this point, I do not have proof that there is corruption (beyond the prisons scandal), but I think the Legislature in the past that set up this review board and system made it awfully easy for corruption to exist," said House Accountability, Transparency and Efficiency chairman Jerry Turner, who's leading the charge for reform.
MDOC Scandal Highlights Privatization Problems
Facing a federal magistrate judge in Jackson, Chris Epps and Cecil McCrory made a curious pair. Despite receiving his appointment to one of the most visible posts in state government from Democratic Gov. Ronnie Musgrove, Epps was also able to survive Mississippi's hyper-partisan government, later serving under conservative Republicans Haley Barbour and Phil Bryant. McCrory, Epps' alleged co-conspirator, seemed to have been a key cog in that system. A former legislator who held a number of elected political positions as a Republican, McCrory knew all the ins and outs of state government. During his time in the Legislature, he served on the Joint Committee on Performance Evaluation and Expenditure Review (PEER), the very agency that would later raise questions about McCrory's business dealings with the state. At their arraignment before U.S. Magistrate Judge Keith Ball, both men pleaded not guilty on all counts.

The alleged activities outlined in the indictment began seven years ago, in November 2007, when Epps signed a no-bid contract with G.T. Enterprises for commissary services at state prisons. That year, McCrory paid Epps $3,000 to $4,000 on about 15 occasions in exchange for the contract that McCrory's company's had with MDOC. That contract was later transferred to St. Louis, Mo.-based Keefe Commissary Network LLC., which resulted in a large profit for McCrory, the indictment states.

Despite PEER's criticism of Epps' no-bid contract for commissary services in 2011, policymakers failed then to take action on the report. Rick Ward, a former official with the Mississippi Gaming Commission, called PEER, which performs thorough investigations but lacks any enforcement power, a paper tiger. "The problems is you've got members of the Legislature on the commission—that's like the fox guarding the henhouse," Ward said. "It's a waste of our taxpayer dollars."
Prison review group examining no-bid contracts
Republican Gov. Phil Bryant appointed a bipartisan, five-member task force to examine the Mississippi Department of Corrections' spending practices after former Corrections Commissioner Christopher Epps and businessman Cecil McCrory were indicted last month on federal corruption charges.

"What we're going to do is try to review all the contracts that have been involved in this indictment and also all the other contracts for the Department of Corrections to see if we can change some of the practices, maybe close some of the loopholes that caused this big mess," said one of the members, former Attorney General Mike Moore. "As you know, taxpayer money must be spent to serve the needs of the public, not to perpetuate ineffective contracts or enrich government officials," Bryant wrote.
Lawyers: Epps said prison companies 'spread' money
During 2011 negotiations, then-Corrections Commissioner Chris Epps said he couldn't get rid of Mississippi's private companies running prisons "because of all the money they spread around Jackson," attorneys told The Clarion-Ledger. His remarks took place during the time when federal prosecutors say Epps was receiving more than $700,000 in bribes, including a beachfront condo.

In early 2011, Margaret Winter, associate director of the ACLU, and Sheila Bedi, then-deputy legal director for the Southern Poverty Law Center, had a meeting with Epps, which they say was also attended by Department of Corrections officials, attorneys and consultants. Bedi said Epps gave her the impression he desired to hold the private prisons accountable, but his hands were tied. She said she thought, "This is a progressive reformer beating his head against the wall." Winter said she asked Epps point blank, "Why don't you just get rid of the private contractors? We all know they're part of the problem, not part of the solution." Bedi said Epps went on to say that it was impossible to get rid of the private contractors "because of all the money they throw around Jackson."
Christopher Epps, Former Chief of Prisons in Mississippi, Is Arraigned The indictment says that Mr. McCrory operated several companies that had contracts with the state, including for prison administration, commissary services and evaluating Medicaid eligibility across the state prison system. Mr. Epps, 53, had been Mississippi’s longest-serving corrections commissioner until he resigned Wednesday. He had been president of both the Association of State Correctional Administrators and the American Correctional Association until his resignation. Mr. McCrory resigned as president of the Rankin County School Board on Wednesday within hours of Mr. Epps’s resignation.

In addition to owning companies with state prison contracts, Mr. McCrory was a paid consultant to firms seeking such deals in Mississippi, including the Management & Training Corporation, a private company based in Utah that operates the East Mississippi Correctional Facility in Lauderdale County, Miss. According to the indictment, around the time that Mr. Epps signed a contract with the Management & Training Corporation to run the prison in August 2012, Mr. McCrory — the company’s consultant — wired $34,000 to Wells Fargo Home Mortgage as a payment on a condominium Mr. Epps had recently bought in Biloxi, Miss. Mr. Epps, according to the indictment, had suggested that Management & Training Corporation hire Mr. McCrory as a consultant, and had also negotiated Mr. McCrory’s fee. “I got us $12,000 per month,” Mr. Epps told Mr. McCrory, according to the indictment. Prosecutors say the two men split the money after calculating how much tax Mr. McCrory would have to pay on the fee. Mr. Epps eventually signed a number of contracts with the management corporation to provide various prison services, including a no-bid contract in October 2012 — just weeks after Mr. McCrory paid another $14,000 on Mr. Epps’s condominium, the indictment said.

Mr. McCrory’s initial payment to Mr. Epps, according to prosecutors, was in 2007, after Mr. Epps had awarded a no-bid contract to G. T. Enterprises, a firm owned by Mr. McCrory, to supply commissary services to the prison system. Mr. McCrory went on to pay Mr. Epps $3,000 to $4,000 15 different times, and Mr. McCrory later sold the commissary business at a substantial profit, prosecutors said.
State contracts: Where should Miss. look for reform?
Past legislation aimed at reform — which was killed — is being revived and has a much better chance at passage. The state also can look to others that have reformed no-bid spending and contracting, which can be a breeding ground for corruption and overspending. "There are some opportunities here for changes in the way the state does business," said former Attorney General Mike Moore, a member of the task force. He and others on the task force said they will look for "best practices" in other states.

One of those might be in Washington state. State law there requires agencies requesting a sole-source contract to make that request public for at least 10 days prior to the contract start date. The Washington Department of Enterprise Services publishes the proposed no-bid contracts on a website. Washington, D.C., has a similar 10-day public posting of intent to award a no-bid contract.

In Iowa, such requests for sole-source contracts also are made public, and the agency must fill out a lengthy questionnaire explaining why a particular vendor is the only one who can provide a good or service and detailing what research went into this finding. The request is posted for at least five business days on Iowa's bid opportunities website, which would allow other vendors to see the request and potentially make bids.

In Pennsylvania, Gov.-elect Tom Wolf made enacting a ban on no-bid contracts with private law firms part of his campaign platform. He vows to issue an executive order banning what he called "crony contracts" with law firms, placing a cap on fees paid to lawyers and making the process transparent online.
Website not designed to track no-bid contracts
The scope and scale of the state's multibillion-dollar business with preferred vendors remains shrouded in darkness despite a 2008 law demanding transparency in government spending.

Mississippi agencies awarded nearly $6.5 billion in no-bid contracts to at least 1,807 individuals and businesses in the past four years alone, according to a Clarion-Ledger investigation. But the public would never know this by viewing the state Transparency website, which the law requires to house agency contract information.

Built and maintained on a shoestring budget by the state Department of Finance and Administration, the website contains countless contract inaccuracies caused by software glitches and human error, making it nearly impossible to know the true number and value of no-bid contracts. It's also impossible to view a list of just no-bid contracts — accurate or not — because the website doesn't track or store them that way. Neither does the Department of Finance and Administration, which, when asked for a list of such contracts, pulled it directly from the website.

But the biggest problem is that no one anticipated the need to examine no-bid contracts on a statewide scale. "The concept of no-bid is an entirely new concept to me that came out of the Epps scandal," said DFA Executive Director Kevin Upchurch, referring to the recent federal indictment of former state Corrections Commissioner Chris Epps.

It took more than two weeks of exhaustive analysis and fact checking by The Clarion-Ledger and several records revisions by the DFA — which provided assistance in the effort — to produce a viably accurate list of no-bid state contracts. Sortable by vendor, agency, contract date and dollar value, the list shows not only who gets the most cash without having to compete for it but also which agencies ink the most agreements and why. But the list is stagnant. Contracts awarded after its completion won't appear unless someone continues to track them.

It's the basis for a series of questions about the way state government operates, and perhaps chief among them are these:

•Is this the first comprehensive list of no-bid state contracts ever created in Mississippi?

•Has no one in state government tracked this before — not just posted data on a website but really tracked and analyzed it?

•And if not, should someone start, especially in light of the Department of Corrections scandal?


Saturday, December 14, 2013

Ethical conflicts: disclose or shun?

In the commercial world it is often sufficient, in cases of conflicts of interests, between, say a board member and a corporation, that a board member disclose conflicts and recuse from voting, maybe even "the deliberation process". This simple disclosure requirement is sometimes found in public procurement. But since public procurement involves the expenditure of state funds, i.e., your money, disclosure is more often than not insufficient to cure the taint of conflict.

Guam law procurement ethics, for example, following the ABA Model Procurement Code, requires that "any [government] employee who has, or obtains any benefit from, any territorial contract with a
business in which the employee has a financial interest shall report such benefit", but the bar is higher in the case of conflicts: "it shall be a breach of ethical standards for any employee to participate directly or indirectly in a procurement when the employee knows" of the usual conflicts.

Furthermore, "notwithstanding any other provision of law, any member of any elected or appointed board or commission shall be prohibited from acting or participating in discussion on any matter in which he is a principal, has a financial interest in, or acts as an agent for anyone other than the government of Guam. Interests held in blind trust shall not be exempt from this provision. The member shall be prohibited from influencing any determination made by the board or commission on which the member serves and in which the member either participates personally and substantially through decision, approval, disapproval, recommendation, the rendering of advice, investigation or otherwise, or which is the subject of the member’s official responsibility, where the government of Guam is a party or has a direct and substantial interest."

The judicious expenditure of government taxpayer money is a significant feature of good public governance. Any appearance of impropriety begins to tear at the public confidence in its government. Public procurement professionals are the sentinels who protect the government of the people by insisting on avoidance of all such appearances. It rots at the core otherwise.

Conflicts of interest is just one of the issues in the following reported case involving the New York Power Authority:

Report finds ethical misconduct at NYPA under Richard Kessel
A state investigation of New York Power Authority practices under then-chief Richard Kessel found "ethical misconduct, procurement irregularities and financial mismanagement" in 2009 and 2010, according to a newly released report. The probe, which took nearly three years, was initiated in February 2011 by former Inspector General Ellen Biben. [Which is why real time policing by protests and public disclosre requirement is so crucial to the integrity of the procurement process.]

For example, Kessel, had "apparent conflicts of interest that he failed to reveal" in recommending that NYPA consider a law firm for a "substantial contract for legal services," the probe found. It said Kessel failed to disclose "his own ongoing personal legal relationship with the same firm," according to the state Inspector General's office.

The probe also uncovered a $15,000 loan in 2009 that Kessel solicited and accepted from a subordinate, "which neither individual reported as required in their annual financial disclosure statements," the IG found. The IG's report said Kessel told DeJesu he was having financial difficulties in November 2009 and "he couldn't come to anyone else." DeJesu, who reported to Kessel at NYPA, provided the loan interest-free, according to the report. By requesting and accepting the loan, the report says, "Kessel created an appearance or situation where [he] could be either improperly influenced [or] give or be given preferential treatment."

Under Kessel's tenure, the probe also found that charitable contributions and business-related contributions increased at NYPA, both statewide and "specifically related to the Long Island area where Kessel lived." The report said NYPA's charitable donations to groups on Long Island, where NYPA has a "limited presence," increased 50 percent under Kessel. The IG's office noted that while the contributions increased under Kessel, investigators did not find "any undue influence with regard to the contributions made to Long Island organizations. NYPA had a deficient policy which lacked provisions for identifying, monitoring, and justifying these purported business-related contributions," the report found.

The Inspector General's office recommended NYPA enact a series of new controls, among them:

• A management audit of its procurement policies, practices, procedures, and organizational structure;

• More exacting procurement standards and full documentation and record retention;

• Disclosure of "actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest" when issuing and reviewing procurement requests for proposals and train officials and employees on disclosure requirements;

• Training regarding the prohibition of seeking a loan from a subordinate and loaning money to a superior;

• A policy prohibiting active board members from seeking NYPA employment;

• A policy for business-related contributions, which includes documentation and justification of each expenditure, as well as disclosure of any ties between a NYPA employee and the funding recipient; and

• Monthly reports delineating contributions, sponsorships and business-related contributions for presentation to the NYPA board.
This is a good example, assuming all is as reported and there are no unreported mitigating factors, of slow rot. 

Not outrageous corruption and theft, but the kind of undermining whimsy that comes from treating public funds as the booty of office or pleasure of the director.   

It does not show any criminal act, but does show an arrogant disregard of the trust we place in our governing officers.  Punishment should follow, but be proportionate to the legal harm done.  In some cases, and with some people, the exposure and shame may be sufficient, if they "get it".


POST SCRIPT January 26, 2014

On a similar topic, whether to disclose or shun political "gifts", is this comment in a WaPo article today:

Virginia was ripe for a scandal
The indictment, against former Virginia governor Bob McDonnell and his wife, Maureen, stems from an investigation of gifts the McDonnells received from businessman Jonnie Williams. In return for these gifts, it is charged, the governor did official favors for Williams’s diet supplement company.

Some might say that Virginia was ripe for such a scandal. After all, until newly-elected Gov. Terry McCauliffe changed it (for only one year, by the way), the law allowed public officials to accept unlimited gifts as long as they were reported. Tim Kaine, for example, reported gifts in excess of $300,000 while governor. For that matter, so did McDonnell (although the gifts cited in the indictment were not reported). This kind of lax ethics would seem an invitation to corruption and is one reason the Center for Public Integrity ranked Virginia 47th out of 50 in “state integrity” and gave it an “F” in combating corruption risk.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Its the little things that give the appearance of impropriety

Bits and pieces from a couple of cautionary tales from the Public Spend Forum.

A Reminder of Why Those Pesky Bureaucratic Rules Matter in Procurement
While the national media has had endless stories over the past two months with the problems enveloping the Obama Administration with the botched launch of the HealthCare.Gov website, at the state level, there have also been massive expenditures and serious technical issues in the fifteen states that opted to develop their own health insurance coverage websites under the Affordable Care Act. Idaho is one of these states, and the state legislature there set up a Health Insurance Exchange Board. Frank Chan was one of 19 appointees to this board, which included representatives of insurance companies, medical service providers, legislators, small businesses and consumers. The board had a tight timeline to build-out Idaho’s state-run health insurance exchange, as its members were appointed on April 10th of this year by Idaho Governor C.L. “Butch” Otter, and the body had to have the state marketplace up and running by January 1, 2014 to comply with the provisions of Obamacare.

In Idaho, the state procurement regulations require almost all contracts over $25,000 to be subjected to a competitive bidding process. However, with the tight timeline to get the exchange up and running to meet the federal mandate, the state legislature exempted the Idaho Health Insurance Exchange Board from the state’s acquisition rules, authorizing the exchange to establish its own procurement guidelines. And for the major contract to be issued by the board to accomplish that task—setting up the website for the exchange—Your Health Idaho Executive Director Amy Dowd awarded Robert Chan’s company a $375,000 contract—without the opportunity being put out for competition—to help the state develop and operate the exchange’s website. Chan stepped down from the board later that same day. The awarding of the no-bid contract immediately brought a firestorm of publicity for the board and its executive director.

And how did the two main characters in this story react to the findings of the investigation. Remarkably, in the aftermath of the controversy, Your Health Idaho Executive Director Amy Dowd characterized her decision to award the no-bid contract to Chan as a “misstep,” saying that: “I think we were given an incredibly tight timeframe and limited resources. I think the board has done a remarkable job. We made a misstep on this. We’re going to face up to it and use it as a way to learn and grow as an organization so we can succeed with the mandate we were given by the governor and the legislature.” And as the other the central figure in the case, Frank Chan commented that: “I believe the intent for me to be able to help out Your Health Idaho was that I do have the experience and my company has the experience to really provide the help that they need right now. It’s unfortunate that given what actually happened and transpired, it went sideways.”

What are we to make of the “missteps” in Idaho and the thing going “sideways”? For all involved in the affair, while the decisions made did not break any laws, the executive director’s choice to award the no-bid contract to a board member did cost the parties a great deal in credibility and opportunity. For Chan, he and his company may have been able to do a great job for the state and its residents, but now, we will never know. For the Health Insurance Exchange Board, they have lost valuable time and credibility through this incident for the state’s health insurance effort. Coming on the heels of the national issues with Obamacare and the HealthCare.gov website, this only creates more uncertainty within the state concerning the health care exchange.

Overall though, the problems with Your Health Idaho illustrate the importance of having some level of oversight and control in making acquisition decisions and serve as a positive reminder of why a degree of bureaucratic control is so critical in the public sector. While we involved in government may indeed tire of “jumping through hoops,” the events in Idaho makes a good case for all public sector entities to make certain that they have hoops in place. The delicate balancing act is in figuring out just what is the right amount and kind of hoops to have in effect. The other thing is that all of those affiliated with an agency should have to play by and be subject to the same rules, from the front lines to executives and board members. And so while the Idaho legislature wanted to remove the hoops to fast-track the development of the state’s exchange, others—like Chan and Dowd—saw it as an opportunity to take advantage of (however bad their decisions look in retrospect).
Magic Bullet: How a Small Gift Shot Down a Huge Contract
How would you feel if what you did was headlined on the local paper? And what was the headline splashed across the front page of the Albuquerque Journal? Well, it involved skeet shooting…

Antonio Sedillo is a construction supervisor with the Los Lunas Schools, and as a hobby, he is a skeet shooter who recently participated in a skeet shooting competition in Albuquerque. The problem arose when another skeet shooter, who was employed by a local construction firm, saw that Sedillo was actually shooting in the event as part of a team from McCarthy Building Companies. Sedillo’s $125 entry fee for the competition had been paid for by McCarthy Building, which had recently been awarded a $24 million construction contract by the school district for the new Los Lunas High School. And who was on the school district committee that evaluated the bids from McCarthy Building and four other competitors? You guessed it—Mr. Sedillo! And who did the curious fellow shooter who reported Sedillo being on McCarthy’s team? As you probably guessed, he was employed by one of the losing firms!

So now, if you are school Superintendent Bernard Saiz, you have a real predicament on your hands. Your employee, who was on the committee to decide the contractor on the district’s largest construction project to date, accepted the “gift” from the firm that won the competition. To make matters worse, it should be noted that the skeet shooting competition actually occurred in the interim between the time the four firms made their proposals and when the award was actually made.

In public comments on the situation, Superintendent Saiz characterized Sedillo as a good employee, but his decision to accept the entry fee was a “clear violation” of the district’s procurement rules. Saiz commented that: “He (Sedillo) is an avid shooter, and I think he just let his desires get ahold of him here.” Saiz has announced that the contract will have to rebid, and that McCarthy will indeed be allowed to compete. However, he has also expressed his belief that in this situation, “I think McCarthy and my employee could have used better judgment.”

So, what have we learned here? The “lesson learned,” and one that should be make this a “teachable moment” for all involved in acquisition at any level of government, is that appearances do matter—greatly! No matter the amount, no matter the circumstances, no matter the timing, those involved in procurement decision-making have to strive to avoid the appearance of impropriety. Antonio Sedillo’s decision to accept that $125 entry fee cost the school district and the competing construction firms probably 1000 times as much in terms of rebidding of the project. Additionally, it cost the district a great deal in credibility—both with the public at large and with the business community.

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

2 stories

Two stories from today's press via Google News. This first story poses a question.

Official: Rotate contracting officers between government, private sector
Joseph Jordan, the White House’s top contracting policy chief, floated the idea Tuesday of having contracting professionals rotate between government and the private sector. “There are all sorts of issues, I know,” said Jordan, who is the administrator for the Office of Federal Procurement Policy. “But I refuse to say this is off the table.”

The Obama administration has placed tight rules clamping down on the so-called revolving door between government and special interests among political appointees, though Jordan’s remarks were aimed an audience of career workforce professionals.

“Is there a way where we can have people kind of bounce back and forth ... between industry and agencies?” Jordan said in remarks here at the National Contract Management Association conference.
Does this second story hint at a reason this might not be such a great idea?

Former government contracting official sentenced to prison
A former government contracting official, Robert Edwin Steele, 38, of Alexandria, was sentenced Friday to 48 months in prison for 14 counts of unauthorized access to a protected computer. In addition to his 48-month term of imprisonment, Judge Lee also ordered Steele to serve two years of supervised release, imposed a fine of $50,000, and required restitution $335,977.68.

When Steele left Company A on December 15, 2010, he gave verbal and written assurances to officials of Company A that he would not access its systems after his departure, and even urged them to shut down his existing accounts. That same day, however, Steele began logging into Company A’s e-mail systems using a secret administrative account which he learned about during his work for Company A. Steele immediately began downloading hundreds of proprietary documents using this administrative account.

Shortly after resigning, Steele joined another government contractor, Company C, that directly competed with Companies A and B for government contracts. At Company C, Steele worked as “Director of Law Enforcement” and prepared bids for government contracts on law enforcement projects. In that position, Steele undercut Company A’s bid on a government contract by approximately $100,000, while downloading Company A’s documents on the same contract. Although his attempt to win the bid failed, Steele continued to methodically sift through thousands of valuable documents stored on computers for Company A.
Of course, you need to read both stories in full for context, but why would you need to hack for information if you can just bounce back and forth and gather as you go?

Monday, August 20, 2012

Procurement ethics for private contractors?

Government should adopt standards for private contractors
The federal government issues more than $260 billion in government contracts each year, with few restrictions on the employees of those contractors.

Government ethics expert Kathleen Clark, JD, professor of law at Washington University in St. Louis, has written extensively about this issue in the last year with three papers: “Ethics, Employees and Contractors: Financial Conflicts In and Out of Government”; “Fiduciary Standards for Bailout Contractors: What Treasury Got Right and Wrong in TARP”; and “Ethics for an Outsourced Government”.

The federal government hasn’t yet outsourced the job of Cabinet secretary, but almost all tasks that government employees perform are also performed by contractor personnel. Contractors perform jobs that are mundane or menial, such as hauling trash, but also tasks that are sophisticated and require discretion, such as providing advice about how to respond to climate change.

Over the course of 25 years, the federal government increased its spending on service contracting by 85 percent in inflation-adjusted dollars. While the government has increased its spending on service contracting, it has actually decreased the number of government employees who supervise that contract spending.

So much so that now the government actually outsources to contractors the function of supervising and evaluating the work of other contractors. That is of the areas where the government is at highest risk for ethical misconduct by contractors: where contractors can influence how the government spends money but are not subject to rigorous government ethics standards. Last year, the government adopted a new regulation to impose some ethics standards on some of these individuals, but it is not yet clear how the government and contractors are implementing that regulation.

Back in 2008, the Department of the Treasury used a contractor as the point person for its bailout of AIG. That contractor was a former employee of Goldman Sachs and owned a substantial amount of Goldman stock. He advised the government to handle the AIG bailout in a way that benefited Goldman Sachs — and himself, as a Goldman shareholder. If he had been a government employee, he could have gone to prison for this conflict of interest. But as a contractor, the conflict of interest law didn’t apply to him.

The ABA Model Procurement Code, substantially adopted on Guam, contains a code of ethics for private as well as public procurement participants. Unfortunately, the enforcement mechanism for each of them is rather ineffective, as implemented on Guam.

Sunday, March 11, 2012

Outsourcing procurement mismanagement

Leighton Abu Dhabi scandal revealed
Leighton signed a $1.4 billion joint venture with Abu Dhabi-based Tourism Development & Investment Company in December 2007 to undertake contracting for various projects commissioned by TDIC, the tourism asset development arm of the Abu Dhabi Tourism Authority.

Eighteen months later, the joint venture company was abandoned and both companies blamed the decision on the global financial crisis. Neither company mentioned a scandal that had resulted in an internal investigation being carried out after TDIC received a series of documents that alleged fraudulent activity by a Leighton manager, who for the purposes of this article is called NX.

The revelations raised in the report come as Leighton admitted last month it had alerted the AFP to a possible breach of anti-bribery laws relating to its Singapore-based subsidiary Leighton Offshore Pvt and payments made to facilitate a wharf construction project in Iraq in 2010.

The Iraq payments are not the only potential corruption case facing the construction giant. Documents from a New South Wales Supreme Court case last year reveal Leighton conducted an internal inquiry into ''apparently corrupt conduct'' involving allegations that a senior employee channelled half a million dollars' worth of steel to a third-party project at the Bantam Shipyard in Indonesia.

It can now be revealed that another internal investigation, code-named project rabbit, was headed by Deloitte Corporate Finance. Deloitte completed an internal report on June 22, 2009, days after the TDIC/Leighton joint venture collapsed. The Deloitte report listed ''mental impressions, analyses and opinions solely to assist Al Habtoor Leighton Group in providing a summary of findings as part of its work in connection with an internal investigation into commercial procurement practices and to brief the TDIC''.

The report said: ''As of the date of this report there has been no evidence to substantiate any fraudulent activities alleged to have been conducted by [NX], however there are still concerns regarding his employment of procurement practices that are not in line with AHLG procedures. Further, the investigative team is not able to confirm the source of or the use for the AED [Arab Emirates dollars] 350,000 that was noted in his personal bank statements.''

Leighton said yesterday: ''It is difficult to confirm the detail. This is a matter that occurred in 2008-09 and current management have no knowledge of this matter. We appreciate these matters being raised with us are serious and undertake to look into them further as we take our values very seriously.'' None of the investigations into Leighton suggest it has done anything wrong, but it is a reminder to companies doing business in countries that have a culture of bribery and graft that they need to ensure their affairs are squeaky clean.

Read more