Labels and Tags

Accountability (71) Adequate documentation (7) ADR in procurement (4) Allocation of risks (6) Best interest of government (11) Best practices (19) Best value (15) Bidder prejudice (11) Blanket purchase agreement (1) Bridge contract (2) Bundling (6) Cancellation and rejection (2) Centralized procurement structure (12) Changes during bid process (14) Clarifications vs Discussions (1) Competence (9) Competition vs Efficiency (29) Competitive position (3) Compliance (35) Conflict of interest (32) Contract administration (26) Contract disputes (4) Contract extension or modification (9) Contract formation (1) Contract interpretation (1) Contract terms (3) Contract types (6) Contract vs solicitation dispute (2) Contractor responsibility (20) Conviction (4) Cooperative purchasing (3) Corrective action (1) Cost and pricing (13) Debarment (4) Determinations (8) Determining responsibility (37) Disclosure requirements (7) Discussions during solicitation (10) Disposal of surplus property (3) Effective enforcement requirement (35) Effective procurement management (5) Effective specifications (36) Emergency procurement (14) eProcurement (5) Equitable tolling (2) Evaluation of submissions (22) Fair and equitable treatment (14) Fair and reasonable value (23) Fiscal effect of procurement (14) Frivolous protest (1) Good governance (12) Governmental functions (27) Guam (14) Guam procurement law (12) Improper influence (11) Incumbency (13) Integrity of system (31) Interested party (7) Jurisdiction (1) Justification (1) Life-cycle cost (1) Limits of government contracting (5) Lore vs Law (4) market research (7) Materiality (3) Methods of source selection (33) Mistakes (4) Models of Procurement (1) Needs assessment (11) No harm no foul? (8) Offer & acceptance (1) Other procurement links (14) Outsourcing (34) Past performance (12) Planning policy (34) Politics of procurement (52) PPPs (6) Prequalification (1) Principle of competition (95) Principles of procurement (25) Private vs public contract (17) Procurement authority (5) Procurement controversies series (79) Procurement ethics (19) Procurement fraud (31) Procurement lifecycle (9) Procurement philosophy (17) Procurement procedures (30) Procurement reform (63) Procurement theory (11) Procurement workforce (2) Procurment philosophy (6) Professionalism (17) Protest - formality (2) Protest - timing (12) Protests - general (37) Purposes and policies of procurement (11) Recusal (1) Remedies (17) Requirement for new procurement (4) Resolution of protests (4) Responsiveness (14) Restrictive specifications (5) Review procedures (13) RFQ vs RFP (1) Scope of contract (16) Settlement (2) Social preference provisions (60) Sole source (48) Sovereign immunity (3) Staffing (8) Standard commercial products (3) Standards of review (2) Standing (6) Stays and injunctions (6) Structure of procurement (1) Substantiation (9) Surety (1) Suspension (6) The procurement record (1) The role of price (10) The subject matter of procurement (23) Trade agreements vs procurement (1) Training (33) Transparency (63) Uniformity (6) Unsolicited proposals (3)
Showing posts with label Guam procurement law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Guam procurement law. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 10, 2015

As good as it gets?

Calvo again vetoes procurement reform legislation
Just as he did last year, Governor Eddie Calvo has once again vetoed legislation that would reform Guam's decades-old procurement law. Governor Calvo says the Guam Legislature appears to be responding to pressure from the private sector with this bill adding "Bill 20 will only prolong frivolous protests and potential increased litigation at the expense and detriment of the people."
UPDATE: Another article on this subject has appeared today (March 14, 2015) here.

Wednesday, March 12, 2014

The pot vs. the kettle

One in five businesses think public procurement skills are getting worse
More than 60 per cent of businesses have not seen an improvement in commercial skills in public procurement in the past year, and one in five believes capability has deteriorated.

That’s the results of a survey of CBI members, in which respondents also said improving the public sector’s commercial skills is essential to transforming the procurement process.

CBI added inconsistency across government departments and a short-term approach to commercial contracts are also key concerns amongst businesses.
Sometime last year, I gave a brief presentation to one of the Rotary Clubs on Guam on procurement matters in general. The Rotarians included some of the leaders of the business community, many with more than passing involvement in selling to the government.

I asked for a show of hands to grade Guam's government procurement capability, starting with 'A' down to 'F'.  Overwhelmingly, they rated Guam's government contracting effectiveness an 'F'.

I then asked for a show of hands to grade the private sector's effectiveness with the government contracting system.  The question seemed to unsettle the crowd a bit, and the show of hands going up didn't get much support until down to 'C' and 'D' (but no 'F'). I admired my colleagues for their critical self-examination.

All contracts require (at least) two parties. Failure of the contract formation process, and contract administration, is bound to deteriorate if either or both parties fail to understand their role in that process, whether it is private or public contracting.

Even the government (on Guam and likely elsewhere) seems to recognize that government handling of its contracting does not always go well, let alone ideally. It is also important that the private sector appreciate that they have a role to play in facilitating that process, however.

There are thousands of protests every year in the federal system, as any search of the GAO website will reveal. Far and away, the bulk of them fail to gain traction. Those that succeed reveal flaws in the government's handling of the solicitation. Those that don't often suggest if not reveal a failure on the part of the private sector participants to understand that government contracting is very much unlike private contracting due to the governance strictures associated with expenditure of public funds. 

There are unyielding standards, disclosure requirements, timelines and limited discretion authorities that make government contracting a whole different ball game than the cut and thrust of private contracting.  Contractors should be aware of the difference and the different approaches required for each.

I have been working with Guam Community College to create a Basic Training procurement program. It consists of 4 "modules", each with 18 hours of class time teaching. 

Module 1 is an introduction to procurement, including its nature, principles, fundamentals, and statutory authority and structure. 

Module 2 is an examination of the methods of source selection, including an understanding of principles applicable to specifications, determinations of responsiveness and responsibility and the like; it is very code and regulation focused. 

Module 3 covers the administrative and judicial review processes of the controversies cognizable under Guam procurement law: solicitations and awards, suspensions and debarments, and contract disputes. 

Module 4 deals with the management aspects of government acquisition, from needs assessment and market research to creating audit trails and contract administration and enforcement. At the end, the students have had 72 hours of fairly rigorous exposure to the nuts and bolts of Guam procurement.

I'm told there has been in excess of 150 students have already gone through at least one of the three modules.  Almost all of them have been government employees (albeit with a modicum of legislative incentive).  This program will eventually raise the bar of the government's handling of Guam procurement.

Government contracting would improve significantly more if the private sector took the same interest. It takes two to tango, and practice to keep off the other's toes.

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Running a government like a business

I have started reading James F. Nagle's compendious History of Government Contracting. It's US history through a lens you have never before perceived.

He tells us that until the early 1800's the Americans ran their procurement system like a business. It hired some of the country's most successful and honorable merchants to look after its fiscal needs on essentially a cost-plus agency or contract basis. And it led to favoritism, collusion, over pricing, shoddy contracting and self dealing.

All of which is mere irrelevant backdrop for the following article in today's Guam Pacific Daily News.

Airport chair challenges bid process
Price should be one of the factors in determining who wins a government contract, according to airport board Chairman Michael Ysrael, who yesterday expressed concerns about the way the airport is selecting a company to operate its pay parking lot.

Ysrael expressed concerns as the airport board gave Torres permission to begin negotiating with the highest-rated company for the airport parking lot job -- Pacair Ltd., which already is operating the airport lot, but whose contract is up. Ysrael said in the private sector, if you find two companies interested in working for you, you let them fight it out in order to get the best price.

That's the way the government procurement process works, Executive Manager Mary Torres told airport board members during their meeting yesterday morning.

According to local procurement law, companies that submit proposals for government contracts are rated according to their ability to do the job, and price is negotiated only with the top-rated company. Only if they fail to agree on a price does the government negotiate with the next highest-rated company.

"It is what it is," Torres told the board. She noted there have been times when the airport didn't give a contract to the highest-rated company.

That is about half right.

Under Guam's RFP (request for proposal) procedure, offerors are first ranked qualitatively in descending order from most to least qualified to offer the services sought. Ranking is not based on any consideration of price, qualities of offeror being singularly paramount at that juncture.

But ranking does not determine who wins the contract. Once ranked, negotiations begin with the most qualified offeror to come to agreement on a "fair and reasonable" price. Here other many factors come into play to value the fairness and, separately, reasonableness of the price. General market prices and the offeror's costs and many other factors are considered. Only if the best qualified offeror agrees to the government's assessment of fair and reasonable price does the best qualified get the contract. If that agreement is not reached, then the government goes to the next offeror and starts again.

The part of this story that I find troublesome is that the RFP process is being used to obtain services for the operation of a car park. Guam's RFP process is only meant to be used to obtain "professional" services, which should generally be limited to licensed, traditional professional services.

The Guam Supreme Court has held that the RFP is the wrong method of source selection to use to acquire services for the operations, management and maintenance of a bus mass transit system. The Guam Public Auditor has determined that the RFP process is the wrong way to solicit debt collection services.

If asked, I'd have to say that the services sought here, based only on the information available to me in the news article, should be solicited by competitive sealed bid. But, of course, it is not for me to say.

Guam's RFP process is extensively discussed in the Guam Procurement Process Primer, Article VIII, available free online as mentioned in the top of the side bar in the right column of this blawg.

Sunday, June 19, 2011

Announcing New Version 2.1 of the Guam Procurement Process Primer

To coincide with next weeks' procurement seminars with Prof. Steven Schooner, I have today announced that V2.1 of my Guam Procurement Process Primer is now available for free download via Scribd.Com.

This new version 2.1 updates and expands the Primer since the last release (v2.0) in August 2010.

Just click the link in the top right sidebar, and follow the instructions.

Thursday, June 9, 2011

Then say what you mean

March Hare: `Why is a raven like a writing-desk?'
Alice: 'I believe I can guess that.'

`Do you mean that you think you can find out the answer to it?' said the March Hare.
`Exactly so,' said Alice.
`Then you should say what you mean,' the March Hare went on.
`I do,' Alice hastily replied; `at least--at least I mean what I say--that's the same thing, you know.'
`Not the same thing a bit!' said the Hatter. `You might just as well say that "I see what I eat" is the same thing as "I eat what I see"!'
`You might just as well say,' added the March Hare, `that "I like what I get" is the same thing as "I get what I like"!'
`You might just as well say,' added the Dormouse, who seemed to be talking in his sleep, `that "I breathe when I sleep" is the same thing as "I sleep when I breathe"!'
`It IS the same thing with you,' said the Hatter, and here the conversation dropped, and the party sat silent for a minute, while Alice thought over all she could remember about ravens and writing-desks, which wasn't much.

-- Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland
__________________________________________________


Suppose you have legislation that says, "In the event of A, B, or C, do this ...."

Subsequent legislation is then passed amending the first bit which says, "Notwithstanding any other law, in the event of C plus X, do this other thing...."

Suppose then that you have an 'A' event. Do you use the original legislation or do you use the subsequent one?

Would it make any difference to your decision if you knew in your heart of hearts that the Legislature really meant the subsequent legislation to also apply to 'A' when there was an A plus X event?

That is the question put to the Office of Public Accountability in a recent case. And the Public Auditor ruled, in the event of A plus X, use the subsequent legislation anyway.

This case was very Carroll-esque from the gitgo, from the time the subsequent legislation, Public Law 31-12, was conceived and sprang into being.

PL 31-12 (now codified as 5 GCA § 5425A) was the result of several belated attempts and bills to get a "take the money and run" expedited procurement procedure to exploit the ARRA funds available to Guam. Its final form was dramatically altered from its introduced form, as a review of the legislative file for PL 31-12 (see link above) reveals.

After running through the legislative concrete mixer, the ARRA law (§ 5425A) says the following:

"Notwithstanding any other provision of this Chapter and any rules promulgated therefore, if an actual or non-selected vendor, contractor, or service provider is aggrieved by an award or a contract funded, in whole or in part, by the funds allotted to the Guam Department of Education from the 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA), the procedure for protest outlined in this Section shall apply...."
Now compare that to the original, general "other provision of this Chapter" (§5425):
"Any actual or prospective bidder, offeror, or contractor who may be aggrieved in connection with the method of source selection, solicitation or award of a contract, may protest...."
As you see, the general provision applies to bidders and offerors as well as contractors, in respect of the source selection, solicitation or award of contract. The ARRA provision does not apply to bidders or offerors nor in respect of source selection or solicitation; it applies to contractors and awards and contracts.

Applying the effect of these different provisions, the general provision extends from pre-opening and pre-award issues all the way through the award of the contract to the contractor. The ARRA provision, however, by excluding its application to bidders and offerors or to protests over source selection and solicitation, does not apply to the full extent as does the general protest law; it does not apply to pre-opening and pre-award issues or bidders or offerors.

So, back to the simplified formula above (where A = source selection, B = solicitation and C = award of contract), the general law applies to A, B and C, and the ARRA law only applies to C but only when ARRA funds are used; it does not apply to A or B at all.

In the OPA case, OPA-PA-11-008, the Carroll-esque nature of this story continues.

Using the simple formula I started with, the issue could be framed like this: The general law would say, "in the event of A, B, or C, then do things this way" and the ARRA law would say, "notwithstanding the general law, in the event of C when the contract involves ARRA funds, then do things this way".

In the application of the real law, this formula is applied to the effect that, if you have a complaint with the (A) source selection, (B) solicitation or (C) contract award, protest to the head of the purchasing agency (or Chief Procurement Officer or Director Public Works if applicable) under the general law, but if you have a complaint with the (C) contract award, when ARRA monies are used to pay for that contract, protest to the Public Auditor.

The protester in the OPA case had a pre-opening, pre-award complaint about the solicitation, particularly the bid specification for bonding. Recognizing that the pre-opening condition was not expressly included in the ARRA law, but cautious about the reach of the law, the protester protested to the CPO and the Public Auditor, but not to the head of the purchasing agency, and asked the CPO and Public Auditor to sort things out.

The Public Auditor looked at the matter and essentially said, I know what the law says, but the Legislature intended to grant original protest jurisdiction to our office to allow quick access to the ARRA funding, so we're claiming jurisdiction over the protest, a jurisdiction the office does not have under the general procurement law. The purchasing agency said, that's OK with us, and the protester was just glad to have someone, anyone, deal with it.

The Public Auditor's Decision says point blank,
"[p]ersons aggrieved in connection with DOE contract awards or solicitations involving ARRA funds, in whole or in part, shall submit their protest to the Public Auditor. 5 G.C.A. § 5425A(a))."
Now, go back one last time to look at the actual wording in the general protest provision (§ 5425) and compare it with the ARRA protest provision (§ 5425A). Do you see the word "solicitation" in the general protest provision? Do you see that word anywhere in the ARRA protest provision?

The Public Auditor's analysis and conclusion on the bonding issue was spot on, but should it have any right of jurisdiction to make a decision over the protest?

Only the legislature can grant jurisdiction, and if it has not done so it cannot be granted by agreement nor proclamation. The Legislature, whatever its intent, did not grant jurisdiction over protests related to pre-opening and pre-award solicitation controversies to the Public Auditor. Even the March Hare could have seen that.


Thursday, January 27, 2011

Guam Procurement Reform -- An Approach

Recently, the Guam Business Magazine was kind enough to run an article I wrote for them suggesting a format for reforming the Guam procurement infrastructure.

To me, it seems the approach needs to be global, and the process methodical.

Before I go to this topic, however, I want to repeat "Seven Steps to Better Procurement", attributed to Professor Danielle M. Conway, Michael J. Marks Distinguished Professor of Business Law & Director, University of Hawai`i Procurement Institute:
1. Develop a fulltime, professional procurement staff in all departments: For most staff, state procurement is now an added responsibility to their usual duties.

2. Make salaries of procurement professionals competitive with private industry: You get what you pay for.

3. Recentralize supervision of procurement in the State Procurement Office: Decentralizing, which was meant to expedite the process, resulted in waste and fraud.

4. Remove exemptions from state procurement code: Far from promoting autonomy, granting exemptions from the code to certain agencies exposes them to litigation, waste and fraud.

5. Encourage, rather than discourage, reasonable protests of contract awards: A lively, expeditious protest system is our most effective way to check misconduct and inefficiency in the solicitation process.

6. Educate, educate, educate: And not only about Hawaii procurement laws, but about innovative procurement practices in the federal government and elsewhere. Remain open to novel or mainstream procurement innovations.

7. Invest time and resources in acquisition planning: Up-front planning will make for a smooth process during the formation and administration of a contract.
These are excellent goals and should guide our own efforts here on Guam to make better use of, and get more from, our procurement resources.

There could be many ways to start down the road to Guam procurement reform, but I believe the first two essential steps are institutional. My first priority would be to establish a Guam Procurement Institute, as I've mentioned in a prior post here.

Although of subordinate priority, at the same time I think we need a Guam Procurement Advisory Council. My proposal for that is filled out in the Guam Business Magazine article.

The article I've written is entitled Procurement Reform.

I'd hope those interested would click the link and read the whole article.

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

I've often been asked ...

Most people's first spoken reaction to seeing the Guam Procurement Process Primer is "why did you write this?".

Yeah. Of all things. And to then just give it away.

After all, as I wrote in the Primer,
The author makes no claim to great authority of the subject. He acknowledges willingly that procurement law has been seen to be impenetrably obtuse, stultifyingly boring, and an aggravation to government and private business alike.
Well, in the first place, it could not and would not have been done had it not been for the encouragement of my boss, mentor and friend for almost three decades, Ken Jones. He basically set me free to "clean up this mess."

But I didn't have an idea in mind for doing so until, after delivering a lecture to the Guam Chamber of Commerce's Small Business Committee on procurement law, I found myself in possession of an outline of sorts, and numerous memoranda I had written for myself to deal with the many topics that come up in a procurement protest, when time is short to organize and research.

And then came the challenge. Hammering out details of a settlement of one such procurement dispute with a sympathetic but hard nosed Assistant Attorney General, he asked why was I being so persevering. And I said, because I hoped to get everyone on the same page as to what the law requires so that we don't have to spend so many protests and appeals challenging procurement lore with procurement law.

And he said, with no malice or antagonism, "good luck".

That's the short, prosaic story. The following is more descriptive.

One man's plan to change public procurement by Janjeera Hail
Guam - With the botched John F. Kennedy High School contract dominating headlines, a huge blow has been dealt to public confidence in the Government of Guam's procurement process. With the release of the 2nd Edition of his Guam Procurement Process Primer, John Brown hopes to bring some clarity to local procurement, a process that, time and again, has cost the local community valuable time and money.

After struggling with it himself and finding that many of his colleagues felt the same, he wanted to do something that would bring everyone on the same page. He was approached by the Guam Chamber of Commerce about delivering a lecture, and the Guam Procurement Process Primer was born. "It would be my goal to get everybody on Guam on the same page so we all understood what the law was or pretty much was. And then we could just argue the facts, which is what lawyers tend to do. And that would cut down on a lot of the unnecessary disputes," he explained.

The first version of the Primer was in the form of the first lecture outline. Those 30 pages have grown to nearly 300 hundred in the most recent version. "There's a lot of 'inside baseball knowledge' that lawyers need to know," Brown quipped. "Unfortunately some of that gets kind of technical, but there's a lot of that spoken to in the latest edition."

In the 1980s, Guam adopted the American Bar Association's Model Procurement Code, but left out two parts Brown believes should have been included. The first was a procurement institute, of which Brown said, "[It's] intended to be a place of learning for both the private and public sector and it's not necessarily a place in the sense of bricks and mortar. It's a curricula that could be combined with a UOG course or a GCC course."

The second would be a council - with no independent authority - but the ability to bring knowledge to bear on a problem and recommend solutions. "The advisory council was to be composed of people who really knew what they were talking about who could assimilate the various viewpoints of private-public sector participants on issues of procurement policy and make recommendations to the policy board," he said.

You can also see the video here. (I hope the link works.)

Friday, July 30, 2010

Unreality procurement TV

This story gets a bit personal, not in the sense of my own personal interests, but in the sense that I have become a bit player in a much larger drama. In involves an ongoing bid process that arises from special legislation to authorize an RFP solicitation to design, build, construct, operate, maintain and finance a new high school facility on Guam.

The procurement process has gone through an initial analysis and ranking of acceptable offerors, and negotiation of all terms necessary to render an award and tender a contract to the selected best most qualified offeror. Along the way there have been two protests by two other offerors, and a court appeal by one of them that ended in a technical dismissal, all of which provided important new material for inclusion and discussion in the draft upcoming new version of the Guam Procurement Process Primer.

At this point, the government's retained bond counsel has decided that the law applicable to this one procurement needed to be changed to remove any possibility that the contract, when awarded, could not be terminated or declared null or void. He opined that this was necessary in order to obtain an "unqualified" opinion for the bond that will be used by the selected offeror to be commercially marketable.

There is disagreement whether any other offeror will need such an opinion, but bond council has stated that, in his opinion, and his inside knowledge of details of all the offerors which must remain undisclosed, all offerors are similarly required to obtain such an unqualified opinion to obtain the financing they have proposed in their respective proposals.

The solution proposed by the bond counsel, and embodied in legislation proposed by the Governor, was sent to the Guam legislature with request for enactment. The transmittal letter stated that the legislation would prohibit any protest of the solicitation. Executive branch testimony was to the effect that protests would be allowed and that the sole intent of the legislation was to eliminate the remedy, allowed under Guam law, for a court or other reviewing body to terminate or declare null and void any contract made in consequence of an award.

In this context, and after amendments conforming the language to that sole intent, amongst other matters, the proposed bill was passed.

The up front and personal part of this for your blawger is that he appeared before the legislature and was offered an opportunity to offer suggestions for some of the proposed amendments.

One consequence of his interjection into that process was the following unreal TV footage, and radio interview, links to which, as well as other news articles, follow:



Radio Interview with Travis Coffman on K-57

Lawmakers question new JFK financing

Special Session Considers Governor's Bill To Jump Start JFK Construction

Senators Grill DPW, AG, Auditor Over JFK Procurement

Special session continues on JFK bill

Senators OK bill to fast-track JFK rebuild

Taitague Applauds Passage of JFK Bill

JFK finance bill passed

Monday, July 5, 2010

PDN editorializes about procurement accountability

The Guam Pacific Daily News has helped to keep procurement issues in the limelight in today's Editorial:

Improve: Hold accountable all those who violate procurement laws
An audit report last week showed that the government of Guam continues to fail to follow its own rules and regulations for procurement. This irresponsible practice will continue until elected officials begin holding government employees accountable for these failures.

These procurement problems persist because elected officials have thus far refused to hold the employees responsible for their actions.

But there's nothing inherently wrong with GovGuam's procurement rules and regulations. The problem is that GovGuam employees aren't following those rules and regulations. And, worse yet, elected officials are letting them get away with it by refusing to hold responsible employees accountable for that failure.

This community deserves better. We need to be able to expect that government officials will spend our tax money responsibly and in accordance with its own rules and regulations. That won't happen until and unless our elected officials do their jobs and hold government employees accountable when they don't follow procurement rules and regulations.

See, also : OPA: Procurement rules skipped

Sunday, May 2, 2010

Ratifying illegal contract

It was earlier reported in these "pages" that a procurement controversy on Guam resulted in an Attorney General's opinion to the effect that the government (Port Authority of Guam) had entered into a procurement contract in violation of law.

This post concerns the continuing saga of the events surrounding that controversy, as reported in one article and another Editorial in the Pacific Daily News:

Law ratifies port deal, AG says
A $350,000 port outreach project was procured illegally, according to the attorney general's office, but the island's chief procurement officer recently gave it her approval, citing a procurement law that allows illegal procurements to be ratified after the fact if doing so is "in the best interests of the Territory."

The port board yesterday evening voted to agree with that decision, affirming that the work had been accepted by the port and that the contractor didn't act fraudulently or in bad faith.

According to the law cited by Acfalle in her April 23 memo, illegal government contracts can be ratified and affirmed after the fact if the person awarded the contract "has not acted fraudulently or in bad faith."

"Since (Guam procurement law) provides for remedies after an award where there was no bad faith or fraud committed by either side and affirming the contract would be in the best interest of the Territory. I have affirmed and ratified this purchase order," she wrote in her memo.

In her memo, Acfalle said the vendor had completed the work to the port's satisfaction.
Shame: Government's failure at accountability lets down people of Guam (Editorial)
The Port Authority of Guam's board affirmed there was no fraud or bad faith in a port outreach project that the Office of the Attorney General called illegal. The board's action simply sweeps the issue under the rug.

This is just another part of a continuing process to try to make the controversy surrounding the outreach contract go away and to refuse to hold anyone accountable for what they did wrong.

Exploiting a technicality or loophole doesn't make a wrong right.

COMMENT: I'd like to make a couple of points.

First, on the notion that "the vendor had completed the work to the port's satisfaction". As I recently commented in a post about a New Orleans procurement controversy,
"It seems the oft-used retort to allegations of improper procurement is that the contractor did a damned fine job, so what's the problem? The problem is that the ends are not meant to justify the means. Both must be justified, independently."
If the ends always justified the means, there would be no law and no order.

Second, this "ratification" is interesting both for what it does as well as what it doesn't do. And I'm pretty confident the CPO did not desire either of these things.

What it does do is constitute an admission of "guilt"; that the contract was made in violation of law. Such a ratification can only be made after a determination of a violation of law. By ratifying the contract, the CPO, contrary to all her prior assertions, admits the violation. (5 GCA § 5452.)

What it does not do is actually extricate the government from the illegal contract. That is because no such ratification can be made except in the context of a procurement protest. Ratification is a remedy that flows from a protest decision or decision on appeal of a protest decision. (5 GCA § 5450.) No formal protest or decision occurred. The "ratification", therefore, is ineffective as legal absolution in this case.

The only finding of violation of law came in the form of an Attorney General review and opinion, at the request of the Lt. Governor. As the Official Comment to § 5450 explains, ratification "does not apply to, say, a review by the Attorney General, who determines, in the course of his normal review, that the proposed action would be in violation of law if it were to be made."

If the CPO could avoid all controversies by simply "ratifying" a contract rather than deal with it by protest, the whole review system would come to naught.

Finally, the CPO's mantra was that there was no fraud or bad faith. That is entirely beside the point. Under the ratification law, an illegal contract can be ratified even if the person who got the contract did act fraudulently or in bad faith.

This event is an excellent illustration of the lack of real "remedy" in the procurement law.

Even if a protester is determined to be right and the contract is proven to be illegal, and even if the person who got the contract did so fraudulently, the contract can still be "ratified", leaving neither the protester nor the public in a better-off position.

There will never be accountability until the legislature steps in to demand it with very carefully constructed law. Personally, I would favor such a law, in broad principle, as part of an expert review of the Guam procurement laws and regulations by a broadly represented and knowledgeable Procurement Advisory Council.

Sunday, February 28, 2010

Procurement Controversies -- Guam

Camacho: No intent to break law
"Most of the appeals that we've had are based on lack of documentation and lack of an understanding of the procurement process," said Public Auditor Doris Brooks, whose Office of Public Accountability hears government procurement appeals.

Brooks said she would like the government to eliminate the sole-source procurement process entirely. "We use that too much as a crutch," she said. "Just advertise, and if only one bidder responds, so be it." That way everyone will know the job is available, she said.

Mayors’ deals with vendors clipped
VILLAGE mayors are ranting about a letter from the Department of Administration’s Accounting Office restricting them from making direct payments to vendors.

Public law allows the Mayors Council of Guam to make purchases via direct payment for equipment, supplies or services without having to go through the normal government procurement process if the items cost below $500.

Kathrine B. Kakigi of DOA’s Division of Accounts, in a letter to Angel Sablan, the council’s executive director, reminded mayors “that the intentions of using direct payment requests [are] strictly for emergency procurements, court-ordered payments/assignments and humanitarian assistances. It is not intended for continuous rendered by vendors or the individual.”

Joannie Flores, management analyst for DOA division of accounts, said the restriction has been implemented after it was discovered that some mayors were paying the same vendors $499 each day.

Flores said the mayors in question should have used a purchase order for that vendor. “They’re not following the public law,” she said. “We’re trying to correct it. We do accept direct payments on certain items. We understand if it’s for one day, but not if it happens every day.”

She went on to say that some of the direct payments have been going on for at least two years.

Ordot/Chalan Pago mayor Jessy Gogue took offense at DOA’s statements.

“I really take offense when they say that we don’t understand the law. There’s almost an assertion that we’re taking advantage of the law by making direct payments to vendors and we’re asking for reimbursements we personally assumed,” he said.

“I know that there is a law that talks about emergency procurement but we wouldn’t have the need for any emergency procurement if these vendors would accept our purchase orders or direct payments,” Gogue added.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Procurement Controversies -- Guam

Report says procurement broke Guam law
Governor's Chief of Staff George Bamba and government chief procurement officer Claudia Acfalle broke Guam law when they approved a Port Authority of Guam community outreach program, according to the Guam Office of the Attorney General.

The job needed to go through a separate procurement process, the attorney general's office said, and noted the procurement also appears to violate federal grant regulations.

The governor's office should consider taking "appropriate action" against Bamba and Acfalle, according to the attorney general's office, and Bamba should be "admonished" for allowing a contractor to be paid for a service or product that was not delivered.

AG: Bamba should be admonished
While the AG's Office found that there wasn't a conflict of interest that would constitute ethical violations under the procurement law by Bamba or Port General Manager, Glenn Leon Guerrero.

Chief Deputy Attorney General Phil Tydingco determined that the procurement of the Community Outreach Program by the General Services Agency at the direction of Bamba violated Guam law because the acquisition of the program was beyond the scope of the original procurement of the Port Master Plan and should have been a separate procurement of professional services.

The AG's Office has also recommended that the Office of the Governor consider having procurement training for those staff directly involved with procurement.

AG's review of the Port Authority of Guam procurement process