Labels and Tags

Accountability (71) Adequate documentation (7) ADR in procurement (4) Allocation of risks (6) Best interest of government (11) Best practices (19) Best value (15) Bidder prejudice (11) Blanket purchase agreement (1) Bridge contract (2) Bundling (6) Cancellation and rejection (2) Centralized procurement structure (12) Changes during bid process (14) Clarifications vs Discussions (1) Competence (9) Competition vs Efficiency (29) Competitive position (3) Compliance (35) Conflict of interest (32) Contract administration (26) Contract disputes (4) Contract extension or modification (9) Contract formation (1) Contract interpretation (1) Contract terms (3) Contract types (6) Contract vs solicitation dispute (2) Contractor responsibility (20) Conviction (4) Cooperative purchasing (3) Corrective action (1) Cost and pricing (13) Debarment (4) Determinations (8) Determining responsibility (37) Disclosure requirements (7) Discussions during solicitation (10) Disposal of surplus property (3) Effective enforcement requirement (35) Effective procurement management (5) Effective specifications (36) Emergency procurement (14) eProcurement (5) Equitable tolling (2) Evaluation of submissions (22) Fair and equitable treatment (14) Fair and reasonable value (23) Fiscal effect of procurement (14) Frivolous protest (1) Good governance (12) Governmental functions (27) Guam (14) Guam procurement law (12) Improper influence (11) Incumbency (13) Integrity of system (31) Interested party (7) Jurisdiction (1) Justification (1) Life-cycle cost (1) Limits of government contracting (5) Lore vs Law (4) market research (7) Materiality (3) Methods of source selection (33) Mistakes (4) Models of Procurement (1) Needs assessment (11) No harm no foul? (8) Offer & acceptance (1) Other procurement links (14) Outsourcing (34) Past performance (12) Planning policy (34) Politics of procurement (52) PPPs (6) Prequalification (1) Principle of competition (95) Principles of procurement (25) Private vs public contract (17) Procurement authority (5) Procurement controversies series (79) Procurement ethics (19) Procurement fraud (31) Procurement lifecycle (9) Procurement philosophy (17) Procurement procedures (30) Procurement reform (63) Procurement theory (11) Procurement workforce (2) Procurment philosophy (6) Professionalism (17) Protest - formality (2) Protest - timing (12) Protests - general (37) Purposes and policies of procurement (11) Recusal (1) Remedies (17) Requirement for new procurement (4) Resolution of protests (4) Responsiveness (14) Restrictive specifications (5) Review procedures (13) RFQ vs RFP (1) Scope of contract (16) Settlement (2) Social preference provisions (60) Sole source (48) Sovereign immunity (3) Staffing (8) Standard commercial products (3) Standards of review (2) Standing (6) Stays and injunctions (6) Structure of procurement (1) Substantiation (9) Surety (1) Suspension (6) The procurement record (1) The role of price (10) The subject matter of procurement (23) Trade agreements vs procurement (1) Training (33) Transparency (63) Uniformity (6) Unsolicited proposals (3)
Showing posts with label Effective enforcement requirement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Effective enforcement requirement. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 27, 2018

Is Section 809 Panel playing for change that we don't need?

This is the second of two articles addressing the perennial changes that accompany all procurement regimes.  The first is the immediately prior post. The same rules and caveats about reading the original article apply here.


When it comes to bid protests, Section 809 panel should follow data
The Section 809 Panel, whose members were appointed by DoD and represent experts across the government contracting field, derives its name from the section in the 2016 National Defense Authorization (NDAA) that created the panel. Among the panel’s mandates is to streamline the acquisition process while protecting “the best interests of the Department of Defense.”

It is no secret that the Section 809 Panel also is looking at the bid protest system as part of its mandate. And it is also no secret that DoD takes a dim view of the current bid protest system. It is not a stretch to believe that, in DoD’s view, significant changes to protests would be in its “best interest.” That would be a mistake.

Bid protests provide a meaningful “check and balance” to help ensure the government consistently acts both in its best interests and in accordance with applicable procurement regulations. This is important to maintain the perception (and reality) that the federal contracting marketplace is characterized by open, robust competition. Without some third-party mechanism to review whether procurements are conducted reasonably and in accordance with federal procurement law, nontraditional federal contractors or established government contractors without established track records at particular agencies could come to view the federal marketplace as a de facto oligarchy of a few companies favored by specific agencies.

The promise of contractor-financed government oversight via the protest process gives companies comfort (especially when utilizing enormous and scarce resources) that their bids will be evaluated fairly and in accordance with the guidelines set forth by the agency in the solicitation. Without such a system, companies the government relies on will turn their backs on this marketplace to everyone’s detriment.

Those looking to change the system argue that protests are prolific, disruptive, and unnecessarily slow procurements. These arguments, however, have largely been debunked with the recent release of the most comprehensive study of the protest system in a generation by the RAND Corporation (through its National Defense Research Institute).

Among other things, the RAND Report found that protests are not at all prevalent when viewed against the backdrop of overall DoD procurement activity. The report found just 0.3 percent of DoD contract actions were protested, and most GAO protests are resolved in just over a month–hardly indicative of a system that causes governmentwide disruption. To make these conclusions, RAND studied 21,186 contract actions at GAO (average of 2,354 per year) and 475 cases filed at the Court of Federal Claims (average of 53 per year).

With respect to GAO, the data set (which runs from fiscal 2008 through fiscal 2016) showed that, while protests had increased, the effectiveness rate of protests (which is approximately 45 percent) remained steady throughout that time leading RAND to conclude that protesters were largely filing protests that had merit. The RAND study also found that 50 percent of protest actions at GAO are resolved within 30 days, and fully 70 percent of cases are resolved within 60 days.

Based on this data, RAND cautioned policy makers from tinkering substantively with GAO’s and COFC’s current bid protest jurisdiction, timelines and procedures.

RAND recommended against shortening GAO’s process to under the current 100 days, based on the data showing the vast majority of cases are resolved much sooner and that GAO reasonably needs additional time for more complex cases. RAND also recommended against reducing GAO’s task order jurisdiction, noting that those protests are more successful, on average, than non-task order protests.

The RAND report did make some recommendations for reform, which were closely aligned with the evidence it painstakingly collected and analyzed. For one, nearly 10 percent of protests at GAO are for procurements valued under $100,000. A streamlined protest process would benefit the quick adjudication of these protests (such, as RAND noted, a small claims-type procedure or mandatory ADR at GAO).

Second, RAND found that small businesses file more than 50 percent of protests though they account for 15-to-20 percent of contract dollars. While this may be because the average contract awarded to small businesses is smaller than large businesses, small businesses may benefit to a dedicated enhanced debriefing process and outside counsel or help from the SBA because protests where outside counsel is present and the underlying source selection record is reviewed lead to better outcomes for protesters with a higher success rate. Counsel are also bound by their ethical obligations to only file non-frivolous pleadings.

The current bid protest system plays an irreplaceable role in enhancing confidence in the integrity of federal procurement, which fosters a more robust marketplace with more participants offering greater innovation to federal agencies. The data in the RAND report shows that current jurisdiction and timelines result in effective, non-frivolous use of the bid protest mechanism by disappointed offerors without undue disruption or delay. While larger procurements are more susceptible to protest, these big dollar procurements are exactly what tax payers and policy makers should want to be the focus of the bid protest system.

Like with everything else, the Section 809 Panel’s recommendations with respect to the bid protest system should be based in fact. Thankfully, with the RAND report, the panel has those facts close at hand.
See previous post related to this topic, here.

Wednesday, May 10, 2017

Government gets spanked for hitting a "new record"

There have been (at least) a couple of of good reviews of a recent decision of the Court of Federal Claims in the case Gallup, Inc. v USA.   In that case, the government got caught out making up an entry for the procurement record in the course of a procurement protest; in effect, attempting to create a new record.

Tch tch.

The court was, shall we say, livid:
The Contracting Officer, Ms. Julia A. DeLoach, signed the Memorandum for Record. While the document itself contains no date, the Index identifies June 24, 2016 as the date of creation for the Memorandum of Record. The Market Analysis contains an undated chart which summarizes the USSOCOM evaluation team’s comments on each RFI response. Pursuant to normal Court procedures, the Administrative Record also contains a “Certification of Contracting Office” signed by Ms. DeLoach affirming that “after careful review, the following documents constitute the record of administrative actions . . . .”

The Government notified the Court that on March 23, 2017 the Government learned the Memorandum for Record “had been prepared on or about December 15, 2016, i.e., after the agency had proceeded with the procurement. In order to “uncover the nature of the inaccuracy present in the administrative record and determine whether any action should be taken by this Court”, the Court issued an Order retaining the March 30, 2017 hearing date, and requiring “all those individuals who assisted in the production of the administrative record” to attend the hearing.

At the hearing, the Court questioned Ms. DeLoach while she was under oath. She further testified that she personally compiled the Administrative Record in this case without any assistance, including choosing the June 24, 2016 date for the Memorandum for Record in the Index, and signed the Certification of Contracting Office. Ms. DeLoach confirmed that the chart accompanying the Memorandum for Record was created on June 24, 2016 and that it accurately represents the contemporaneous comments of the USSOCOM evaluation team. When presented with the Memorandum for Record and asked to explain why she created the document, Ms. DeLoach responded:
[W]hen I received the pre-filing notice about December 13th, I said, uh-oh, if [Gallup] really file[s], I need to make sure my record [is] in good shape. […] I realized I had the [chart] with nothing that consolidated that or nothing that summarized that and I prepared the [Memorandum for Record] at that time, sir. I now know that [] was a huge mistake and I am deeply sorry that this has come to this. . . . [T]he timing was wrong.
Ms. DeLoach confirmed that the GRAP acquisition was already “underway” when she created the Memorandum for Record.

On March 30, 2017, immediately following the hearing, the Court issued an Order to Show Cause stating that “the Court contemplates the imposition of sanctions against the government and ordered the Government to explain why the Court should not require USSOCOM to pay Gallup’s attorney’s fees and costs associated with the prosecution of this bid protest. Knowingly providing inaccurate information to the Court is certainly grounds for sanctions.

A recent bid protest before this Court, Coastal Environmental Group Inc. v. United States, presents nearly identical facts to those here and further supports the imposition of sanctions in this case. An EPA official included a backdated document in the administrative record in order to “make it appear to anyone who read the document that she prepared and signed the document ten months earlier than she actually did.” The official then “attempted to cure her oversight by preparing . . . a Determination and Findings document.” Accordingly, Judge Margaret Sweeney of this Court imposed sanctions.

In this case, Ms. DeLoach also realized her record was incomplete and attempted to “cure her oversight” by preparing a Memorandum for Record nearly six months after USSOCOM made its set-aside decision.

The Court held a telephonic status conference at the request of the parties during which counsel for the Government indicated (and confirmed in writing the same day) that the parties had “reached an agreement in principle for USSOCOM to pay Gallup’s attorney fees and litigation costs . . . as contemplated by the Court’s order.” In addition, the Government noted that USSOCOM will:
issue guidance to its contracting staff emphasizing the importance of completeness, accuracy, and integrity in preparing records and accompanying certifications [and] is in the process of planning a training session . . . that will focus on issues of accuracy and ethics in preparing and certifying administrative records.
Therefore, the Government does not dispute the appropriateness of sanctions in this case.

The integrity of the administrative record, upon which nearly every bid protest is resolved, is foundational to a fair and equitable procurement process. While the Government has accepted responsibility for its misconduct, the importance of preventing a corrupted record cannot be overstated. The Court encourages USSOCOM to take all reasonable steps to ensure that its contracting office appreciates the necessity of conducting a well-documented, well-reasoned procurement and producing a meticulous and accurate record for review.

The Court will not tolerate agency deception in the creation of the administrative record.
The two reviews mentioned above are:
Government “Misconduct” in Preparing the Administrative Record Warrants Sanctions, and
Fed. Claims Warns SOCOM Over $45M Contract 'Misconduct'
It might be noted that Guam procurement law, consistent with the ABA Model Procurement Code, requires that "No procurement award shall be made unless the responsible procurement officer certifies in writing under penalty of perjury that he has maintained the record required by § 5249 of this Chapter and that it is complete and available for public inspection. The certificate is itself a part of the record." (5 GCA § 5250)

Monday, August 29, 2016

Transparency? You can't handle the transparency!

 NOTE: As usual, I have have changed the articles reported below, leaving material out, rearranging, and paraphrasing, to suit the purposes of this blawg. The obvious purpose here is the need to have adequate and effective transparency regimes in order to have and maintain good governance, in procurement as well as other aspects of government. You must read the full articles at the links to get the accurate version of the story.

Americans pay millions to whistleblower at BHP; we hound them out of their jobs
In Australia, those who flag corruption inside companies receive limited or no protection and are often sacked or mistreated, while in the United States, which paid for evidence that exposed alleged bribery by BHP Billiton, whistleblowers are encouraged to come forward. The calls for reform are being made as Fairfax Media can reveal new details of another whistleblower case that suggests serious ethical failings by a top Australian businesswoman and ABC board member, Kirstin Ferguson.

A Fair Work Commission complaint filed by the whistleblower alleges he was "victimised as a result of the disclosures" he made to Dr Ferguson about alleged corruption at mining services giant Thiess. Dr Ferguson is a director at Thiess' parent company, Leighton Holdings (now named CIMIC), and is responsible for company ethics as ethics committee chairwoman. Dr Ferguson declined to comment on detailed questions sent to her by Fairfax Media.

Key MPs Nick Xenophon, Jacqui Lambie and Andrew Wilkie, as well as the Greens and shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus have all said they will push in Parliament for stronger whistleblower laws to encourage reporting of corporate corruption.

In May, the US corporate watchdog, the Securities and Exchange Commission, revealed it would pay a bounty "to a company employee whose tip bolstered an ongoing investigation with additional evidence of wrongdoing". Legal sources have confirmed that the whistleblower was a BHP Billiton insider, paid US$3.75 million (about $4.96 million). The former employee provided detailed information to US investigators about the mining firm's activities overseas several years ago. The allegations remain the subject of an active Australian Federal Police bribery investigation.

It is the first time an employee of an Australian company has received a US whistleblower bounty. Under the US Sarbanes-Oxley Act, the SEC can reward whistleblowers by giving them a cut of a fine extracted from a company, with payouts often reaching many millions of dollars.

In May 2015, BHP Billiton agreed to pay $US25 million to the SEC to settle an inquiry into trips to the Beijing Olympics that the company gave to government officials. The officials represented countries where the miner was operating, and where it was sometimes seeking government permits. BHP Billiton said in a statement that, during that inquiry, the SEC had made no findings of bribery or corrupt intent against the company, and that the US Department of Justice had investigated but took no action. The company said it was not aware of the involvement of any whistleblower as part of either investigation. "We respect and fully support protections for all whistleblowers, and the importance of providing confidential avenues for reporting," the statement said.

Senator Lambie, who has taken up the cause of a Defence Department whistleblower, said she wanted "world's best practice" whistleblower laws which would "strengthen our democracy, prevent and uncover official corruption, decrease government waste, save lives, money and prevent damage to our environment".

Shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus said private sector employees should enjoy the same whistleblower protection as people in the public sector because their information is "just as valuable to our community, and they should not be treated differently under the law".

"Recently a string of brave private sector whistleblowers have come forward with valuable information, including those who have exposed wrongdoing in our banking sector. They deserve our protection," Mr Dreyfus said.

Mr Day says there was merit in compensating whistleblowers, although he cautioned against aspects of the US scheme. Senator Nick Xenophon has told Fairfax Media that "whistleblowers in the US get rewarded and protected, but here they get punished and ruined". Andrew Wilkie, who was recently elected as an independent MP in Tasmania, said Australia had a cultural problem in which whistleblowers were scorned as untrustworthy dobbers, or unhinged: "In the US whistleblowers are celebrated, but in Australia they're often vilified," he said.

"Greater whistleblower protection is one of the building blocks of a healthy democracy and ... of a healthy corporate culture."

ASIC executive Warren Day believes new whistleblowing laws could provide far greater clarity and protection for employees who wanted to report a range of misconduct, spanning financial crime and environmental or health and safety breaches although he cautioned against aspects of the US scheme. Minister for Financial Services Kelly O'Dwyer said the government was looking at strengthening Australia's corporate whistleblower regime. Minister O'Dwyer said that, as it looked to strengthen legislation, the government would "follow usual process, and will consult publicly".
The 'naively noble' man who could not get his voice heard
The words, coming from the chairwoman of the board's ethics committee, were intended to be reassuring: "I'm really glad to have you in that role. I really am," she said. Dr Kirstin Ferguson was speaking to "David" (not his real name) who for more than two years had been working to stamp out alleged corruption and misconduct within his company. David was suffering stress and anxiety because he feared - with good reason - that his boss was cutting him loose.

David's faith in his company was first shaken in November 2011. As one of Thiess' more senior figures, David came across a document, signed by his boss Bruce Munro more than three years earlier, as part of the company's 2008 tender for a $5.5 billion mining concession in India.

It quickly became clear that the deal might have had at its heart a corrupt arrangement. Documents and key emails suggested that Thiess' business partner in India would be paying $12 million to powerful Indian government officials - an apparently illegal payment under Australian law.

But two weeks after speaking to her, Ferguson's reassurances meant nothing. David was given three months' notice and told to go immediately on "garden leave".

The company was Thiess, part of Leighton group, which has been implicated in among the most serious foreign bribery and corruption cases in recent Australian history. David's boss was then Thiess managing director Bruce Munro, who later left the company under a cloud.

As for the ethics committee chairwoman, Dr Ferguson: she is still there, and still in the top integrity role at the firm, since renamed CIMIC. She has since scored one of the most high-profile jobs in Australia - she was appointed by the Coalition government as a director of the ABC board, where she is a member of its audit and risk committee, the body in charge of overseeing ethical behaviour.

David declined to speak to Fairfax Media, but his full story can now be told for the first time through documents held by Thiess and CIMIC, and leaked by a source close to both firms.

In the United States, someone who came forward with information about corporate malfeasance might be paid millions of dollars. In Australia, speaking out is a shortcut to dismissal, despair and unemployment. And so far in this country, whistleblowers cannot even console themselves that the bad guys will be held to account for the deeds exposed, given the difficulty often facing police or the corporate regulator in investigating, prosecuting and punishing large companies.

Inside Leighton, some were concerned the company might have a deep ethical problem. So a new confidential internal review, Project Mango, was ordered into whether Leighton might be exposed to corruption issues elsewhere. It turned up about 100 payments made by Thiess employees in Indonesia to the country's government, military and policing officials. Not everyone appreciated the revelation.

David's boss was then Thiess managing director Bruce Munro, who later left the company under a cloud. Munro was concerned that risk and compliance activities were cramping the style of those whose job it was to win contracts in difficult markets.

"I want you to ... have a look and tell them [senior management] that there is nothing to see here ... We are tying people up in paperwork. Our processes have gone too far".

In court documents linked to the whistleblower's case, it's alleged that Munro explained to the whistleblower that the sticklers for good process inside the firm would have "never let me sign it [a deal with the Indian partner]". Alarmed at what he had seen, David escalated the emails and Leighton senior management ordered an external investigation. It was codenamed "Project Orange."

When the Project Orange investigation was completed, it suggested Leighton may need to inform the Australian Stock Exchange of a foreign bribery matter. Munro had breached the company's code of ethics and internal policies, the report found. However, there was not yet enough evidence for criminal charges.

n March 2014, as Project Mango was underway, Leighton was taken over by a Spanish group and eventually renamed CIMIC. But if anyone hoped the change of management would lead to a more open culture, those hopes were quickly snuffed. The senior executives who had commissioned Project Mango were sacked and the new bosses wanted it shut down. The story about the payments to Indonesian soldiers was reported, via a leak, in Fairfax Media. But instead of performing a mea culpa, an internal witch hunt for the leakers began.

After that, precisely nothing happened. The market was not informed. Munro kept his job.

In July 2014, Dr Kirstin Ferguson, a former flight lieutenant in the air force, an expert in safety, a lawyer, a PhD in corporate governance and a professional company director, became the head of CIMIC's ethics committee.

Two weeks after her appointment, David rang her. He wanted to meet for coffee. He asked if she knew about what had happened in India, if she was aware of Project Orange. "If I were in your position, I would want to know this," he said of the "biggest ethical issue the company has and would be the biggest ever in Australia."

"I do. I really do," she replied, adding reassuringly: "I'm really glad that we have you in that role."

But a fortnight later, David received a call from the "manager of people" at CIMIC. He was told he "hasn't made it in the restructure". He'd lost his job, and was sent immediately on three months gardening leave.

Two days later, Dr Ferguson sent David a text. To a person humiliated, isolated and sacked for trying to report wrongdoing in front of him, the message rubbed salt into his wounds.

"Hi - just wanted to let you know I have been following up on your call and will be sure to call you when done," Dr Ferguson wrote. It might take another couple of weeks, she said.

David's lawyers later argued his conversation with Ferguson should have been a "protected disclosure" under Australia's flawed whistleblower regime.

Thursday, February 18, 2016

A(nother) contractor gets kicked back

Federal Government Contractor Sentenced To Prison For Accepting Kickbacks And Tax Evasion
An Enterprise, Alabama, resident was sentenced today in the Southern District of Florida to 48 months in prison to be followed by three years of supervised release for accepting unlawful kickbacks and tax evasion, announced Acting Assistant Attorney General Caroline D. Ciraolo of the Justice Department’s Tax Division.

According to court documents and statements made in open court, Victor Villalobos, 47, worked for a federal prime contractor at Fort Rucker, Alabama. In 2009, Villalobos approached Maxim Silinsky, a Florida-based subcontractor for this company, and solicited illegal kickbacks on the federal subcontracts that Silinsky held in connection with the federal prime contractor. Villalobos agreed that in exchange for kickback payments he would refrain from conduct that would unfavorably affect Silinsky’s business relationship with the federal prime contractor and help ensure that he obtained additional business.

As part of his plea, Villalobos admitted that from June 2009 to December 2014, he received approximately 57 separate wire transfers totaling more than $1.9 million in kickback payments from various foreign and domestic bank accounts controlled by Silinsky. At two separate meetings in 2015, Villalobos accepted envelopes from Silinsky containing cash kickbacks totaling $60,000. Between June 2009 and February 2015, Villalobos attempted to conceal his receipt of the kickbacks by forming nominee entities and opening nominee bank accounts. Villalobos also admitted that he evaded paying income taxes on the kickback payments by causing false federal income tax returns to be filed with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).

In addition to his prison sentence, U.S. District Judge Daniel T.K. Hurley ordered Villalobos to pay $542,562 in restitution to the IRS. As part of his plea agreement, Villalobos also agreed to be permanently debarred from federal government contracting.

Silinsky pleaded guilty to filing a false tax return in November 2015 and cooperated in the investigation and prosecution of Villalobos. Silinsky was sentenced to one year and one day in prison on Feb. 2. Silinsky also cooperated in the investigation and prosecution of Trevor Smith, a retired U.S. Air Force Master Sergeant who pleaded guilty in October 2015 to unlawfully disclosing confidential procurement information and filing a false tax return. On Jan. 28, Smith was sentenced to 18 months in prison.

Wednesday, August 6, 2014

Not so straight-laced procurement in Victoria, Australia

We begin this post with the following articles. You can and should read the articles in full at the links associated with their headlines. I tend to selectively cut, paste and rearrange them to suit myself in this blawg, and there is a lot of additional information and context that gets left on the cutting room floor.

Office of Living Victoria broke procurement rules, says Ombudsman
Victoria's recently abolished water agency deliberately flouted procurement rules and back-dated documents to award contracts worth millions to consultants in a manner which implied a "jobs for mates" culture, the Ombudsman has found.

In a major setback for Water Minister Peter Walsh, Ombudsman Deborah Glass has found the agency he created, the Office of Living Victoria, to be rife with undeclared perceived conflicts of interest and having lacked respect for "public sector values and accountability for its use of funds". Mr Walsh told the Ombudsman he was not told of the procurement breaches by Mr Fennessy. But Mr Fennessy told the Ombudsman he last year advised Mr Walsh he needed to audit OLV and that more recently he told the minister ''we've got some procurement problems ... this is why I have been saying for the last six months that I need to audit OLV''.

Mr Waller and Mr Want initially reacted strongly to Ms Glass' draft report, rejecting many of the findings. They commissioned legal advice that stated the OLV was not bound by procurement rules because of its status as an administrative agency. Their advice conflicted with other legal opinion held by the government.

The pair later accepted that the OLV should have paid more attention to ensuring compliance with Victoria's purchasing policies. "I accept OLV made some poor decisions," Mr Waller told the Ombudsman. Mr Walsh said on Tuesday that all government departments had to adhere to procurement rules. He said despite allegations against OLV being raised publicly in recent months it was not appropriate for him to interfere.
Victoria's water agency ignored government policies, the ombudsman says.
The underlying attitude at the Office of Living Victoria (OLV) seemed to put procedures and principles second to urgency, Ombudsman Deborah Glass found. "From the earliest days of OLV, the inclination and focus have been on the end, not the means," the report said.

Ms Glass said the prevailing attitude at the office had been that it needed to "crash through" a bureaucracy that would stymie effective and timely change. "Government procedures exist to protect the public purse," Ms Glass said. "Poorly managed conflicts of interest fundamentally undermine the integrity of public policy."
Ombudsman finds water agency, Office of Living Victoria, mishandled conflict-of-interest concerns
The office was established by Water Minister Peter Walsh in May 2012 to manage the change in the way water services are managed in Victoria.

"Conflict of interest was poorly understood and badly managed by OLV."

The ombudsman was also critical of procurement practices in the agency. In one example examined by the ombudsman, three companies provided quotes for events management services. The ombudsman found OLV accepted the most expensive quote without explaining why.

The report found OLV rushed a number of project briefs, quotations and other documents. "In some cases they were prepared after the contract was in place, to give some semblance of credibility to the arrangement," the ombudsman said.

Mr Walsh acknowledged mistakes were made in the management of the water agency but said the OLV had operated effectively. "Good governance and effective and timely policy reform are not mutually exclusive, but having said that, OLV has delivered some significant benefits."
By the way, you can read the whole "Investigation into allegations of improper conduct in the Office of Living Victoria" here, and an earlier 2014 report on "Investigation into allegations of improper procurement of services by the Department of Education and Early Childhood Development" here.

Well now.

First observation, those last comments of Mr. Walsh in the last article above are routine, de rigueur responses typical of government comment when caught with its pants down in procurement.  I call it the "no harm, no foul" defense, even though there is always obvious harm when good governance is given short shrift whilst the means is meant to justify a result.

Second observation, this smacks of a procurement regime that has no real-time procurement police on the beat. It relies on ex post facto reviews, well after the horses have bolted, with the hope that someone will uncover the stuff-up and fix it (or, as is most often the case, with the hope that it will pass unnoticed at all).

I do not believe that ex post facto discovery is any kind of effective prophylactic or deterrent, and is a blunt instrument when error is found that could be corrected. Rather, what we see too often, as in this case, is that the whole baby is thrown out with the bathwater; here, the whole department was shuttered due to failure of its leadership.

For mine, the most effective way to police procurement is to encourage real-time critique and intervention by the people with most real interest in a fair and equitable system, which is commonly called a "protest" procedure. 

Hell hath no fury like a competitor scorned, and that is exactly the cop on the beat you want, provided you have a fair and expeditious procedure for assessing and resolving the protests. It has to be fair or no one will engage the process, which puts you right back where you started from. It has to be expeditious because the government must quickly and effectively address the issue or get sidelined by the controversy.

On Guam, the law requires that all new elected or appointed officials and department heads undertake and every 4 years re-take a one day course in ethics and or administrative safeguards, which includes an introduction to conflicts of interest and procurement. See 4 GCA §§ 15409 and 15410. At least they can't say they weren't told.

That said, consider the following article: Australian government must take ‘great care’ over public procurement rules
The Australian government needs to take “great care” in the policy, practice and operation of public sector procurement rules to work in the interest of the country’s citizens.

That’s the view of senator Kate Lundy, chairman of the Finance and Public Administration References Committee, which has published its conclusions following an inquiry into the operation and effectiveness of the country's procurement rules. Lundy added: “Government procurement decisions may well be a significant determinant of the social and economic health of many Australian communities and regions. As a result, great care needs to be taken in the policy, practice and operation of the Commonwealth Government procurement rules if they are to operate in the interests of the Australian people.”

Recommendations included calling on the Department of Finance to establish an “independent and effective complaints mechanism” for procurement processes. But the department said that it does not support this because there are a “number of opportunities” for people with complaints and there have been a “very low” number of complaints received.





Monday, June 23, 2014

Plan ahead for protests

Innovators: Aneesh Chopra says open data is key if government wants to solve big problems   (An interview with Aneesh Chopra)
   Aneesh Chopra become the nation’s first chief technology officer under President Obama, a position that oversaw a series of federal initiatives to make government data more accessible to the private sector and general public. That experience serves as the backbone of Chopra’s recently released book, “Innovative State: How New Technologies Can Transform Government.”

The bungled roll out of HealthCare.gov has been well documented. What stands out to you as a key lesson for the government and the private sector to learn from that experience?
The No. 1 lesson is we have to tackle is fixing the procurement system.

If you do a fair and open competition, and you pick something, you know the first thing that’s going to happen is someone’s going to protest. You have to factor that into your time cycle.
Is the first step to reform eliminating procurement protests?
Life is generally about balance. There are obviously circumstances under which protesting is warranted ... but you want to have more skin in the game.  Protesting for no reason as part of a way of doing business isn’t sustainable, nor do I think is it the right thing. There has to be a better way.

In general, lowering the barriers to entry and increasing the capacity of the system to root out mistakes, errors or outright fraud, those have to be the guiding principles. Are there people in the U.S. who could have helped build HealthCare.gov in a more cost effective manner, and with greater agility and responsibility? I’m pretty sure the answer would be yes.

Sunday, December 1, 2013

Ghana crowd sourcing procurement accountability?


Government Award Of Contracts Will Be Scrutinised
A Programme and procurement implementation management information system has been launched to ensure transparency in the award and execution of government contracts. The new accounting software is also to provide a framework that will give Ghanaians the platform to be abreast of happenings in government agencies in the country.

The project, which is under the auspices of the Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development (MLGRD), is primarily to halt the arbitrary award of contracts and to help the government in the fight against corruption in the country. At the launch of the system, the Minister of Local Government and Rural Development, Mr Kwasi Opong Fosu, said the enterprise was an initiative of President Mahama to bring transparency and accountability to the planning, contracting, procurement, monitoring and implementation processes of public projects and programmes.

The motive for the establishment of the contract portal, the minister added, was to ensure proletarian democracy, hence the need to engage the public to influence decision making by the government. “Citizens of Ghana want transparency and accountability and expect their government to involve them in decision making,” he said.

The MLGRD, he said, had decided to embark on an open government initiative to meet its mandate for good local governance and grassroots democracy.
I truly hope this turns out to be more robust than the kick-the-can approach it seems at first blush. Government itself must take the lead in policing and scrutinizing contract awards, and cannot abandon responsibility to a public process. As we see in Guam, even a full court coverage by the press does not seem to stem the flow of procurement train wrecks.

Friday, October 25, 2013

Debarring contractors takes root in UK

No procurement regime will ever be fully effective if it does not ride herd on wayward contractors.

In the US, there is a quaint notion that contractors will be suspended or debarred from government contracting work if they get caught engaging in contract fraud or rendering unsatisfactory performance.

 It is quaint because that penalty is most often applied to small contractors, and way too often ignored when it comes to the "too big to flail" naughty big boys of government contractors.

If they will not be suspended or debarred, there must be some other penalty applied to deter wayward performance to prevent government contracting from being a mockery of procurement principles.

Boss of Serco resigns in desperate bid to help group secure lucrative government work in the future
The security firm has been rocked by fraud allegations over a number of its contracts with the Ministry of Justice. A probe into its entire portfolio of government work is due to finish next month. Ministers said they would not give any fresh contracts to Serco until the review was completed.
Serco chief's exit shows companies need to think before they boast
Nobody should doubt Hyman's intention to run a decent company. The question is whether, when you've got 120,000 employees, any services business can hope to avoid regular catastrophes.
At Serco, of course, there have been more than a few recently. Allegations of overcharging on a tagging contract and dodgy record-keeping when escorting prisoners are the biggest issues. But there was also a damning official report on the state of Serco-operated Thameside prison. And "substandard" was the public accounts committee verdict on the company's operation of out-of-hours GP services in Cornwall.

Friday, August 23, 2013

Poppycock

There is an element of the press that feeds on creating, not uncovering, creating controversy. An easy and perennial target is bid protests, such as this:

Bid protests are slowing down military procurements
The appeals process for bids is slowing down military procurement and the number of bid protests is rising, according to a report by Federal Times.

Click here for full report from Federal Times.
I bothered to click the link and read the source material, which you should always do, especially with the posts on this blawg.

In fact, I read it and posted it when it first came out some time ago. See What has taken this so long to happen. How can protests slow down the process when the process is being planned to accommodate them? As the source article stated,
They have become so common that agencies expect them, build them into their contracting timelines, and regularly train their procurement staffs on how to minimize them, according to agency officials and outside experts.

“We build time in our procurement now for protests. We know we are going to get protested,” said Mary Davie, assistant commissioner of the Office of Integrated Technology Services at the General Services Administration, at a July 11 conference.

Joe Jordan, administrator for federal procurement policy at the Office of Management and Budget, said bid protests are an important part of the acquisition process, but too many of them can gum up the process. OMB encourages agencies to explain clearly to companies why they lost a competition and why an award went to a particular company. By sharing more information, agencies can reduce bid protests, Jordan said.

GSA Administrator Dan Tangherlini said the agency is working to minimize bid protests by reviewing its contracting process and identifying opportunities to train employees on comprehensive contracting requirements.

GSA also has lengthened its lead time on certain contracts to make sure the agency has done its due diligence but balances that with keeping up a timely contracting process.
In contrast to the poppycock above, consider this post: Protests: Rare and worth it
Steven Maser, Professor of Public Management and Public Policy, recently authored a study funded by the Acquisition Research Program at the Naval Postgraduate School and distributed for practitioners through the IBM Center for the Business of Government. It evaluated the way government agencies manage the bidding process when they purchase products or services.

What Maser found was eye-opening. In the past few years the number of bid protests, where a rejected bidder complains to the Government Accountability Office, has been on the rise although the total number is small. Maser found that in most cases bid protests were not sustained.

However, bid protests aren’t necessarily bad. Maser argues that they provide an important benchmark. "In general, the system serves a very good purpose of helping the government actually police itself," he said during an interview with Federal News Radio. The study notes that the more transparency and disclosure that’s built into the process, the less likely a bid protest will occur. It recommends that agencies should simplify the requirements they create for the products and services they need and adequately train staff members who will evaluate proposals.

The percentage of contracts that spark protests is also comparatively small, while the overall impact of the protest procedure is healthy, according to Dan Gordon, the former Obama administration head of the Office of Federal Procurement Policy and now associate dean for government procurement law studies at George Washington University Law School.

In an article set for publication this spring in the Public Contract Law Journal, a copy of which was provided to Government Executive, Gordon wrote that “there exist a number of misperceptions concerning bid protest statistics that deserve attention, because these misperceptions can taint judgments about the benefits and costs of protests. In particular, even people quite familiar with the federal acquisition system often believe that protests are more common than they really are, and they believe, inaccurately, that protesters use the protest process as a business tactic to obtain contracts from the government.”
And this: Doth we protest too much? Methinks not
There’s little the agencies can do to prevent the automatic, 100-day work delays triggered by protests to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, which arbitrates contract disputes. As a last-ditch effort, the government can supersede the stays with an override, which requires the officials to justify an urgent need or show that it’s in the best interest of U.S. taxpayers.

There have been no significant changes to the automatic delays in almost two decades. Congress in 2009 requested that GAO assess whether frivolous protests were rising. The office responded that attempts to discourage those challenges might backfire by adding costs and deterring “good-faith protests.”

Protests can serve as checks and balances to a sometimes opaque and flawed contracting process.

Sue Payton, who was assistant secretary for acquisition at the Air Force from 2006 to 2009, said she used to build potential delays into the timeline for planning contracts. “Getting the requirements right up front saves you from protest hell,” Payton said.

The most effective way of avoiding challenges, though, is making sure the contracting process is fair and complete from beginning to end, according to current and former military officials. The Army tries to deter protests with contract solicitations that are “thoroughly scrubbed” to make sure they are clear, concise and compliant with federal regulations, said Matthew Bourke, a spokesman for the service. It also works to keep “a very open dialog with our industry partners,” he said in an e-mail.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Transparency is an essential but not adequate factor in mitigating corrupt procurement

Anybody writing a blog for a "Sunlight Foundation" must know a thing or two about, and have a predilection for, transparency. So when they conclude that transparency is not a total cure for corrupt procurement practices, you have to pay attention. Why not?

Case Study: Public Procurement in the Slovak Republic
Transparency and open data policies and initiatives have reached a state of maturity where it is crucial for us to evaluate them to learn what works, what doesn’t and why. Transparency is not likely to be a cure-all, but we think it is a cure-some; so, we need to figure out where and how it should be best applied. As part of that process, we have been conducting a series of in-depth case studies on the impact of technology enabled transparency policies around the world. Our initial case studies look at transparency in public procurement and we have chosen four countries to study. This analysis discusses our findings about public procurement disclosure by the Slovakian government.

Corruption in public procurement in Slovakia has been a long-standing problem. By 2010, immediately prior to the reforms studied here, businesspeople and entrepreneurs listed corruption as the number one barrier to doing business in Slovakia according to a survey conducted by the Slovakian Business Alliance.

However, according to Juraj Nemec, a Czech economist at Masaryk University who studies public procurement in Slovakia, the actual decision making process followed by procurement authorities has never been the primary locus of corruption. Manipulation of public procurement has tended to occur either before or after the awarding of the bid, rather than during the decision process itself, which is heavily regulated.

Prior to the submission of bids, procuring authorities can limit competition and manipulate the results of the tender process by custom tailoring a contract or setting unreasonable conditions on who can submit a bid in the first place. Concern over manipulating procurement outcomes by setting conditions prior to tendering was widely shared amongst our interview subjects. Gabriel Sipos, the Director of Transparency International Slovakia, expanded on this point.

In Slovakia there is a big problem that some participants are excluded from tenders because the conditions of participating in the tender are illogical or irrational. For example they need to submit documents proving their experience in fields which are not directly connected to the award itself. One example would be when the state in Slovakia once wanted to create a website. One of the requirements on the tender participants was that the company needed to have experience in taking photographs from a plane.
[One Guam bid recently raised eyebrows when it required that a manufacturer of a firetruck have at least 2 manufacturing facilities in the US. The Slovaks did not invent that little charade.]

Our interview subjects also highlighted the problem of public procurement manipulation during the contract management phase. This form of manipulation occurs through not fully enforcing contracts, or through various addendum, amendments and changes to the contract. Prior to reforms, it was possible for this to result in the final contract differing significantly from the bid accepted during tendering.

There have been three major changes to public procurement since 2010 in Slovakia: 1) the introduction of e-procurement, in which dissemination of tenders, tender documents, the submission of bids and the publication of notification of awards is done publicly through a single portal; 2) the introduction of reverse auction mechanisms for procuring goods and services; and 3) the mandatory publication of all public contracts on a centralized online government contract repository.

There was wide agreement amongst all interviewees that the central contract repository is immensely useful. Peter Kunder, data analyst at Fair Play Alliance, summarized the general view: “the central repository of contracts is a big help to us.” In particular, the central contract repository has made post tender procurement manipulation more observable, and enabled much greater public participation in uncovering suspect procurements.

Gabriel Sipos noted that all of the newly available data enables a different kind of oversight from that made possible by FOI. The data makes it possible “to compare who is a better contractor, and what kind of supplier is giving the government the best deal.“ Not only are these high level comparisons now possible, “there are other kinds of data that are not necessarily related to procurement that you can connect with [the procurement data]. The company register gives you information about the owners so you can tie the tender results to the owners so you can see if some cities or government institutions are buying from only some companies and you can try to track if it is donor related or these guys are friends or maybe somebody worked in that company before and now he is a purchaser. You can look at those links…You can connect it to other data.”

The widespread publication of procurement data online has fundamentally reshaped the civil sector and media oversight ecosystem. The value of the change from reactive publication of information in response to FOI requests to default publication of all materials should not be underestimated.

The availability of the data online in an easily digestible form, through the Open Public Procurement Portal, has also changed the character of who brings suspect tenders to the attention of journalists and researchers. Before the reforms, leakers or whistleblowers had to alert journalists or watchdogs of suspicious proceedings. Once alerted a reporter or researcher would then file FOI requests. In these circumstances corruption could only be exposed from within: “someone would have to know that something wrong was going on and try to get that information from the public body.” ) According to Adam Valček, “Previously, only a few people have read the contract, because contracts were unavailable.” As a result, “Most of the tips came from the interior of authorities.” Now, it is possible for journalists and CSOs to proactively monitor procurement and highlight suspicious cases.

These lower barriers have also made a difference for participants in the business community. Robert Kicina noted that the only way to discover tender restriction manipulation is through public control and access to tenders. According to him, it is now easy for competitors to “look this up and send it to the media. This is the only mechanism that works in Slovakia…It is used by entrepreneurs to protect themselves from unfair competition and unfair procurement.“
This is a variant on what I call the outsourcing of policing of the procurement system. My reference point for that claim is a robust review system, in which competitors are allowed if not encouraged to blow the whistle on questionable procurement practices through a protest system that responds to the protest without favor and has teeth to sanction or change the wayward behavior. In the Slovak system, it seems, the public is empowered to perform that role. In contrast, the protest system of the ABA Model Procurement Code and the Federal contracting regime prevents the public from direct policing; it requires that protestors must be "aggrieved" or have some kind of "economic interest". Public interest, taxpayer concerns, do not pass standing muster.

For the public protest system to work effectively, there must be a particularly robust independent news reporting regime and an enforceable right of free speech. And a people with backbone to stand up and be counted upon to demand accountability from their government. That is not found in a people who continually elect the same old faces. Transparency is lost on people who have long ago ceased to be surprised -- and outraged to action.

Monday, August 5, 2013

The good, the bad and the corrupt-ish

Taiwan Is Angry But Is It Also Corrupt?
Proudly democratic Taiwan with the world’s 26th largest economy is demanding that the graft-detection group Transparency International do a recount after placing it on the NGO's corruption list. It has also sent the Berlin-based NGO two letters of protest. But Transparency International, which calls its barometer the biggest ever survey on global public opinion on corruption, says it stands by its findings and has no plans to scrap or redo its research on graft in Taiwan.

The standoff between Taiwan and Transparency International leaves open the question of how corrupt this global exporter in the West Pacific really is. Public records laws let the public see a lot of government in action. The news media have ample freedom. No one is charging the government with systematically stealing wads of public money to spend on itself. Taiwan’s leaders are no African kleptocrats.

At the same time, despite the liberal democratic reforms put in motion since martial law was lifted in 1987, Taiwan is hardly free of corruption. Based on local news reports and discussions with lawyers, it’s safe to call payoffs and unholy alliances core part of government business. Government procurement is considered shady. And it’s widely suspected that contractors pay officials under the table and that some don’t even need contracts.

Some projects are so “off the wall” that the public must imagine a hidden financial motive, says Robin Winkler, who founded his Taipei-based law firm in 2002. He says lawmakers may also raise construction bid prices to get more from themselves and others in their camp.

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

What's the point of having rules?

Out of Singapore, we have this globally recurring theme:

Procurement lapses due to individual officers' failure to follow rules: MOF
The Auditor-General's report scrutinized the expenditure of government ministries and statutory boards for the last financial year and was released on Wednesday. Several ministries were cited for various oversights.
[The StraitsTimes reported, For instance, the Media Development Authority negotiated with a vendor for a revised proposal to organise the $4.57 million Film Festival. This was after the request for proposal exercise had closed, and contravened government rules. Another tender by Republic Polytechnic was not conducted in an open and fair manner, Auditor-General Willie Tan said. The tender was for a $19.14 million project to develop an integrated academic system."]

The Ministry of Finance said it has reminded all permanent secretaries and heads of government agencies to pay close attention to procurement issues.

Government agencies are also urged to undertake regular reviews of procurement processes and ensure vigilant supervision throughout all stages of the procurement process.

The ministry stressed that it is essential that the public service and its officers remain fully accountable for the use of public funds and uphold the integrity of public procurement.

To further strengthen government procurement as a whole, the ministry said it has already stepped up the training of public officers, as well as requiring all agencies to conduct regular internal audits to provide an independent check.

Work is also in progress to develop a procurement specialist track, with professional development opportunities and proper career pathways.

MOF explained that the procurement specialist track will help professionalise the practice of procurement by giving officers greater recognition and more opportunities to develop deep skills and knowledge.

The ministry said while it cannot expect to be able to completely eliminate lapses in a system with over 80,000 tenders and quotations annually, the public service is committed to take every effort to avoid them or promptly rectify them when they are detected.

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Of foxes and hen houses

Conflict of interest in $4 billion government minority program
The conflict in the federal Department of Transportation’s program, which is administered by each of the states, occurs because civil rights personnel with an explicit mission to expand the number of minority contractors and the amount of taxpayer dollars awarded to them are the same people tasked with policing and banishing the bad actors.

An audit last month of Minnesota’s program by state investigators illustrates the typical setup.

“One task of the Office of Civil Rights is to monitor the companies in the [Disadvantaged Business Enterprise] pool for those firms who no longer qualify as a DBE company. The other task of this office is to grow the pool and increase participation within the pool. This clearly is a conflict of interest,” the audit said. Companies “eventually earn enough money to be eliminated from the DBE pool.”

“However, it is those companies that aid MnDOT in reaching its participation goal. Audit has found several companies that no longer meet the DBE requirements.”

Further, the minority office’s specialists had neither the “technical knowledge” nor “level of effort” to properly set goals, and they could provide no documentation for the percentage of contracting dollars it said were given to minority firms, or duplicate its calculations. And “our review found little to no monitoring or enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance.”

As a Transportation Department inspector general’s report put it last month, states “place more emphasis on getting firms certified as” disadvantaged rather than keeping track of the work they do. The report said the Office of Civil Rights is responsible for certification, appeals and coordination of enforcement.

In Maryland, the same office that oversees federal minority contracts also runs a parallel program with even laxer restrictions to disburse state money to contractors. Last month, the governor's office announced it was raising that percentage from 25 percent to 29 percent, one of the highest in the nation.

Maryland’s minority contracting program differs from comparable programs in that it would rather give a contract to a black businessman from out of state than a taxpaying resident, with no requirement that participants in its preference program be based in the jurisdiction.

Read more: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/jun/9/conflict-interest-4-billion-government-minority-pr/?utm_source=RSS_Feed&utm_medium=RSS#ixzz2VpbDjdvt Follow us: @washtimes on Twitter


Saturday, March 16, 2013

Can stand some improvement - Iowa, USA

State procurement chief concedes ‘lax’ enforcement of bid process rules
After cancelling three bid requests because of questions about the irregularities, the director of the Iowa Department of Administrative Services conceded to lawmakers Wednesday the process “can stand some improvement.”

Among the concerns prompting Carroll’s cancellation of the bid process were complaints from state legislators and law enforcement radio vendors that bid requests for communication radios for various state agencies have been intentionally uncompetitive with unusually exacting specifications.

Too often, he said, vendors approach employees in agencies in the process of buying goods or services in attempts to gain information that would improve their chances of winning bids. So he plans to enforce the prohibition against communication between vendors and any state employees other than the designated procurement officers.

The policy applies to communication from lobbyists, lawmakers and vendors to state employees, Carroll said. Even when the questions come from lawmakers, they can be traced back to vendors, he said.

At the same time, Carroll will institute a process to allow vendors to have anonymous communication with DAS internal auditors. That communication would be made public, but without the vendor’s identity attached.

Also, there will be a two-week protest period for vendors to raise questions about the vendor-neutrality of requests for proposals or the procurement process. That protest period will occur before the contract awarded, rather than after, Carroll said.

Chairwoman Sen. Janet Petersen, D-Des Moines, asked for more information about conflict of interest policies to prevent someone from leaving state employment to work for bidding on a state contract.

“I think Oversight would be interested in putting stronger fences around that,” she told Carroll.
I don't know. These seem like such basic matters that I suspect there would be quite a bit of more room for improvement.

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Protests: Rare and worth it

You will gain more by reading the linked articles than accepting this rendition at face value.

Steven Maser Authors Study on the Federal Bidding Process
Steven Maser, Professor of Public Management and Public Policy, recently authored a study funded by the Acquisition Research Program at the Naval Postgraduate School and distributed for practitioners through the IBM Center for the Business of Government. It evaluated the way government agencies manage the bidding process when they purchase products or services.

What Maser found was eye-opening. In the past few years the number of bid protests, where a rejected bidder complains to the Government Accountability Office, has been on the rise although the total number is small. Maser found that in most cases bid protests were not sustained.

However, bid protests aren’t necessarily bad. Maser argues that they provide an important benchmark. "In general, the system serves a very good purpose of helping the government actually police itself," he said during an interview with Federal News Radio. The study notes that the more transparency and disclosure that’s built into the process, the less likely a bid protest will occur. It recommends that agencies should simplify the requirements they create for the products and services they need and adequately train staff members who will evaluate proposals.


Bid Protests Are Worth Their Costs, Ex-Procurement Chief Says>
Contractors on the losing side of a competitive bidding who protest to the Government Accountability Office do not hurt or game the procurement system as some critics allege, says a forthcoming study.

The percentage of contracts that spark protests is also comparatively small, while the overall impact of the protest procedure is healthy, according to Dan Gordon, the former Obama administration head of the Office of Federal Procurement Policy and now associate dean for government procurement law studies at George Washington University Law School.

In an article set for publication this spring in the Public Contract Law Journal, a copy of which was provided to Government Executive, Gordon wrote that “there exist a number of misperceptions concerning bid protest statistics that deserve attention, because these misperceptions can taint judgments about the benefits and costs of protests. In particular, even people quite familiar with the federal acquisition system often believe that protests are more common than they really are, and they believe, inaccurately, that protesters use the protest process as a business tactic to obtain contracts from the government.”

Because of the difficulty of knowing precisely how many contracts the federal government awards each year, the reports of protest to GAO -- which reported 2,353 in fiscal 2011 -- are actually overstated, Gordon says. “Between approximately 99.3 percent and 99.5 percent of procurements were not protested,” even though the trend since the 1990s has been upward. That’s because of increases in procurement spending, the article says.

“It is, of course, true that very high-dollar procurements are much more likely to be protested: the higher the dollar value, the greater the likelihood of a protest,” he said. “For a company that loses the competition for a $100 million contract, with all the bid and proposal costs that competing entails, the additional cost of filing a protest may seem minimal, so that filing a protest can be very tempting.”

Of protests making it through the full GAO process in fiscal 2010, only a handful succeeded in winning the contract, according to Gordon’s calculations.

Overall, Gordon finds the bid protest process to be positive for the procurement system, citing several advantages:

>Protests introduce a relatively low-cost form of accountability into acquisition systems by providing disgruntled participants a forum for airing their complaints;
>They can increase potential bidders’ confidence in the integrity of the procurement process if the GAO is directly responsive to participants’ complaints, leading more players to participate;
>Protests can increase the public’s confidence in the integrity of the public procurement process; --The known availability of the protest avenue empowers those in contracting agencies who face pressure to act improperly;
>Protest decisions made public provide a high level of transparency into what is happening in the federal procurement system; and
>Protests provide guidance.
Bid protesting system helps agencies police themselves
It's nothing personal, but bid protests are one way of keeping the federal procurement system honest. Congress and the Government Accountability Office have been encouraging greater transparency in contracting. One way of doing that is giving the unsuccessful bidder the opportunity for a debriefing, in which the contracting agency describes how the bidder failed to secure the contract and how they could be more successful in the future.

"What the agencies have some fear of is the more they disclose, the more a company or an attorney for that company will find a basis for a bid protest."

According to Maser, if agencies were more open at the beginning of the bidding process, the likelihood of a bid protest could be reduced. "But again, there's some risk that's inherent in this that they'll never be completely eliminated," he said.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

"Someone will be going to jail"

When the US Government passed its American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, at about the same time there was a massive uptick in local spending as the US pivoted its attention to the Central Pacific, a friend of mine noted there will be a tsunami of money coming in. The honey will attract flies. And it will have to be spent in a hurry and by people not well accustomed to monitoring the acquisition and administration of contracts in the best of times. "Someone will be going to jail", he told me. Well, his prediction may become reality if charges revealed today stick.

GWA contractor accused of filching $118K fed funding
A CONTRACTOR for the Guam Waterworks Authority is being sued in federal court for allegedly submitting false claims in order to obtain a reimbursement worth nearly $118,000 in American Recovery and Reinvestment Act funds from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

A civil suit filed by the U.S. Attorney’s Office on behalf of the USEPA was filed Wednesday in District Court of Guam against GRH Technologies Construction Co. Ltd. and its first director, treasurer and company stockholder, Chen Pei Su.

According to the complaint, GRH entered into a contract with GWA in January 2009 to provide services including leak detection, pipeline, location, mapping, leak control analysis, and related training.

GRH was to complete work in three phases under the contract, and was required to “provide all leak detection equipment, and that the equipment ‘be new ... and based on the most updated state of the art technology,’ and for the equipment to be transferred to GWA at the end of the contract,” court documents state.

USEPA awarded GWA more than $2 million in ARRA funds for Phase II and part of Phase II of the GRH contract.

In June 2011, court documents state, Su submitted a reimbursement request to GRH for $117,912 related to the purchase of leak detection equipment from Great Harvest Ltd., a Taiwan-based company.
But this contract was not being administered locally. Federal funds have federal requirements and accountability that is enforced.
As part of the process, GWA reviews the reimbursement request for approval and once approved, forwards a request to USEPA for final review and approval. If approved, USEPA uses ARRA funds to complete the reimbursement to GRH.

GWA had approved and forwarded the GRH reimbursement request to USEPA which subsequently approved the request and reimbursed the $117,912 to GRH, court documents state.

However, when GWA requested Su and GRH President David Lei to provide a copy of the GRH check to Great Harvest Ltd., as well as itemized receipts, neither was able to provide such documentation.

Because GRH was unable to provide evidence of its payment to Great Harvest in the amount of $117,912 to USEPA, the government believes they submitted a false claim in order to pocket the $117,912.

The government is seeking a court judgment against GRH for “triple the damages” plus penalties per violation, or as an alternative, recovery of all payments mistakenly paid and other such costs.
It is interesting that a recent Guam Office of Public Accountancy report found that the local procurement staff proved quite effective in spending and monitoring federal funds, but woeful when it came to spending and monitoring its own funds. There's nothing like having a cop that won't look the other way standing over your shoulder.

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

U. of I.'s C. of I.

When it comes down to conflicts of interests, in regimes with fairly effective enforcement regimes, the most critical element is the appearance of impropriety. To avoid the build up of distrust in the integrity of the system, not only must actual conflict be dealt with, but as important, the appearance of favoritism.

'Conflicted' contract may be rebid
Under pressure from state authorities, the University of Illinois plans to rebid a multimillion-dollar contract with BLDD Architects of Champaign because of concerns about a potential conflict of interest, Chancellor Phyllis Wise said Monday. "I don't think there was a conflict of interest," Wise told The News-Gazette on Monday.

But she added, "We will rebid it (the contract). And it will cause a significant delay in the renovation of the Natural History Building, but it probably is wise to rebid it."

At issue: Jill Maxey, UI associate director of planning in Facilities and Services, who supervises some aspects of campus construction projects, is married to Bruce Maxey, who works at BLDD and owns a 8.9 percent share of the firm. Jill Maxey is also a former BLDD employee.

The Natural History Building was initially scheduled to reopen by fall 2015, but that's already been pushed back to winter break of 2015, and any further delays mean the building wouldn't be available until the summer of 2016. The total cost of a 12-month delay would top $1.1 million, the university said.

BLDD disclosed the relationship, as required under state law. And the state's chief procurement officer for higher education, Ben Bagby, last month refused to void the contract, saying he found no evidence that the potential conflict resulted in any improper actions, documents show.

A state law that took effect in July 2010 requires that when a potential conflict of interest is identified or "reasonably suspected," the state chief procurement officer must send the contract to the Procurement Policy Board. The board then recommends whether to allow or void the contract or bid offer, "weighing the best interest of the state of Illinois."

UI officials made a determination in 2010 that notification wasn't required under its interpretation of the new law, according to testimony from a hearing in May prompted by the procurement board's vote.

Assistant Vice President Maxine Sandretto, the UI's state purchasing officer, saw the potential conflict as a "serious concern given the close relationship involved," emails show. But she consulted with the UI's legal department, which advised that the statute didn't apply to Maxey because she did not meet the salary threshold in the state procurement code.

The UI also argued that it had an internal procedure in place to prevent a conflict, as Facilities and Services had set up an informal "firewall" to remove Maxey from the decision-making process if BLDD bid on a project. Therefore, they argued, no potential conflict existed.

But the procurement board said documents and testimony from the hearing revealed several "breaches" in that firewall. Maxey recused herself once BLDD bid on the Natural History project but was later copied on several emails about the scope of the project, before a firm had been chosen.

Also, the employee that Maxey assigned the project to, Anthony Battaglia, testified that he had connections to the firm, playing in a band with some BLDD employees. His wife's brother-in-law works at the firm, documents show. Battaglia testified that he removed himself from the process after the four finalists were chosen.

Bagby conceded in his decision that the university's efforts at the firewall were "weak," adding, "The process was simply lacking." And he said the UI should have submitted the contract for review before it was signed.

Panel again votes to void U. of I. contract over conflict of interest
The two firms that had the second- and third-highest scores during the selection process both agreed to continue what BLDD started with little or no delays, records show.

An official with the firm that came in second place, Chicago-based BauerLatoza, said Tuesday she is glad the contract is getting another look. The firm fell a fraction of a percentage point below BLDD when 34 companies submitted bids in 2010. It told the procurement board that it would take two weeks and no additional costs to get caught up to speed with BLDD's design plans.

"I would like to think we could do something with those two firms that were so closely ranked that would avoid a complete and total rebid," said procurement board member Bill Black, a former Republican state representative from Danville. "I don't want to see this project delayed nine, 10 months, and I don't think we have to."

Sunday, July 15, 2012

US Iraq Reconstruction payments ok, but payment for what?

A large amount of money is at risk all along the procurement trail from the time a "need" is identified to the time it is exhausted by consumption of the goods or services procured. Strict budgeting, planning and management controls are needed to make sure the need is indeed that and properly identified. Competitive oversight via effective protest systems give real time policing of the solicitation process. And accounting and auditing work are meant to control the delivery and payments functions of the contract administration end of the procurement lifecycle.

This is a tale of that last aspect of procurement.

Final Forensic Audit Report of Iraq Reconstruction Funds (SIGIR-12-017)
Public Law 108-106, as amended, requires the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction (SIGIR) to perform forensic audits and issue a final report on all funding appropriated for the relief and reconstruction of Iraq. A forensic audit involves the systematic examination of a program’s internal controls over expenditures and financial data for indications of fraudulent, wasteful, or abusive activities.

This report summarizes the results of SIGIR’s forensic audits and investigations of Iraq reconstruction funds and satisfies the requirement for a final forensic audit report.

SIGIR audits, inspections, and investigations have found serious weaknesses in the government’s controls over Iraq reconstruction funds that put billions of American taxpayer dollars at risk of waste and misappropriation. The precise amount lost to fraud and waste can never be known, but SIGIR believes it is significant. As of June 30, 2012, SIGIR audit reports had questioned $635.8 million in costs, and SIGIR Investigations, working with other agencies, had resulted in $176.84 million in fines, forfeitures, and other monetary results.

SIGIR found few problems in the agencies’ invoice payment processes. SIGIR tested 180,000 DoD Department of Defense), DoS (Department of State) and USAID payment transactions totaling about $40 billion. SIGIR looked for problem transactions such as duplicate payments, payments to fictitious vendors, or inappropriate separation of duties of individuals in the payment process. Overall, SIGIR’s tests found that once invoices were approved for payment, the payments were essentially processed correctly and to valid vendors.

However, because of the internal control weaknesses, government agencies cannot be certain that the payments were for goods and services that (1) were actually received, (2) met contractual specifications, (3) were in accordance with the contract prices, or (4) were competitively priced.

SIGIR audit reports identified internal control weaknesses such as inadequate reviews of contractors’ invoices, insufficient numbers of, or inadequately trained oversight staff, poor inventory controls, high staff turnover, poor recordkeeping, insufficient price competition by subcontractors, and weak oversight of cash disbursements.

For example, SIGIR’s audit of a DoS contract for Iraqi police training program support found that more than $2.5 billion in U.S. funds was vulnerable to fraud and waste as a result of poor DoS oversight. Another SIGIR audit of a DoD contract for warehousing and distribution services found that the contractor’s business systems had not been adequately reviewed. Business system reviews are the government’s primary control to ensure that prices paid are reasonable and allowable.

Weaknesses in internal controls open the door to opportunities for fraud and other illegal activities. As of June 30, 2012, SIGIR investigators, working with other agencies’ investigators, have developed information used to indict 87 individuals and convict 71 individuals for fraudulent activities including bribery, kick-backs, theft of government funds and property, inflated invoices, delivery of insufficient or inferior goods, and bid rigging.

For example, a U.S. Army Captain was convicted of stealing $690,000 intended for security contracts and relief and reconstruction programs. A regional vice president of a logistics company was convicted of a scheme to inflate invoices for military shipments to Baghdad through the firm’s contract. The estimated loss to the U.S. government was approximately $1 million.

Read the full report at the link.

Wednesday, July 4, 2012

Fines for procurement violations

First, in the private sector, fines for procurement violations, at least in the following case, could also be characterized as imposition of liquidated damages. But as the other cases following note, in the public sector, a fine is a penalty paid by the contracting agency. The Public Purse has many pockets, and lifting money from one for another does have real world effects.

Tesco fines suppliers for late deliveries
Retail giant Tesco has imposed a new system of fines on its suppliers for missed or late deliveries which are causing shortages at depots and costing millions in missed sales.

In a letter seen by The Grocer, Tesco has started to charge its suppliers £10 for every case of goods that was either late or missing. According to the retailer its top 40 suppliers had failed to deliver more than £6.2m cases which in lost sales opportunities had cost it £50m.

Suppliers responded to the news, accusing Tesco of acting unfairly and saying that the action could cause some suppliers to go out of business. One supplier told The Grocer, “The sort of sums involved are enough to take a small company down... This sort of approach totally alienates the supply base and it’s going on across the board.

A spokesman for Tesco, responded by saying that the retailer’s approach was commensurate with the problem. “They [the charges] represent reasonable and legitimate compensation due from suppliers for not meeting their contractual obligations,” said a spokesman for Tesco. “The terms are set out in the contractual documentation agreed up front.”

In the public sector context, I have not seen this before. Live and learn:

Demands for three county transport undertakings to pay procurement fines
“There is a justified requirement for business-like behaviour, sound long-term planning and knowledge of the applicable rules and regulations when dealing with large sums of taxpayers’ money. When contracting entities, such as those concerned in these cases, are lacking in these respects and completely fail to subject substantial contracts to competition, there are no guarantees that taxpayers’ money is being used efficiently,” explains Dan Sjöblom, Director-General of the Swedish Competition Authority. The Competition Authority considers that this is serious and urges all those responsible for allocating resources to the procurement function at local and central government authorities to attribute sufficient strategic importance to these functions.
Fines for the Swedish Armed Forces following improper procurement
In an application to the administrative court, the Swedish Competition Authority has demanded that the Swedish Armed Forces pay SEK 270,000 in procurement fines following an illegal direct award of contracts for certain advertising services. Stockholm Administrative Court has now adopted the line of the Competition Authority and has sentenced the Armed Forces to pay the fines sought.

It is now possible for the Competition Authority to present demands requesting an administrative court to impose fines in the event of a breach of the rules. This was achieved in this case.

“I am pleased that the administrative court has taken the line of the Swedish Competition Authority. The procurement rules exist as a guarantee that taxpayers’ money is used in the best and most efficient way possible,” comments Dan Sjöblom, Director-General of the Competition Authority.

“It is good that the new rules and regulations may curb the making of routine contract calls on former suppliers and that such illegal conduct may have repercussions for the authority concerned.”
Norwegian Complaints Board for Public Procurement fines the Oppegard municipality for direct procurement of medical services

Public procurement (Sweden): The Swedish Coast Guard fined for improper procurement
According to the Swedish Procurement Act procurement fines shall not exceed ten percent of the contract value. However, the Court held as an aggravating circumstance that the SCG previously had committed similar errors in its procurement processes. For this reason, in accordance with the SCA´s claim, the Court established procurement fines amounting to SEK 35,000, over nine percent of the contract value. Source: Swedish Competition Authority Press Release 17/02/2012
Martineau: A Guide To The European Public Procurement Rules Note: this is truncated and out of context, so go to the link.
Where the remedy of ineffectiveness is applied the court must also impose a fine. Where a declaration of ineffectiveness is not made for certain specified reasons the court must order that the duration of the contract be shortened and/or impose a fine.

Grounds for ineffectiveness
The three grounds on which a declaration of ineffectiveness may be based are as follows.
Ground 1: Award of a contract without publication of a contract notice where the Regulations require publication
Ground 2: Breach of standstill or suspension provisions
Ground 3: Framework agreements and dynamic purchasing systems

It should be noted than even if “overriding reasons relating to a general interest“ are found to exist, and the contract cannot therefore be declared ineffective, the court must still shorten the duration of the contract and/or impose a fine as described below.

Fines and shortening of the contract duration: If the court makes a declaration of ineffectiveness it must also order the contracting authority to pay a fine. If the court does not make a declaration of ineffectiveness because: (a) although one of the grounds for ineffectiveness exists, there are “overriding reasons relating to a general interest“; or (b) the court finds a breach of the standstill or suspension provisions but no ground for ineffectiveness is raised or the court is not satisfied that one of the grounds applies; then the court must either impose a fine and/or shorten the duration of the contract.

The penalties that the court imposes must be “effective, proportionate and dissuasive”. The court must look at all the relevant factors but is specifically required to take into account the seriousness of the breach, the behaviour of the contracting authority and, if the contract still remains in force, the extent to which it does so.

Thursday, June 28, 2012

New guy on the block in White House Office of Federal Procurement Policy

Procurement chief seeks sharing of contract pricing data, star recruits
His three top priorities are buying smarter, creating effective relationships with government suppliers and developing the acquisition workforce.

By stressing transparency, agencies and contractors can be assured that contract awards are made on “real facts and decision criteria” while curbing waste, fraud and abuse.

“There’s also an oversight component,” he added, describing “timely enforcement against the few bad actors” by making it clear enough cops are on the beat. “Suspension and debarment should not mean flaying in the public square, but should be a deterrent that prevents” bad behavior from the outset, Jordan said.

Equally important is “getting data and aligning incentives” so that agency contracting officers don’t feel they’re being punished when they’re asked for data about whether they got the best price, he said.

His third priority, developing the acquisition workforce, means planning beyond the 36,000 contracting officers (two-thirds of them at the Pentagon) to the broader population of program managers and post-award contract officer representatives. At the White House, “we make it clear that acquisition is not an ancillary function but a core of what we do. People perk up when they see we’re talking about real money,” Jordan added.

Buying smarter means “instead of operating as 130 mid-size entities engaging vendors and one-off awards, we should amp up strategic sourcing in a thoughtful and strategic way that leverages buying power and achieve other goals such as reducing high-risk contracting,” Jordan said. The best model is the General Services Administration’s OS2 Strategic Sourcing vehicle for office supplies, which steers 76 percent of contract dollars to small businesses and is on pace to save $250 million by end of 2013, he said.

Some agencies have so little understanding of what their “sister agencies pay for commodities, it’s shocking,” said Joe Jordan, newly installed administrator of the White House Office of Federal Procurement Policy. The “paucity of pricing data” in one case involving bulk purchases of BlackBerry mobile devices meant a price variance of 100 percent, he said
.